Here are videos of 22nd March episode of Amul star voice of India Chote Ustad

Chote Ustad Videos – 22nd March episode – Part I

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RSS feed | Trackback URI

502 Comments »

Comment by Ronnie
2008-03-22 23:30:59

Just finished watching MAR 22d episode. I thought Anwesha was fantastic in both songs – to “Kambakth Ishk’ she added a lot of variations to make it more interesting and ‘Dola re dola’ was simply SUPERB in my opinion. Aishwarya’s rendition of ‘Aye re aye re’from Rageela was good although nowhere near the original by Asha specially the lower notes. She sang ‘Bairi piya’ from Devdas soulfully but went off sur at least three times.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Ronnie
2008-03-22 23:32:12

Drama baazi to the extreme by Aishwary’s family in the Mar 22nd episode. Aish calls his dad on the phone and informs him that she is in top 2 and he acts like he is hearing this for the first time. WHAT!!! That means he did not know the results for 24 hours!! We are not stupid people o.k.? Anwesha on the otherhand called her Dad and talked about Jaipur’s 2nd day performances.The whole family is corrupt and into unnecessary DRAMAA BAAZI!

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-23 11:19:32

RONNIE:
YOUR IMAGINATION HAS GONE HAYWIRE. ALL WISHFUL THINKING. IF WISHES WERE HORSES BEGGERS WOULD RIDE.

Comment by Ronnie
2008-03-23 19:12:09

DEVKISHIN,
Like v d are you deaf or blind! What imagination?? Aish talked to her DAD hours later of the first Jaipur episode and both pretended that its NEW NEWS that she is in the finals RIGHT? Anwesha did not tell her father that she is in the finals because he already knew that.Either Aish never botherd to call her DAD (that’s hard to believe) or its all DRAMA BAAZI, plain and simple. It does not take a rocket scientist to figure this out O.K.?

Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-24 06:15:29

i reciprocate what you stated here above-ronnie.even my small 5 year old kid appear more intelligent than you brat.

 
 
 
Comment by Badria
2008-03-23 19:55:07

And you forgot to mention the mother crying and hugging the daughter…..Big time Drama bazz…On the other hand both Anvesha & her mum mentioned Aishwarya…God Bless Anvesha I have a strong feeling Aishwarya will get preference over Anvesha &she’ll win unfairly….I hope to God I am wrong.

Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-24 06:19:04

serial watchers find drama in every thing .not their fault .serials are made for empty upper storey-indivudals.
for badria.

 
 
Comment by M
2008-03-29 18:18:56

Hello,

For me it looked like both the episodes were shot the same evening..did anyone notice the maharani of jaipur was wearing the same saree…only the judges n the contestants changed costumes..

Comment by rohail
2008-03-31 08:39:43

also noticed holi colour on host hair and ear, and on sherya ghosal’s hands.

 
 
 
Comment by gooboo123
2008-03-23 00:35:40

Hello,
Completely agree with your Ronnie… the drama baazi by Aishwaryas family is unnecessary and disgusting to say the least.

I was not impressed by any of Aishwaryas performances. Though she sounded soulful with a very good rounded voice she lacks the finesse and control over her voice which Anwesha has in abundance.

As far as Anwesha is concerned i think she got carried away in the ‘Kambhakt ishq’ where Urmila was dancing along side… also the song is very very difficult…. as it is Asha Bhosale song. I thought that she would have done much better had she not got carried away with the dancing and the crowd jumping up and down. But she pulled her socks in the second song “Dola re Dola” and how well……..She was awesome……..!!!!!

But if there were any critics for Anwesha, they should go into hiding now coz she has answered them by an absolutely awesome performance.
The rendition of “Dola re Dola” was out of this world. There were no mistakes and the variation in the song was amazing.

I cant describe my pleasure in seeing the thumbs up from Kunal ganjawala where he seems to be saying ‘yes’ this is what we expect from anwesha and this will tell what the difference between Anwesha and Aishwarya is. Though Aishwarya deserves to be no. 2 in this show…… it is Anwesha who already is no. 1.

I am sure this episode showed why Anwesha is better than Aishwarya ….. as Urmila pointed out……the emotion and exuberance of song is well depicted by Anwesha.

Hats off Anwesha……!!!
According to me you are the Chhote Ustaad !!!!

Sanjay

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-24 06:23:55

all emotional fools. .instead of concentrating on individual talents they are searching for unknown and unconfirmed emotional content.what mental powers!
for all those who could only see drama-all emotional fools.

 
 
Comment by dr.praveen
2008-03-23 01:56:20

yes.. i also agree with u guyz…the dramabaazi by aishwaryas father was disgusting…..
n coming to the performances….
Anwesha was fantastic in both songs “Kambakth Ishk” and ‘Dola re dola’..she added a lot of variations to make it more interesting…. Aishwarya’s Rageela re was good although nowhere near the original .‘Bairi piya’ was also good but not upto the mark…..
In my opinion..
ANWESHAAAA…………..U R THE BEST !!!!!!!!!!!!!
n
YOU ARE THE CHHOTE USTAAD !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! GOD BLESS YOU !!!

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by v d
2008-03-23 11:27:37

Get you ears checked! Where did you hear Aishwarya`s father`s Dram,abaazi?
CHALU GAADI MAIN CHAD GAYE! FOOL! YOU DON`T EVEN KNOW WHAT OTHERS ARE TALKING ABOUT!
stop this nonsense!You are making a fool of yourself!

Comment by Ronnie
2008-03-23 18:22:00

Drama baazi to the extreme by Aishwary’s family in the Mar 22nd episode. Aish calls his dad on the phone and informs him that she is in top 2 and he acts like he is hearing this for the first time. WHAT!!! That means he did not know the results for 24 hours!! We are not stupid people o.k.? Anwesha on the otherhand called her Dad and talked about Jaipur’s 2nd day performances.The whole family is corrupt and into unnecessary DRAMAA BAAZI!

V d, are you deaf or blind?

 
Comment by dr.praveen
2008-03-24 01:24:06

V D….. U FOOOOOOOL !!!!!!!!! DIDN’T U LISTEN TO AISHWARYA’S FATHER’S WORDS????SHE CALLS HIM N INFORMS THAT SHE IS IN TOP 2 AND HE ACTS LIKE HE IS HEARING THIS FOR THE FIRST TIME….THAT MEANS HE DINT KNOW THE RESULTS FOR 24hrs.. I AM NOT A STUPID LIKE U….OKAY???
DEAF& BLIND VD…….. COME TO ME….I WILL CURE UR DISEASE FREE OF COST….

Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-24 06:28:21

i doubt about your credentials doc. better get your mental powers examined by a qualified neuro physician. you are neurotic.

 
Comment by dr.praveen
2008-03-25 07:28:01

hey DEVKISHIN….. y r u saying like that dude? i dint say anything against ur comments…i jus expressed my opinion.(did u 4get ur comments on 2008-03-23 10:14:26.u said:DO NOT WORRY ABOUT SOMEONES EARS.WE ARE HERE TO EXPRESS OUR VIEWS FREELY RATHER THAN THRUST OUR VIEWS ON OTHERS.
YOU ARE ENTITLED TO YOUR OPINION AND I HAVE EVERY RIGHT TO HOLD ON TO MY VIEWS.then y r saying i’m a neurotic??take it back dude.it’s not at all fair).infact i’m a fan of both aishwarya & anwesha…do u know dat??what i said was:it’s unnecessary to remind her father that she was in top2… that’s it.. i got irritated by vd’s comments(against me)…so i replied him like that…i dint mean that aishwarya should lose the crown…i’ll b happy whoever wins the cup… i think u r gr8 fan of aishwarya..in some of ur comments u said :( on
2008-03-23 11:57:52) “STRANGELY AFTER BHOPAL EPISODE EVERYONE IS ROOTING FOR ANWESHA. WHAT A FICKLE MEMMORY! HOW CAN YOU FORGET SUPERB RENDITION OF AISHWARYA IN DUET QAWAALI?SHE MATCHED NOTE FOR NOTE ALAAP BY ALAAP SUR BY SUR BOTH THE PERFORMERS WERE FULLY TESTED IN THAT QAWAALI AND BOTH WERE THE WINNERS.AMEN!”
dude…u have to remember onething… u should vote them based on the present performance bt not for the old performances..everyone had given their BEST performances at some point…bt whoever sings better than others till the end she/he will win….
like u said: MAY THE BETTER TALENT TRIUMPH.

 
Comment by dr.praveen
2008-03-25 07:37:28

To DEVKISHIN…
LIKE U SAID (ON : 2008-03-23 14:42:08)
It is none of your business to give unsolicited advice to me. What I am doing and why I am doing is entirely my outlook. Your language smacks of your arrogance and superiority complex .Stop using foul language when are communicating with the bloggers. Hope you will not compel me to hit you below the belt.
You are dwelling in fool’s paradise and seeing fools everywhere.
I only request you to desist from personal attacks and behave in a civilised manner on this site. You cannot impose your views on others .Every one in this free democratic country can express his views freely. The right to expression is one of the Fundamental Rights of the citizens of this country under the CONSTITUTION OF INDIA.

SO……DID U GET MY POINT???? TAKE BACK UR WORDS……………

 
Comment by devkishin
2008-03-25 11:40:33

I have highest regards for you Dr Parveen. Whatever was written in comments was solely due to provocative comments addressed to me by gooboo123.
In fact I was bombarded with all sorts of attacks/ insults but I took everything in good humour. I bear no ill will against anyone .If knowingly or unknowingly my comments have hurt the feeling of any individual on this blog I sincerely regret the same and assure you that henceforth no such words will be used in any of my communication whatever may be the provocation.
All the best Doctor.

 
Comment by dr.praveen
2008-03-25 20:25:16

thank u devkishinji…. n all the best to u too…

 
 
 
 
Comment by dr.praveen
2008-03-23 01:57:41

n SHREYA’s performance was also rocking…..

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by devkishin
2008-03-25 11:50:47

extraordinary doctor: she was at her best when she belted out waada raha pyaar se pyaar ka— from film khakee. just watch the video of this song on SmasHits.com. the picturisation of this song is simply superb.

Comment by dr.praveen
2008-03-28 08:50:40

yup…it’s really awesome….

 
 
 
Comment by fairy
2008-03-23 02:04:21

A good episode all in all…..
Urmila exudes a lot of exhuberance in every show she appears which was infectious.
Aishwaryas singing was great at places but not satisfactory at certain places.
Anweshas performance was definitely better than aishwaryas. Her drawback is her voice similarity with shreya so no matter however well she sings ppl are gonna compare her with shreya. But her variations were superb.
Shreyas medley was simply mesmerizing.Out of the world.
Glad that Kunal didnt get much chance to say anything…
Preetham was tolerable.
I loved jaipur and the maharanis quiet grace.
Yaar when will they sing old numbers?????will they ever??

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-23 11:46:42

FAIRY
EVERYONE IS SHOWERING PRAISES ON URMILA.THE STAR ALWAYS DID LIP-SINGING ON TRACKS MOSTLY RECORDED BY ASHA BHOSLE. SHE IS A GOOD ACTRESS BUT NEVER A GOOD SINGER.IN FACT SHE DID BETTER LIP-SINGING ON AISHWARYA’S PERFORMANCE THE VOICE WHICH SUITED HER THE MOST.

Comment by fairy
2008-03-23 23:33:34

devkishinji
hi.thanks for replying to my comment.ive always enjoyed reading your blogs and i think we’re both ardent admirers of shreyas talent.
i commented on urmilas exhuberance by virtue of her presence on shows. shes primarily an actor so lipsync she will. what else can she do……excel at singing she definitely cant!
honestly i ve never thought her to be much of a singer…but shes very sportive and cheerful if nothing else…..coz its never easy to sing in front of established and aspiring singers.shes been quite a good judge on jhalak dikhlaja(dance contest for novices)though.
now even i was wondering why they ve invited her on a talent show of singing….especially when shes not even promoting any movie!
regards
fairy

Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-24 06:37:11

are you related to archana of bangaluru who was a winner in one of the gajji’s show?
if you happen to come to mumbai just bring archana along . archana’s mom and dad were often seen among the audience encouraging their darling and talented daughter.watch all her performances at my residence. shreya however beat her in another competition.
my mob.9819583059

 
 
 
 
Comment by gooboo123
2008-03-23 02:05:07

well said praveen…..coz shreyas performance on bairi piya showed what Aishwarya lacked. Also you could see that Kunal was very reluctant in giving sartaj sarvottam to Aishwarya after “aiye re aiye re”.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-24 06:40:02

imagination is flying in all directions.
shreya-100% perfect -an icon
aishwarya-40%in comparison to shreya-long way to go

 
 
Comment by Martha
2008-03-23 06:01:46

As usual, our little princess rocked. AISHWARYA was a revalation.She is not better then many who have been eliminated. She is surviving only on hype.
ANVESHA WE ARE VOTING FOR YOU!! GO GIRL!!

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-23 11:57:52

MARTHA:
IF YOU ARE SERIOUSLY SUPPORTING ANWESHA START VOTING FOR HER RIGHT NOW LEST SHE LOSES THE RACE.ANWESHA AND AISHWARYA ARE EQUALLY TALENTED FINALISTS. STRANGELY AFTER BHOPAL EPISODE EVERYONE IS ROOTING FOR ANWESHA. WHAT A FICKLE MEMMORY! HOW CAN YOU FORGET SUPERB RENDITION OF AISHWARYA IN DUET QAWAALI?SHE MATCHED NOTE FOR NOTE ALAAP BY ALAAP SUR BY SUR BOTH THE PERFORMERS WERE FULLY TESTED IN THAT QAWAALI AND BOTH WERE THE WINNERS.AMEN!

 
 
Comment by Singh
2008-03-23 06:03:21

I loved Anvesha’s ‘kambakht ishq’. she did it with so much finesse and grace.
Aishwarya’s entire family is into corruption and unease. I hate gajendra for trying to showcase Asihwarya as some priceless commodity.AISHWARYA SICKS.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by v d
2008-03-23 15:42:32

who is this SINGH?
Seems to know Aishwarya`s whole KHANDAAN! why are you just sitting and posting comments? BE A MAN AND GET SOME PROOF!
Without that you know what it looks like- talking nonsense like this? EMPTY POTS ONLY MAKE MORE NOISE!

 
 
Comment by Singh
2008-03-23 06:04:49

In fact, Aishwarya’s entire family knows she will win. Gjaendra, don’t take the public to be fools. everyone except aishwarya’s biased fans knows the truth.
As for DEVSHIKIN, get a reality check buddy. Your ears need to be cleaned. i will finance a free check up for you

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-23 10:14:26

SINGH:ANALYZE PERFORMANCES OF TALENTED TEENS.DO NOT WORRY ABOUT SOMEONES EARS.WE ARE HERE TO EXPRESS OUR VIEWS FREELY RATHER THAN THRUST OUR VIEWS ON OTHERS.
YOU ARE ENTITLED TO YOUR OPINION AND I HAVE EVERY RIGHT TO HOLD ON TO MY VIEWS .
THE FIGHT FOR THE TITLE IS ON. MAY THE BETTER TALENT TRIUMPH.
IF YOU REALLY WANT TO BACK SOMEONE JUST SPEND FEW LACS FOR CASTING VOTES IN FAVOUR OF THE CONTESTANT OF YOUR CHOICE.
NOW ONWARDS IT IS GAME OF MONEY- POWER RATHER THAN TALENT.
THE JUDGES HAD ENOUGH OF ROWDY BEHAVIOUR OF CRITICS.THEY WERE MORE “SINNED AGAINST THAN THEY HAD SINNED”. EVERY TOM DICK AND HARRY JOINED THE GROUP TO CODEMN THE JUDGES WHOSE ONLY FAULT WAS TO CALL SPADE A SPADE.

Comment by sa
2008-03-23 10:59:35

Devikishanji,
There is no point in saying anything to these huge bunch of Biased Fanatics. The so called Great Bengali Culture! If they were even half as cultured as Aishwarya and her family, they would not be saying all these!
This shows very blatantly that this great culture is nothing but a HYPE! They can not appreciate and on top of that they are JEALOUS and all they know is to SLING MUD AT OTHERS who are praised!
Even their favourite Anwesha was wrongly praised so many times earlier in the show but Aishwarya`s fans never did what these bunch of Fanatics are doing!
What CORRUPTION they are talking about?Does any one has any proof?
The great CULTURE they are talking about-Why can`t they understand an overwhelming feeling of a PROUD mother!DID THESE PEOPLE HEAR WHAT AISHWARYA`S FATHER SAID IN THE BIDAAI EPISODE? OR are they Jealous because they can not think so DIFFERENTLY and can GO WITH THE HERD!

Comment by Preet sagar
2008-03-23 17:20:21

Mr SA
you are showing your own uprbringing and culture.Pease stop rascist commenst which only highlight your sick nature. And refrain from making persdonal attacks.
Are you Aishwary’s dad in disguise? Or some relative? Stop being biased and fanatic.
And so what if urmila is not a singer, Abhas is and Abhas told anvesha on friday she is best. this too from an anchor who is supposed to be neutral, but just because of his great love for singing made it public.
Abhas and Abhilasha are in love and i know Abhilasha. Abhas is a good person and appreciates good music

 
Comment by ajay
2008-03-24 00:17:33

For your INFO Urmila sang a beautiful song with ASHA BHONSLE in her new album and she did a very good job.You better check it out before you start babbling anymore!Get the facts right O.K.

 
Comment by ajay
2008-03-24 00:28:55

ABSOLUTELY RIGHT!!

 
Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-24 06:44:18

urmila vs asha bhosle!even australian pacer brett lee has recorded a duet with asha bhosle. this food is for all those who relish it

 
 
Comment by serious
2008-03-23 17:34:35

You youeself called Kunal and Shreya PATHETIC after Prikrtis elimination! Although I agree that judges were just doing their job to let the best contestants go the the finals.

Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-24 06:56:22

i fully agree with you serious all the three judges did a difficult job quite effectively .
they could have been little restained while commenting on prakriti’s performance.
at least you understand the reality;but kindly go through all my comments on judges behaviour viz.viz prakriti if you get time.
the judges were in dilemma over agressive voting by prakriti’s supportes. but they and the director resorted to tactical voting to neuterile the effect of excessive voting and save the best talent for the finals.
happy viewing doc.

 
 
Comment by Sonam
2008-03-23 21:16:23

Looks like Mr. DEVKISHIN is a relative or close friend of Shreya & Ashwariya. He writes so much on Blog & supports judges bahaviour towards Prakriti. He is also very sarcastic in his comments whenever he had praised Prakriti & sometimes with Anwesha.So sad.

Everyone has right to express their opinion & favour their contestants but it looks like DEVKISHIN has very different way.

Good luck to both singers.

Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-24 07:04:33

sonam:
i am only making efforts to save young aishwarya from savage attacks by a section of bloggers. as for as shreya is concerned i hold her in very high esteem as a higly talented and successful singer.i worship music and talent. i would have reacted equally strongly had anwesha been singled out for harsh treatment .aishwarya and anwesha complement eachother
thanks.

 
 
 
 
Comment by Singh
2008-03-23 06:06:07

Aishwarya will neevr be a playback singer. kunal knows it,taht’s why he is grudging towards her. kunal you are right in this. Urmila also stood up for ANVESHA.

GAJENDRA who acres the hell for you and your licking ash’s footstpes

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by sa
2008-03-23 10:31:49

Urmila is not a singer! I wonder what did you feel when a good singer like Abhijit and with him all the 3 Judges and Alkaji also stood up for Aishwarya`s Man Mohana…..!
This is nothing but a biased mind.

Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-23 11:07:48

SA:
ALL GOOD PERFORMANCES OF AISHWARYA HAVE BEEN CONVENIENTLY OVERLOOKED AS YELLOW EYES SEE YELLOW EVERYWHERE.
MORE THE BRICKBATS FOR AISHWARYA BRIGHTER HER CHANCES TO WIN THE CROWN AS THE PUBLIC ALWAYS SUPPORTS THE OPPRESSED .
PRAKRITI WAS CROWNED QUEEN AT JAIPUR ON ACCOUNT OF SYMPATHY VOTE . AISHWARYA IS BEING TREATED QUITE HARSHLY BY ALMOST EVERYONE ON THIS BLOG. ONLY TIME WILL TELL WHO GETS THE PUBLIC SYMPATHY.
ANWESHA I STILL HOLD YOU IN VERY HIGH ESTEEM AND YOU ARE WORTHY OPPONENT OF AISHWARYA .MAY THE BETTER TALENT WIN AND NOT THE MONEY POWER.

Comment by Martha
2008-03-23 17:03:04

You want talent to win and not money power?and yet you are supporting the person embodying money power…how strange.aishwarya is here only because of moeny power. the way gaj highlights her all the time is ridiculous.
Also oppressed and that too for aishwarya? Stop living in dream world

 
 
Comment by moonmoon5
2008-03-23 15:01:39

yes,alka is a singer who is biased about aishwarya,becoz they are from same community and they know each other.
About Abhijit………
poor guy doesn’t have any job in bollywood anymore so he needs to keep gajju happy so that he can come back as a judge in the next voi for the seniors.
Alka gave her that necklace even if she didn’t sing that well becoz it was all pre planned by alka.
don’t you call it favouritism ?????

 
Comment by ajay
2008-03-24 00:33:39

yeah right! She is as much of a singer as Aishwarya if not better. Have you heard her song with ASHA? She is fabulous in it according to Asha herself O.K.?

 
 
Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-24 07:07:55

singh please have some mercy on aishwarya and allow her to become a playback singer as you only can decide in this country who should become playback singer and who does not deserve to be one.

 
 
Comment by maverick
2008-03-23 06:26:07

well…i guess kunal was immatured and shreya appeared as very clever to choose right words. it seems they have got to learn more in future… and adding to the list… starplus messed up the situation…

well… one thing shreya should understand is that any
talent shows competited automatically takes into consideration of various other factors too..or else there would have been zero fan for prakriti and 100% fan for Amisha and no competition…. and no talent shows would have become successful..and she would not have been there commenting..
so in that context there is very big part of Pragrati Giri for the show becoming popular and yes too for finding out shreya as intelligent…

well… in every talent shows we find judges commenting on how to improve over ones singing ability… but here it is found otherwise..and some remarks were were harmful physchologically….

but poor prakriti.. she was hurt and it was worst situation for her during elimination as she wanted but could not cry… well done kunal and shreya…. i just wish that prakriti had quited the show voluntarily..

really.. this talent show has highlighted many things which were not known..

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-23 11:16:10

KUNAL AND SHREYA HAVE COME UP IN LIFE BY THEIR HARD AND DEDICATED WORK. THEY ARE CELEBRITIES IN THEIR OWN FIELD ON ACCOUNT OF THEIR OWN TALENT AND NOT DUE TO ANYONE’S MERCY.
NO PERSONAL ATTACKS ON JUDGES PLEASE . FIRST TRY TO REACH THEIR STATURE IN LIFE BEFORE YOU GET A RIGHT TO ATTACK THEM.

Comment by maverick
2008-03-23 13:18:44

well… comments were made for kunal and shreya based on the conditions that had prevailed and things that were found wanting… and i guess it has nothing to do with who the person is…
and yes of course… in general talent and morality have two different meanings..

 
 
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-23 06:51:19

To-day,we enjoyed the show very much:
sherya’s singing was memorable.
Rajasthan episode is far better than other episode.The guest filmstar,we don’t know but with due apology, she is not good looking and her voice is very rough.The only beautiful lady was the princess dyia ,she looked gorgeous and has good height.shreya looked beautiful.pritam and kunal are ugly as usual.
look forward to delhi episode
best wishes

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Ashish
2008-03-23 07:49:14

Aishwarya for me.Thanks gajji and team for highlighting these two precious pearls

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by v d
2008-03-23 11:50:27

I agree with you.
Aishwarya for me today and always.
Anwesha is only a Hype and Biased Judgements. From first episode these Judges have just praised her even when she was not up to the mark.
I find her very very NASAL, though Shreya did mention it once without cutting marks! She cut Aishwarya`s Flawless Performance of Piya Bole, Piyu Bole saying that she was Nasal!
For me even Aishwarya has been very CONSISTANT but they don`t acknowledge it. And with that she has been very VERSATILE ALSO.
Both the girls are very good and both are winners!

Comment by Rupinder
2008-03-23 16:59:17

Get real your aishwarya is nothing but fake drama and substandard singing.Sonia was much better,and so was jayant.aishwarya is on level with singers like prakrit,mansi and abeer

Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-24 07:10:55

rupinder:dramabaaz sees drama everywhere not your fault you kid .grow up otherwise you will continue to have brains of 3 year old

 
Comment by mmm
2008-03-28 00:38:45

Devkishin,

You have a brain of a monkey to comment like that…even 3 year olds are smarter now a days and know where to say what :)

 
 
 
 
Comment by urvashi
2008-03-23 08:01:28

hey next episode is in delhi………..can anybody tel me hw v cn came to know tht where it is going to happen……bcz v still have no info abt tht….

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-23 11:39:05

URVASHI:
ABHAAS ANNONCED IN 22ND MARCH EPISODE THAT THE FRIDAY’S EPISODE WILL BE HELD AT DELHI

 
 
Comment by Aishwarya
2008-03-23 08:29:50

Aishwarya’s performance has been disappointing in both these episodes. Despite singing most of the intricacies correctly, she failed to maintain her melody during the energetic songs and her variations in tone seemed a bit forced.

Anvesha sang very well but her voice sounded slightly nasal while delivering the high notes of “Dola Re”. Still, she outshone Aishwarya in both the episodes.

It is interesting to see the Judges being so politically correct in their comments to Anvesha and Aishwarya. Probably they don’t want to be accused of partiality. Fancy that, after their remarks to Prakriti!

Shreya and Abhas were brilliant. They should be the Lata Mangeshkar and Manna Dey of the future.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-24 07:13:32

aishwarya condemning another aishwarya!
please donot pass judgement if you are not qualified in this art.

 
 
Comment by APK
2008-03-23 09:52:23

Ash wasn’t at her best in this epsiode..Anwesha at the other end sung both songs beatifuly but she still has to overcome her problem with high notes….shreya was just awesome..and URMILA..what to say about this lady..she is as refreshing as she used to be..full of joy, masti, maza…she is F5 key to me..:D

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by alia
2008-03-23 09:54:18

i dnt fink so bth of dem wer gd wel yh u cn sy anwesha did a lil bit betta tdy bt ystrd dey bth sang superbly nd i read sum 1 tlkin bout d drama den 4 u guyz..alw blmin dez lil kid nd go 4 der singin nt wt der families r lyk do uz agr33 dat aishwarya is a crp singa NO ( if u do den ur complete dnoutz i wnt bother) den…n yer evrytin dat v c is organized by d director of d shw..he tell dem 2 do stuf nt demm..so dnt blme dem 4 it…newy

UZ BTH GT LONG WAY 2 GOOO..! wohay U BTH IN FINALZ..WT ELZ DID U WNT DESNT MATER HUEVA WINZ..I LYK AISHWARYA a bit mre bt yh bth r amazin so all d bstt

PEACE OUT………………….XOXOOXOXOX BLESSS

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by alia
2008-03-23 09:56:16

dnt fink so bth of dem wer gd wel yh u cn sy anwesha did a lil bit betta tdy bt ystrdy dey bth sang superbly nd i read sum 1 tlkin bout d drama den 4 u guyz..alw blmin dez lil kid nd go 4 der singin nt wt der families r lyk do uz agr33 dat aishwarya is a crp singa NO ( if u do den ur complete donutz i wnt evn bother) den…n yer evrytin dat v c is organized by d director of d shw..he tellz dem 2 do stuf nt demm..so dnt blme dem 4 it…newy

UZ BTH GT LONG WAY 2 GOOO..! wohay U BTH IN FINALZ..WT ELZ DID U WNT DESNT MATER HUEVA WINZ..I LYK AISHWARYA a bit mre bt yh bth r amazin so all d bstt

PEACE OUT………………….XOXOOXOXOX BLESSS

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by alia
2008-03-23 10:25:20

-i dnt get dis ..wt do u mean bi biasd ppl hu support aishwarya ourr choice v cn lyk wteva v wnt inih….if u dnt lyk d oda dnt get rude keep it 2 urself bth r deservin das y dey r here n 1 mre thing which is pisin me of..wen aishwarya puts her variation in d sng pppl sy shez a new cummer she shuldnt ply wid d original n wen anwesha duz d sme ur lyk she mde it betta wen aishwaryya did dis be4 ii thought dat went superb memba in himesh’s song..wen she did dat sooo ppl get a lyf kk bth r gd dnt need 2 dis hearten d oda prsn..n newy its nt lyk dey vil b readin dis so goonn..uz lot r so immmature ….flip ske

kk gdluk gain mwa..xxxx

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by alia
2008-03-23 10:26:27

n if er family knwz AISHWRYA wil win gd 4 dem she shuld..so wtt aint lyk shez nt a gd siinga..jus cauz u dnt lyk er dsnt evn mke a bit difference so HU CREZ!

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-23 10:51:10

alia:
please first learn to write in language which can be understood by everyone. could you please tell me the name of your script?

 
 
Comment by alia
2008-03-23 10:29:38

SINGH…wt u on bout…gf if ganjendra duz lik her footstepz bludy lw lyff goon hw bout u go n sing denn..i agr33 anwesha is gd bt so is AISHWARYA ii aint ere 2 fi8 soo..WOTEVA..ppl lyk u dnt mke no diference..SHE WIL DEFO B A PLYBCK SINGA..!!!!

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-24 07:16:25

please stop using sms script on this blog as it is quite irritating. write in simple english whether you know this language or not.
thanks.

 
 
Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-23 10:29:52

IN MY OPINION -YES IN MY OPINION-THE PERFORMANCES OF SINGERS AT JAIPUR -DAY TWO-CAN BE RATED AS UNDER:
1.SHREYA: 100% DAZZLING -OUTSTANDING-HER ONE OF THE BEST
2.ABHAAS: 60% STILL A LONG WAY TO GO-MUCH BELOW HIS CALIBRE.
3.ANWESHA AND AISHWARYA: 40% IN COMPARISON TO SHREYA’S PERFORMANCE. BOTH THE PERFORMERS SOUNDED NOVICES BEFORE THE ICON WHO HAS MASTERED THE ART OF SINGING.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Eva
2008-03-24 12:07:00

Shreya only 100% ? why not 100+…% ? Ha, ha.

Comment by devkishin
2008-03-25 12:54:53

EVA: ANY DOUBT ABOUT 100% DAZZLING PERFORMANCE OF THIS RISING STAR CALLED SHREYA GHOSHAL?
SHE WAS SIMPLY AMAZING-SUPERB- WHEN SHE SANG” WAADA RAHA PYAR SE PYAR KA—”FROM FILM KHAKEE. SHREYA GHOSHAL IS UNDOUBTEDLY ONE OF THE BEST FEMALE SINGERS IN FILMS AT PRESENT.

 
 
 
Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-23 10:47:05

PLEASE DESIST FROM COMMENTIG ON AISHWARYA’S MOTHER’S DRAMABAAZI ETC. IT APPEARS EVERYONE’S IMAGINATION HAS TAKEN TO WINGS AND THEY ARE FLYING INTO THEIR OWN WORLD OF FANTASY. YOU HAVE STARTED IMAGINING THINGS WHEN THERE MAY NOT BE ANYTHING. BY THE WAY DO YOU BELIEVE IN GHOSTS ETC AS SOME OF YOU ARE EXPERIENCING THE INFLUENCE OF SOME UNKNOWN POWER WHICH IS PROMOTING CHANCES OF ONE OF THE CONTESTANTS IN THIS SHOW .
YOUR ARE WATCHING GANJENDRA SING’S SHOW AND AT THE SAME TIME DOUBTING HIS INTEGRITY AND CREDIBILITY. IF YOU HAVE NO FAITH IN IN THIS REALITY SHOW JUST SWITCH OFF YOUR TV SETS AND GO TO SLEEP.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by sa
2008-03-23 11:14:04

DEVIKISHANJI,
I agree with you 100%.
If all these great Anwesha fans think that Aishwarya`s mother is a drama baaz and this was all rona dhona etc… Then i think these people don`t have children or they have no Indian Values. They don`t even deserve to have children if they can not value them.
What to say about a person sitting there without any emotions-feelings-expressions on her face? Statue made of stone?
They just have their Bengali Values-to sling mud on others- never appreciate who are better than them!
THESE ARE SURELY NOT INDIAN CULTURE AND VALUES!
They are mentally SICK and surely need help!
Mr SINGH! give me your e-mail id, so in very near future i will remind you about your Bhavishyavani! Ha! Ha!

Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-23 11:34:03

SA:
AT LAST A SANE VOICE. KEEP IT UP BROTHER. WE LOVE BOTH ANWESHA AND AISHWARYA EQUALLY AS BOTH ARE HIGHLY TALENTED TEENAGERS. MOST OF THE COMMENTATORS HAVE RESORTED TO PERSONAL ATTACKS AND ARE CONDEMNING AISHWARYA HER MOTHER HER FATHER THE GREAT DIRECTOR GAJENDRA SINGH, THE CELEBRITY JUDGES PARTICULARLY KUNAL WHO IS ONE OF THE TOP VOICES IN PLAYBACK SINGING IN BOLLYWOOD. ARE WE HERE TO CONDEMN EVERYONE FOR THE SAKE OF ONE INDIVIDUAL? LET US NOT STOOP SO LOW AND FORGET THAT WE ARE ALL RATIONAL ANIMALS AND NOT ANIMALS.
HOPE AND TRUST BETTER SENSE WILL PREVAIL THE WE WILL INTERACT WITH EACHOTHER IN CONGENIAL ATMOSPHERE.

Comment by gooboo123
2008-03-23 12:09:08

Devkishenji

You are not the webmaster who would cut anyones comments.
You seem to be in the Army …..man !!!
And even if you are ……. Pleassssssssse …… Give me a break.

You seem to keep writing in bold handwriting and when Alia writes in sms language you pass a remark on it as if you were the webmaster.
Do you even know what writing in bold implies ???
Or you are not learned enough for that ?
I guess being Kandivali gujju bhai does not give you that much sense.

You have absolutely no right to cut each and everyones remarks just because you have nothing else to do in life……. !!! It seems you are online and on this website for every minute of the day.

Go home Devkishenji……..your family must be missing you.

Seriously you need to do something worthwhile before you start advising people. As you say Shreya and kunal have done hard work in their life to come this stage and people should not comment on the judges.

If there would have been no comments to be passed your very existence would be in Question.

So go home devi ji and do a bit of exercise… you are becoming a potato couch.

 
Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-23 14:42:08

I think it is not your birth right to express your opinion and gag the viewes of others in free civilized society . Time and again I have been saying that every one has got equal right to hold one’s opinion on any matter in free society .
For your kind information I graduated in Law from Asia’top Law College in Mumbai decades ago. I am also holding degree in Arts from university of Mumbai. I do not believe in blowing my own trumpet and indulging in savage attacks.
It is none of your business to give unsolicited advice to me. What I am doing and why I am doing is entirely my outlook. Your language smacks of your arrogance and superiority complex .Stop using foul language when are communicating with the bloggers. Hope you will not compel me to hit you below the belt.
You are dwelling in fool’s paradise and seeing fools everywhere.
I only request you to desist from personal attacks and behave in a civilised manner on this site. You cannot impose your views on others .Every one in this free democratic country can express his views freely. The right to expression is one of the Fundamental Rights of the citizens of this country under the CONSTITUTION OF INDIA.

 
 
Comment by holymoly
2008-03-23 15:23:51

Oye…sa…people in glass houses do not throw stones…Ask people from around the world which state in India has the worst record of human rights violation and violence against minorities in India…We know about you gujratis where you belong…from the other side of the world…So for the sake of music at least plz stop throwing stones at people of other communities on this forum…Now that you are pointing your finger at the bengali culture…is really outrageous…

Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-24 07:32:05

holymoly -gujarat under narendra modi’s administration has achieved progress in every field and the government of gujarat has bagged the award of-best administered state from the congress government!
if you are really interested in politics just read about the plight of people in different states where they are repeatedly targeted by the locals.
narendra modi is sardar patel of the present era.hindus will disappear from their own country if the leaders like modi are not there to protect the hindu race
modi believes in”live and let live”donot harm hindus in their own motherland or else—

 
Comment by rafisaabkafan
2008-03-24 15:18:57

Devshikin jee, now a new element to your personality– religious fundamentalist? These right-wing people are very dangerous. Stay away from them./ We have seen damage of Modi and now we see another such person in the making-DEVKISHIN.
we do not care about religion like you mr. devkishin we are tolerant and liberal people. So stop making usless comments.

 
 
Comment by munguchungu
2008-03-23 15:40:45

yeah sa. now shove it up.

 
Comment by oops
2008-03-23 16:11:47

@SA & Devikishin,
Who said all Avwesha fans are Bengalis? I for one is not. Nobody is slinging mud they are just expressing what they feel. About DRAMA BAAZI by AISH’s family – there is recorded proof of the Drama Baazi when Aish’s dad acted like he is hearing for the first time, that Aish is in top 2. Aish did not let her father know for hours that she is through to the finals! That’s hard to believe!Pure DRAMA BAAZI.

Comment by mmm
2008-03-23 18:40:06

I agree “oops”… not all supporters are Bengali…I just do not understand the fight between these biased racist people..I mean Mr DEVKISHIN, if you are sooooo EDUCATED…plz…turn the education light bulb in your head and knock some senses. Plz don’t be biased and racist, you are just being close minded.
I like Aish and Anu both. On some parts of Anu she sang nasal…it is true..but come on…they are onlly 13/14 yrs old…still learning…as for aish, I think she should sing variety of songs..she is only singing classical…well, I think the viewers know by now that Aish and Anu both are excellent in classical..If aish keeps singing one type of song…then I would have to say she is not all rounded and in a previous episode Shreya mentioned they are looking for an all-rounder to be the chote ustaad. In that sense, I think Anwesha should be chote ustaad. But if its on classical, I would go for Aish..her voice is really sweet.

In anycase, those were my opinion. And I just want to say that I want to watch a talent show, not a soap opera…so, the less drama the better :) . I could understand aish’s mom’s emotion…I think every mom are proud to have their kids…to every mom, a kid is a jewel. So, some of the drama was unnecessary….

 
Comment by v d
2008-03-24 05:27:59

mmm,
wake up! if you think that Aish sings only one type of songs then, I m sure you are not following the show properly!
about her mother`s so called drama – the way you understand her feelings, i m sure you can understand that at such moments in your life you tend to become very emotional! so the tears! I don`t have a daughter, but i wish in my next birth i would love to have a daughter like Aish.
All this does not mean that I m against Anwesha! I like her also. I think both of them are very Talented and have a very long and bright future ahead. Anyone winning the title will be like unfair to the other! but when there are rules-we can`t help it!
Lot of people on this blog have some thing against Aish, that is bothering me. most of them are slinging mud at her, which is wrong. If one likes Anwesha- that is his opinion/choice.
IF YOU LIKE ANWESHA,THEN PRAISE HER! WHY TALK NONSENSE ABOUT OTHERS WITHOUT ANY PROOF?

 
Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-24 07:37:43

commonsense in this country has proceeded on leave giving the reins to irrational narrow-mindedness and one way thinking – vd.
god bless them.

 
Comment by mmm
2008-03-25 01:14:09

v d,
I am not talking against aish..I know she sings well…just saying all these drama in a talent show like this is pointless….people are going to judge on emotion than talent….I am sure Anwesha’s mom is very proud to have her as a daughter. All these emotions, tears, DRAMAS are to get audience feel sorry and “cultured” as DEVKISHIN said.
anwesha and aish both are talented…they both are! I am sure I will hear them both as a playback singer.
In my opinion, aish is good as a classical singer…not so much with modern…I was not attaking her.

The original argument was about regional bias….I was just expressing my opinion….no harm in that.

 
 
Comment by fairy
2008-03-24 00:05:45

that was an enirely uncalled for comment in my opinion!

Comment by fairy
2008-03-24 00:07:57

the above blog was in reply to sa’s comment.doesnt mean that if you dont weep in public you dont value your kids or Indian culture!how immature….

 
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-26 20:57:05

Lastly and not the least: how much liberal thoughts come to people was clearly demonstrated no other than two mother’s statements: MRS MAZMUDER SAID” SHE FEELS PROUD AND DEVINE ;IT’S DESTINY FOR HER CHILD TO BE CHOTTE USTAAD.”
MRS.DUTTAGUPTA SAID” BOTH ARE CHOTTE USTAAD AND BOTH ARE MY DAUGHTERS”
This leaves NOT a shade of doubt how two mothers think.
Many of us are liberal and respectful ,others are different in selfish ideology!
for MR/MRS SA : ROOTING here are many even not Bengali>when you said BENGALI CULTURE >Indian statesman Gopalakrishna Gokhale once said — “..what Bengal thinks today, India thinks tomorrow>this man was NOT BENGALI BUT GUJRATI>”TABAT SOBHOTYE MURKHA JABAT NA BHASYATHE”

 
 
Comment by chote ustaad viewer
2008-03-24 04:39:17

stop bossing

 
 
Comment by moomoon5
2008-03-23 16:17:14

yes,alka is a singer who is biased about aishwarya,becoz they are from same community and they know each other.
About Abhijit………
poor guy doesn’t have any job in bollywood anymore so he needs to keep gajju happy so that he can come back as a judge in the next voi for the seniors.
Alka gave her that necklace even if she didn’t sing that well becoz it was all pre planned by alka.
don’t you call it favouritism ?????

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-24 07:41:49

moomoon5:
you better join classes for psychology to understand the human behaviour properly and in proper perspective.you are only exposing yourself with childish comments.

 
 
Comment by Lovely
2008-03-23 16:30:34

Guajartis are the worst they have no idea of human rights and def. no IQ that is why they feel only bengalis supporting anvesha singh as far as i know is not a bengali surname…get a life dudes
as for aishwarya..she is just like guajartis,proud, arrogant and overbearing
did you hear her ‘i will only sing first’ what a jerk
And everywhere anvesha has more fans…i am a south indian and everyone prefers anvesha because they know good singing unlike guajarti fanatics

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Preet sagar
2008-03-23 17:13:54

Please don’t ame this a regional issue. We are here to support good singer, and that is there only in our little jewel Anvesha who is humble, sweet and down to earth apart from being immensely talented. no wonder Abhas said to her you are the best. Abhas is a good singer and knows good music.

Abhas and Abhilasha are in love. he is a wonderful person who wanted to leave senior VOI just because his sweetheart got eliminated-abhlasha. I know Abhilasha personally and she says she is lucky to have Abhas.
As for Anvesha and Abhas, they are next rafi saab and Asha bhonsle

Comment by Ronnie
2008-03-24 16:46:58

Abhas, in the very begining, told the press in an interview that in his opinion Anwesha is the best singer among all the contestants of ‘CHHOTE USTAAD’.

 
 
 
Comment by Rolly-polly
2008-03-23 16:31:59

I have heard very good singers on chote ustad and definitely anvesha is the one who outshines all and sundry
Best of luck Anvesha…you are a true singer in eevry respect

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-24 07:47:59

i am neither gujarati nor bengali only indian and i support indian talent in every field.any problem madam?

 
 
Comment by Rolly-polly
2008-03-23 16:33:13

Devshikin ji and sa
plz refrain from attacking other cultures. that is very negative. It is surprising you are suppofting inferior singing, but equally bad tha you are making such rascist remarks

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-23 16:53:52

My name is repeatedly mis-spelt.No wonder even anchor Shaan called me Devprasad;prompter immediately stepped in to assist Shaan.
I am D E V K I S H I N
Thanks for reading our comments.Whether you like me or hate me I shall continue to respect all my friends here AS I AM A HUMANBEING AND A PROUD INDIAN

Comment by Martha
2008-03-23 17:06:25

Anchor Shaan?and why would he call you? by the way, I am sure you have never even met Shaan.

 
 
Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-23 16:55:32

YOU ARE RIGHT. NO COMMENTS.

Comment by HASSAN Pakistani
2008-03-23 19:21:59

HI EVERY BODY I AM FROM PAKISTAN AND I USED TO WATCH VOI ALWAYS. BOTH CONTESTANTS ARE GOOD BUT I PERSONALLY LIKES AISHWARIYA’S VOICE. SPECIALLY HER SONG “ALBELA SAJAN” WAS BEAUTIFULLY SUNG BY HER.
I WISH THE BEST MAN WINS. IF YOU ALL WANA SHARE SOMETHIN’ WITH ME I WILL FEEL PLEASURE.
AND I RELLY LIKED THE SHREYA’S PERFORMANCE ON 22 MARCH.

Comment by oops
2008-03-23 22:12:06

Anwesha would have done a much better job with the same song given the chance but she was given some garbage numbers to sing, just to promote AISH.That’s really UNFAIR.

 
 
 
Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-24 07:54:50

yes we are supporting inferior singing and we will continue to support that; who are you to dictate to us what we should do and what not
for us anwesha=aishwarya but for you inferior/superior .go and see a good doctor when you see yellow everywhere.

 
 
Comment by Rupinder
2008-03-23 16:52:37

Anwesha, all Punjabis are with you. You are the best child-artiste after Shreya Pant and Sanjeevani

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-24 07:58:51

rupinder in scaryland! come out man and see the reality. there is no ishmit this time. are you guru of punjabis? if not how can you speak on behalf of all pujabis. you brat.

Comment by Rupinder
2008-03-24 15:08:29

Who is this stupid Devkishin cutting everyone’s comments?
You are not some great expert that has given you this right
I am in Punjab and my entire family friends here who are you you to talk about us?
we support true talent which is ANVESHA
we are not like you narrow-minded gujaartis only supporting your own kind ok?
we support taklent and we understand music
stop making comments on punjabis we have produced talent like daler mendi,rabi shergill
who ahve you iditoic gujartis produced?
that stupis aishwarya and gajendra who is against good singers?worth a laugh

 
 
 
Comment by Preet sagar
2008-03-23 17:10:10

I for one can blatabtly say who is far better. i am not a diplomatic judge like Shreya and preetam. It is obviously Anvesha.By far, by far! I am not even sure if Aishwarya deserved to be in top 2

As far as i can see the situation, Anvesha is the next Asha jee in making. Aishwarya will be a good music teacher for a private school run by gajendra ji;)

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-24 08:02:20

are you sagar of preet or sagar of poison! get your horoscope examined by a an astrologer who knows his businessas your nature is contradicting you name.

 
 
Comment by Sandip Bhattacharya
2008-03-23 17:13:02

I have been reading all the comments for quite some time.
Everybody has a favourite, but that does not allow you to speak ill of others. All the kids worked very hard.
We should all appreciate their efforts.
And in supporting one’s favourite, I find that regionalism, family etc. are also criticised!
Why can’t we think that we are all indians and that is the only identity we have?
These kids are also indians and they are making all of us proud!
My 2 cents worth of thoughts.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-24 08:07:16

at last a truly great humanbeing-sandip battacharya.
your opinion confirms that sanity has not totally disappeared from this country
we all love anwesha and aishwarya equally.keep up this divine spirit.

 
 
Comment by serious
2008-03-23 17:44:06

I loved Anwesha’s rendition of ‘Kambakth Ishk’ – such a hard song and she even sang a more difficult version with a lot of variations. And ‘Dola re dola’ was spelbinding!Such a difficult song (there no time to breathe) and she sang it perfectly. Aish’s voice sounded very nice in ‘Aye re Aye re’ and ‘ Bairi Piya’ but was a far cry from the originals with a lot of subtle mistakes. Shreya proved rightaway how ‘ Bairi piya’ should be sung.Anwesha is definitely the winner for me.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Shree
2008-03-23 17:53:00

I request all Anu’s fans lets not give personal,regional or communal comments,we know Anu is best and people around the world who are music lovers appreciate Anu’s talent,lets not waste time in proving who is the best because our Queen has already shown her superiority time and again,so lets chill and vote for her,there is a job for us,lets put effort in that

Just neglect the negative comments passed and our motto is to make Anu the Chote Ustaad because we need the real talent to be crowned

Cheers

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by serious
2008-03-23 18:33:08

well said!

 
Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-24 08:10:01

a wishful thinking always lands you in blunderland or scaryland-shree

 
 
Comment by STOP THIS SHOW ITS DRAMA
2008-03-23 17:56:25

I AM SO SUPRISED YOU GUYS CALL IT A REALITY SHOW. HOW CAN THE RULES CHANGE EVERY WEEK. THESE PEOPLE KNOW FROM INDIAN IDOL EXPERIENCE THAT PRAKRITI CAN WIN WITH VOTES LIKE PRASHANT. THATS WHY THEY GAVE 50% TO JUDGE WHO HUMILATED HER IN FRONT OF MILLIONS OF VIEWERS (COWARDS KUNAL AND SHREYA). NOW AS SHE IS OUT THEY PUT ALL POWER TO JANATA SO ASHWERYA CAN WIN. THIS IS DRAMA. ARENT THEY SUPPOSED TO HAVE A FIXED RULE FROM BEGINING.
OK JANATA CANT DECIDE FULLY FOR TOP TWO BUT THEY CAN FOR THE BEST. WHAT DOES THIS MEAN?? SO NOW THE SAME JUDGES WHO THREW PRAKRITI OUT DESPITE JANATA SUPPORT WILL SIT AND WATCH WHAT JANATA DO ON THE FINAL.
GAJENDRA IS PLAYING WITH JANATAS MONEY. WE SHOULD BAN AND STOP THIS KIND OF SHOW.
INDIAN IDOL SHOULD BRING KID SHOW IN SONY AT LEAST THEY FOLOW A FORMAT.
ALSO KUNAL AND SHREYA AND PRITAM ACT AS THEY ARE GOOD MUSICIANS BUT THEY ARE FOLLWING GAJJIS INSTRUCTIONS FOR MONEY.. AND MAY BE FOR POPULARITY AS I DIDNT KNOW MUCH ABOUT THESE PEOPLE BEFORE THIS SHOW… THEY ARE USING KIDS FOR THEIR OWN FAME..

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-23 18:50:23

SHREYA NOT BE BLAMED:
please, donot implicate shreya with public humilation of prakriti.SHE DIDN’T. i am very much sympathetic to PRAKRITI for Kunal’s behavior. parkriti’s aunt also brought the allegation to Kunal and NOT SREYA. SHREYA gave low mark according to prakriti’s performance and that is not humilating.The question is the whole system of elimination, grading and scoring needs to be changed. public participation of voting needs to be eliminated, to eliminate regionalism,unnecessary hype and pressure on a child to catch votes.

Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-24 10:24:30

above comments meant for’STOP THIS SHOW ITS DRAMA’
very strange name and equally strange comments. keep up the humour1

 
 
Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-24 08:28:19

these comments are unwarranted and illogical. the judges and the director had no option but to leave it to public to select their own favourite for the title as all their efforts to get the best talent in finals have suceeded. it would have been very embarrassing for the judges to select the winner between two top talents who have been repeatedly applauded in this show for their great performances.judges were no more interested in thankless job as they were repeatedly targeted by vested interests

 
 
Comment by vijay
2008-03-23 18:17:07

@ DEVKISHIN
You are the one who said in one of these blogs that Aishwarya RAI and Maduri Dixit are both dark skinned ladies. And you know that because you ARE FRIENDS WITH a very FAMOUS PHOTOGRAPER in Bombay right?. Give me a break o.k.? Skin colour does not matter but lying does.I know for sure what you said is not true becayse I have friends who have seen them upfront. You are just trying to project yourself as a VERY IMPORTANT PERSON and as a MR KNOW IT ALL but sadly its not working.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-24 08:32:56

your comments donot merit any reply as you appear to know nothing about mumbai and its citizens. you are still a kid living in fool’s paradise.
useless comments from a novice who knows nothing.

 
 
Comment by Ronnie
2008-03-23 18:30:27

Drama baazi to the extreme by Aishwary’s family in the Mar 22nd episode. Aish calls his dad on the phone and informs him that she is in top 2 and he acts like he is hearing this for the first time. WHAT!!! That means he did not know the results for 24 hours!! We are not stupid people o.k.? Anwesha on the otherhand called her Dad and talked about Jaipur’s 2nd day performances.The whole family is corrupt and into unnecessary DRAMAA BAAZI!

V d, are you deaf or blind?

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Ronnie
2008-03-23 19:13:00

DEVKISHIN,
Like v d are you deaf or blind! What imagination?? Aish talked to her DAD hours later of the first Jaipur episode and both pretended that its NEW NEWS that she is in the finals RIGHT? Anwesha did not tell her father that she is in the finals because he already knew that.Either Aish never botherd to call her DAD (that’s hard to believe) or its all DRAMA BAAZI, plain and simple. It does not take a rocket scientist to figure this out O.K.?

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Titas
2008-03-23 19:20:13

How many votes can we cast from one email id for the final round? Is there any limitations as stated in rules?

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-23 19:38:48

i heard 20 from my brother in texas.please check it,vote until the server rejects you! that’s what i told others.
happy voting

 
Comment by Ronnie
2008-03-23 22:02:59

Titas,
According to the rules you can only vote 20 times for each email ID.Right now for some reason they are accepting more than 20 votes but I think they are not going to COUNT any votes over 20 according to the rules. Safest thing is to cast 20 votes for each email id.Happy voting.

 
Comment by JAY
2008-03-24 03:21:45

Why After all this bloging you are NOT VOTING? You DON’T KNOW THe RUlES??

Comment by JAY
2008-03-24 03:33:23

@Dr akbiswas
the last remark was for you.

 
 
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-23 19:27:15

DRAMA:
We have seen in the past the drama from the family of certain participants.we have seen for voym and we have seen from AISWAYARIA.
ASH’S MOTHER EMOTIONAL TEARS,grand mother’s appearing and grand father’s predictions before death,Her appeal that “GOD has her daughter special to her to be great singer”-TEARS HAVE FLOWN ALL THE TIME.FATHER ALSO MADE A VERY EMOTIONAL APPEAL at the wedding episode.HOW MUCH THIS add to create special effect but this part of the video edting should have been censored.
ANWEHA’S MOTHER:She is very reserved.she is self-contained and respectful.she didn’t made any comments even whes she wiped her tears silently.i have never seen her “god’s reference,bowinghead like voym’s mother or gleeing like ASH’S mother”. her last statement was very meaningful.question”what’s your feeling?”
she simply replied” as far as chotte ustaad is concerned,both two finalists are chotte ustaad and both are my daughters”
WHEN ANWESHA WAS TALIKING TO HER FATHER ,SHE REFERRED AIWYARIA’S SUCCESS TO HER FATHER as much as her. I ALSO SAW SHE HUGGED BOTH PRAKRITI AND AISWARYA WHEN THEY CRIED.OF COURSE ,IT goes without saying PRAKRITI and her aunt reflect GRACE ,BEAUTY AND DECENCY OF REARE QUALITY.
THESE ARE THE REFLECTIONS WE GET FROM THE WHOLE EVENTS.I PERSONALLY THINK PUBLIC PERCEPTION OF ANWESHA IS INCREASING.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-23 19:33:33

few typo: RARE QUALITY

 
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-23 20:02:19

FINAL RESULTS:
IT’S VERY DIFFICULT TO JUDGE THE WINNER:
THE decision has been bestowed on public voting is a clever choice> the more i am analysing GAJJI, though i have no knowledge about this person(i do apolgise).
I HAVE NEVER SEEN HIM BUT FEW THINGS OF HIS PERSONA IS PROJECTING THROUGH FEW DECISIONS AND I JUST CAME TO KNOW LAST WEEK THAT HE IS THE BIGGEST PROMOTER AND DIRECTOR OF MUSICAL EVENTS FOR LAST 20YRS.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-23 20:08:26

I would ask DEVKISHANJI, please make few comments since you are in Bombay for many years.NONE OF MY FAMILY FRIENDS FROM KOLKATA,HAVE MUCH KNOWLEDGE! AMAZING!
thank you

Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-23 20:35:22

TYPO:DEVKISHINJI

 
Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-24 08:57:12

drakbiswas:for true music lovers anwesha and aishwarya are worthy rivals in the finale of this show . the judges realised that it proved to be a thankless job to select a better talent. they have performed the difficult task they were entrusted with by the organisers, with exemplary prudence and expertise . in view of many controversies generated by judgements of the judges the director and the judges had no other option but to call quits leaving the final judgement to general public . i personally still feel that the title should be shared by the top two i.e. anwesha and aishwarya.
in my eyes both are winners irrespective of the final results. both the talented teenagers are heading for very bright future in world of glamour and music.

 
 
Comment by JC
2008-03-23 23:56:16

And we knew him for at least for the last ten years!GREAT GUY! BUT is he CORRUPTED ? We will come to KNOW in this CONTEST for sure!!!! GAJJI I want you to come through as an honest producer for once. I have hope but let’s see what happens.I do have faith in you!!

 
 
Comment by Aamir
2008-03-23 20:57:57

all said and done…its obvious that anwesha is wayyy better than aish…and shud be the winner but unfortunately we have been shocked before in voi and indian idol…why wud this be any different…sad:( lets stop critisizing and start praying for little anwesha…

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Bonnie
2008-03-23 22:41:50

WE can just Vote, Vote, Vote! That’s the only way to make a deserving candidate a winner.If its preplanned then there’s nothing we can do but let’s just try to do the RIGHT thing. So,all music lovers please vote for our Anwesha! I think she is a god gifted singer. If she doesn’t win it will be a travesty of justice!! Aishwarya has a very nice voice quality, if she competed against Anamika may be she could have been the SAREGAMAPA title winner but the CHHOTE USTAAD TITLE IS DEFINITELY FOR ANWESHA,the most versatile, the most technically perfect,the most consistent( with all SARWOTTAMS FROM THE JUDGES),the contestant with the widest range and unbelievable voice modulation!!! Anwesha in my opinion, is one of the best singers to have come along in long long time! Come on all true music lovers, lets vote for the best candidate O.k.? And you know its ANWESHA – She is simply the best.So lets not waste any time in this blog and lets just go and vote for ANWESHA!!

 
 
Comment by Sonam
2008-03-23 21:48:47

Looks like Mr. DEVKISHIN is a relative or close friend of Shreya & Ashwariya. He writes so much on Blog & supports judges bahaviour towards Prakriti. He is also very sarcastic in his comments whenever he had praised Prakriti & sometimes with Anwesha.So sad.

Everyone has right to express their opinion & favour their contestants but it looks like DEVKISHIN has a very different way.
All human beings are beautiful. Mr. Drakbiswas comments “ugly” is not appropriate. Kunal & Shreya are equally guilty for humiliating kids on National TV.

Good luck to both singers.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by jack
2008-03-23 21:49:25

DEVKISHIN
Dear Devji,

Sorry to reply late …. I have seen ur one blog where u have written that ” Nimbuda ….” is an original composition of Imail Drabar….

I would like to say that ” Nimbuda… ” is a famous rajasthani folk which is used for marriage funtions…. and this is total copy of Ismail ji ….
I dont expect this types of mistakes from u ….

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-24 09:04:23

many film songs are based on folk music and almost all music composers -present as well as past -have composed songs based on folk .
thanks.

 
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-23 22:29:30

TO SWAY PUBLIC EMOTIONS:
I have not seen any more GRAND MASTER,Comrade JOYTI BASU than anybody in my life.
i still remember as a child,when he shattered a man like DR.B.C ROY,THE THEN CHIEF MINISTER OF WEST BENGAL-6′-3″ ONE OF THE BRILLIANT DOCTOR INDIA EVER PRODUCED!,VERY RESERVED(BENGAL MADE THE MAXIMUM PROGRESS DURING HIS PERIOD IN INDUSTRIALISTAION TO EDUCATION) as if he never existed in Bengal and lasted for 26yrs in politics of WEST BENGAL.
he is 5′-4″ tall,lincon barrister ,made billions for his family,son and daughter; made “bahu” from Marwari industrialist,one of the biggest industrialists of India.children settled in London but he sold communism to the public in such a way as if his life was on “dal aur chawl” and WEST IS “BIGGEST BURJUAH.”
MR. JOTYI BASU USED TO ELECTRIFY THE JANATA> HE COULD DO ANYTHING AND DID EVERYTHING FOR HIS GAIN.
SO WE WILL SEE THE SAME AGAIN IN ANOTHER GRANDMASTER WHO WILL SWAY THE PUBLIC EMOTIONS IN GRAND FINALE OF MUSIC !>I HOPE PUBIC COULD GUESS!!

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-23 22:40:24

typo:than joyti basu to anybody.

 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-23 22:57:51

I have another example came to my mind (i do apologise for this,out place!)
MR.MOHAMMAD ALI ZINNAH,MADE PAKISTAN BUT KEPT HIS DAUGTHER,DINA WADIA IN BOMABY,INDIA.(she still lives in India; her son Nausli wadia is preeti zinta’s boyfriend)
MANY PAKISTANI when they first come to know this they get a SHOCK!

 
 
Comment by Bonnie
2008-03-23 22:42:47

WE can just Vote, Vote, Vote! That’s the only way to make a deserving candidate a winner.If its preplanned then there’s nothing we can do but let’s just try to do the RIGHT thing. So,all music lovers please vote for our Anwesha! I think she is a god gifted singer. If she doesn’t win it will be a travesty of justice!! Aishwarya has a very nice voice quality, if she competed against Anamika may be she could have been the SAREGAMAPA title winner but the CHHOTE USTAAD TITLE IS DEFINITELY FOR ANWESHA,the most versatile, the most technically perfect,the most consistent( with all SARWOTTAMS FROM THE JUDGES),the contestant with the widest range and unbelievable voice modulation!!! Anwesha in my opinion, is one of the best singers to have come along in long long time! Come on all true music lovers, lets vote for the best candidate O.k.? And you know its ANWESHA – She is simply the best.So lets not waste any time in this blog and lets just go and vote for ANWESHA!!

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by gooboo123
2008-03-23 23:26:45

Hello,

I for once took Devkishin head on … for what he was talking in this forum.
Yes sir you must be twice my age and i should give respect to you but remember that you should behave in a manner that deserves respect.

Anyway…….i dont want to drag on this issue coz i believe my message did the necessary impact.

There are loyals on both sides (Aishwarya or Anwesha) but then there are certain undecided lot (swingers) who need a bit of help in deciding whom to vote.

My advice to those swingers is to go and hear the 22nd march episode coz it is the latest and I think the problem of who is the best is solved beyond doubt in this episode.

There are some Aishwarya fans in here who would still cry out loud that Aish did it better but I think there is no doubt in my mind or in judges or Urmilas mind who the better singer was … Anwesha !!!!

To tell you the truth i dont have any faith in the voting system and i think Anwesha is going to miss out on Chhote Ustaad because of voting. But she is going to rock hindi movies songs very very soon. She is not perfect but closer to the perfection that bollywood needs than Aishwarya. Aishwarya because of her voice definitely would find a place in bollywood but she will have to learn a bit more control over her voice, her breathing which she will achieve in the near future.

As far as Anwesha goes……You Rock !!!!
This program has been worth seeing only because of your performances week after week. There are lots of votes coming your way from Australia.

Sanjay

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Bonnie
2008-03-23 23:44:10

We are all with you!

 
Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-24 10:41:00

anwesha is precious for the music industry and the music world of this country . it may not be problem for aishwarya to get into bollywood through playback singing but the golden girl from far off calcutta must bag the crown to remain in this city of dreams.everyone would like to hear a fresh melodius voice .buck up all lovers of anwesha’s voice.
aishwarya you are already in . young anwesha is truly a cultured teenager and it will indeed be a red letter day in history of indian music world to welcome two young gifted and talented singers simultaneously in the industry.AMEN!

Comment by gooboo123
2008-03-24 11:32:53

Good morning Devkishinji,

I was really missing your comments.

But well said … it will indeed be a red letter day if you cannot give credit to the talent where it deserves. This is the most unfortunate thing that happens day after day in India and no matter what we do……it is still going to happen over and over again. You know that Anwesha is a better singer but people like you will continue to argue and find a way to crush her talent.

Talent is going to be crushed under our feet. We are going to annhiliate people like Prakriti. We are going to crush the talent of Anwesha since she comes from “far off Calcutta” and not from our land Gujarat. We are the ones to blame for it. When it comes to appreciate the talent we start comparing and saying our kid is not bad. We start giving alms to these people in good position to favour our children or the children from our region.

Just do a bit of introspection Devkishinji. Just a little bit before you come up with that sentence. Would you have said the same thing had it been your daughter in place of Anwesha… that she will struggle to find a place here if she loses this competition. People like you are going to make life difficult for new people who come to a city like Mumbai… and you boast of that. You already boast of being in touch with the program director Gajji (whoever that is), and Shaan (if that was really him. People like you who think they have the power of doing things their way and they can do anything will crush a blooming career of Anwesha. Because it gives you satisfaction that a “ghar ki chhokri” has made it to the winners podium.

If that is what your law has taught you God Bless India and its constitution.

Sanjay

 
 
 
Comment by fairy
2008-03-23 23:51:02

i agree with you sanjay!
i wish anwesha wins…she seems so sweet and sincere and untouched by the vagaries of life. no artificiality whatsoever.she and her mum are both so dignified and composed. i love that a lot.singing wise…..superb.what can i say….shes obviously put in a lot of hard work.
no doubt aishwarya may have worked hard as well…..but she seems more popular as a crowd-puller.
i dont want my blog to be only politically correct or diplomatic…..my hearts been taken by anwesha. God bless her. hope she gets a good guide if she plans to enter the big bad world of bollywood….becoz a few wrong moves in the beginning of your career can be disastrous.
i wish both of them well for this contest but i wish anwesha goes a long long way in her life and musical career.
lots of votes from UK as well.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Bonnie
2008-03-24 00:03:27

@fairy,
You are a true well wisher. I feel the same way as you do. We are true Anwesha fan. Good advice and god bless!

Comment by fairy
2008-03-24 23:04:13

hey Bonnie
Are you from Canada by any chance?
Glad to know that you are also an ardent Anwesha fan. I liked your blog asking ppl to vote. A lot of blogs on this site speak lines and lines of irrelevant stuff, some using strong language (even foul), some screaming rudely (u know who).
But I think the important thing to do now is vote.
I just hope ppl vote for Anwesha from all parts of the world not to forget India.
Cheers
Fairy

Comment by Bonnie
2008-03-25 00:43:42

Hi fairy, I’m from the U.S. But my brther lives in Canada. We are all voting for our Anwesha as much as possible including our friends here and back home. Happy voting!

 
Comment by fairy
2008-03-25 01:00:13

Hi Bonnie
I happen to know a Bonnie whos now based in Canada and we’ve lost touch for a while now. Hence the question. I hope you didnt mind that on a public blog site.
I’ll be happy to be in touch with you even after this contest ends…..no pressure…its only if you wish.You can happily refuse.
My id is tantheta21@yahoo.com and I am an honest, law-abiding, tax-paying citizen…not to mention a lover of music and Hrishida’s movies.
fairy

 
 
 
 
Comment by ajay
2008-03-24 00:22:33

URMILLA can sing definitely better than you.For your INFO Urmila sang a beautiful song with ASHA BHONSLE in her new album and she did a very good job.You better check it out before you start babbling anymore!Get the facts right O.K.She is no novice , she gave a standing ovation to ANWESHA bacause it was definitely worth it.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by serious
2008-03-24 03:10:56

totally agree with you.

 
 
Comment by gooboo123
2008-03-24 00:24:31

There are certain people in this forum who keep on talking about Nasal pitch to Anweshas voice when she sings those high pitches. But i would like to tell them that since you have nothing else to talk about in Anweshas singing that you come up with this flaw. She is perfect in Sur, Lay and Taal. As far as singing competition goes this is what we try and ascertain…….Whether ‘A’ competitor can sing in sur taal and lay. It is never checked if he sings with the exact open mouth or nasal twang like the original song.

Otherwise if you ask Kailash Kher to sing Mohd Rafis songs the way rafi sang……it would make him an ordinary singer but he is a great singer. If you ask anyone of the present generation to sing songs like Mukesh did….they will all be hopeless. But we dont want to listen the same throw, same open or close mouth, same things over and over again otherwise we would be Robots.

What we are looking for is whether a singer can stick to the original Sur, Taal, Lay.

With Anwesha though she does have a Nasal twang with high pitches she sticks to the original sur so well that she rarely misses it.

While with Aishwarya, she misses the sur, taal atleast a few times in each song. Though she sounds melodious…that is not enough for a singer.
Also she has modified many songs for her own convenience over this competition which is not good when you are growing up. She is not great enough to change the original composition.

If anyone disagrees …… let me know.

Sanjay

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by serious
2008-03-24 02:40:10

No, I compleyely agree with you.

 
Comment by fairy
2008-03-25 01:26:05

Hi Sanjay
I agree with you in many respects and would like to add something to what you’ve said in your blog.
First of all, let me declare that I am not a Himesh Reshamiya fan….but even if Anweshas voice did sound nasal, which seems to be the hot topic of debate with some people, whats wrong with it? She sounded so fantastic and carried the song so beautifully…..I agree that Shreya pointed it out and its to Anweshas benefit if sorted out early, but is it such a huge flaw? Keeping in mind her entire performance, what difference did it make….I personally dont think it ruined her song at all. Anybody can sound a bit nasal when they have a cold. Some ppl make a living…even a fortune with nasal voices….!!! There have been other songs where Anweshas sung very high pitched notes to perfection…like “the sargam in mere dholna ”
Aishwaryas voice is superb…advantaged in being original but in my opinion, she lacks finesse……
I hope Anwesha performs exceptionally in the coming episodes and gets lots of votes.
I also hope both of them get to sing some old and melodious numbers….after a long long time we are seeing singers capable of carrying off old songs beautifully.
cheers
fairy

 
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-24 00:26:46

Truly speaking,i have lots arguments in my own family,as i said before,WHICH WILL NEVER HAPPEN BUT i would still recommend GAJ JI TO MAKE THIS AWWARD TO BOTH, ANWESHA AND AISWARYA.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by devkishin
2008-03-25 16:35:36

This judgement is unbiased and purely based on string of amazing performances both by Anwesha and Aishwarya in this show. It appears Doctor your family has watched all the performances carefully and appear to be undecided about the best talent between the two little giants.
Hats off to you doctor and your blessed family.

Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-28 06:57:57

as you said DEVJI> My son a surgeon from stanford loves AISWYARIA and she is also favorite to our daughter-inlaw(Doctor;) My daughter,a med student stanford,would like to invite ANWESHA and aiswyaria to stanford but she likes ANWESHA. My 2nd daughter, law student again swings between the two according to their each performance.
Me and my wife love Both kids.
so what i am supposed to do !

 
 
 
Comment by gooboo123
2008-03-24 00:30:14

I think by giving an award to both you are saying that both are equal…..I can understand if you dont want any more fights in your family by suggesting that. But you know by heart who is a better trained singer, who is the better singer. So let the best singer win.

Sanjay

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by gooboo123
2008-03-24 00:34:20

And mind you if people here start thinking that i am a die hard Bengali……I am not. Coz there is a lot of people having alliances based on language, region and religion.

so let me be clear……I am a Marathi person who does not live in India.

Sanjay

Comment by vijay
2008-03-24 02:50:49

WE are not bengalis but we would like to vote for the best singer , ANWESHA – IS THAt a crime? Stop ganging up on us o.k.? I am a die hard fan of Anwesha but not a Begali so its nothing about regionalism, only about love of true music.

 
 
Comment by devkishin
2008-03-25 16:39:06

LET THE BETTER TALENT BE CROWNED CHHOTE USTAD.
YOU ARE 100% CORRECT. I FULLY ENDORSE YOUR VIEWS.

 
 
Comment by well wiisher
2008-03-24 00:33:06

On my opinion both Aishwarya and Anwesha should win. Both have a great voice. I don’t know why people keep criticizing these little ones. At this age singing like this is superb. This comment system is not for criticizing but for praising. If you can’t do that then there is a voting system as well ,go and vote for ur favorite contestant, rather than writing offending words against somebody. Common lets encourage these talents….

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by devkishin
2008-03-25 16:46:21

A FAIR COMMENT FROM AN INVIDUAL WHO KNOWS HIS JOB well. KEEP UP THIS SPIRIT.IT IS SOOTHING AND EQUITABLE.
THIS IS IN REPLY TO A COMMENT OF-well wiisher

 
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-24 00:34:47

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bKldYV3-S2o&NR=1
SHREYA GHOSAL : SAREGAMAPA CONTESTANT AS A CHILD;
COMPARE AND YOU WOULD REALISE BOTH ANWESHA AND AISWARYA ARE MORE ADVANCED

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Eva
2008-03-24 12:49:33

Hello.. Devkisinji please note it down.

Thanks

Comment by devkishin
2008-03-25 17:22:35

FOR EVA:
This piece is from one of the rounds of the competition in which Shreya Ghoshal floored half a dozen senior rivals and won the title. Shreya Goshal was the youngest contestant in this competition.There were seven legends who officiated as judges in this competition.
There was one round in the competition in which a song recorded in recording studio was presented before the judges.
This particular song was composed by one of the musicians in Show’s orchestra and is not a popular piece. I leave it to other bloggers to form their opinion about Shreya’s singing prowess at the age of 16/17.
in my opinion Shreya has rendered this song superbly and the chhote ustad finalists are nowhere near her standard .
Shreya Ghoshal-100% perfect at the age of 16/17
Anwesha/Aishwarya – presently 50% the age of 13/14
This is my personal judgement.
I have got recording of the entire competition.All are welcome to watch this show at my residence
Thanks EVA for reffering to me above link.

 
 
 
Comment by ajay
2008-03-24 00:38:05

@Sa
yeah right! She is as much of a singer as Aishwarya if not better. Have you heard her song with ASHA in her new album? She is fabulous in it according to Asha herself O.K.? Go listen to her songs and then comment.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by ajay
2008-03-24 00:39:31

@SA
I meant URMILA, the singer.

 
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-24 00:52:53

LOOK I MUST SAY IT’S VERY DIFFICULT> I HAVE NO KNOWLEDGE OF MUSIC TO THE PROFESSIONAL LEVEL,MOST OF MY FAMILY THEY ARE PROFESSIONAL PEOPLE BUT A DOCTOR OR AN ATTORNEY (WITH DUE RESPECT TO MY FAMILY MEMBERS)HAS NO KNOWLEDGE OF INDIAN MUSIC.THIS IS THE TRUTH.REST OF THE PEOPLE ARE THE SAME EXCEPT VERY FEW PEOPLE.
WE MAY NOT LIVE IN INDIA,BUT WE KNOW INDIAN PUBLIC.SO THAT’S WHY I SAID NOT TO DO INJUSTICE TO TALENT, BOTH SHOULD BE AWARDED.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-24 01:02:44

NO COLLEGE OR UNIVERSITY EDUCATION CAN GIVE THAT MUSICLAL KNOWLEDGE OR SENSE.IT’S ENTIRELY A DIFFERENT FIELD
(NO DISRESPECT TO ANYBODY).

 
 
Comment by chronic
2008-03-24 01:18:32

Anwesha was just fabulous in this episode. Both songs were very dificult and she did them both 100% justice. She was clearly the better performer tonight. Though I liked Aishwarya’s ‘Bairi Piya,’ the mistakes in her performance could be easily noted after hearing Shreya sing the song. Anwesha, what more can I say? She is simply on a league of her own. Whether she wins this competition or not, it is clear that she will be every Music Dircetor’s favourite young singing artiste very soon.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Bonnie
2008-03-24 02:03:14

Completely agree wyth you.

 
 
Comment by Anonymous
2008-03-24 01:30:47

Anwesha might have a slight nasal tone to her voice (when she attempts the high notes, this is more obvious), I noticed this particularly with ‘nimbooda’ (though she sang this exceptionally well), but Aishwarya doesn’t even try singing high-pitched songs and when she does, she often goes besura. Aishwarya, though she is a very good singer, does not have the range, finesse and control of Anwesha…

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Bonnie
2008-03-24 02:35:53

Aish Fans and Fanatics.
I think you’re taking this nasal(?)thing to a little bit too far. High Pitch is one thing and nasal another thing O.k.? Anu has never been nasal and yes she had to sing at a very high pitch which is very hard to attain. Aish can’t even attain the high notes unless she sings in falsetto so ther’s no comparison.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Anonymous
2008-03-24 04:28:17

Please reread my post. I wrote that Aishwarya does not even attempt to sing high-pitched songs because she knows she can’t sing them and on the rare occasion she does, she is very out of tune! I’m NOT a so-called “fan” or “fanatic” of Aishwarya (infact I support Anwesha for reasons stated above). But, Anwesha is not perfect, she is close to perfection, but not there yet. She does get a bit nasally when she attempts the really high-notes. Shreya had pointed this out before in the Salman Khan episode, but I did not agree with her then as I could not hear any nasal tone in her voice when she sang “kyun ki itna pyar,’ but with the recent episodes, I finally noticed what Shreya was talking about. If you listen to her ‘Nimbooda’ closely, you will be able to hear a slight nasal twang coming through, especially in the really high-pitched part of the song. But this does not matter anyway, as it is a very minor issue. An issue that I’m sure this wonderkid will work on in the future. She is superior to the other contestants in every way and definately deserves to win.

 
 
Comment by vijay
2008-03-24 02:52:22

2008-03-24 02:50:49
WE are not bengalis but we would like to vote for the best singer , ANWESHA – IS THAt a crime? Stop ganging up on us o.k.? I am a die hard fan of Anwesha but not a Begali so its nothing about regionalism, only about love of true music.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-24 03:25:27

IT’S TRUE THAT SHREYA SINGS ALSO IN TAMIL AND SHE IS VERY POPULAR IN SOUTH.
SHE IS BENGALI ,BORN IN RAJASTHAN AND FAMOUS IN SOUTH! WHAT CAN I SAY!

Comment by he he
2008-03-24 05:23:22

DONT SAY ANYTHING DREAM OF SHREYA AND JACK OFF ASS HOLE

Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-24 15:11:04

THIS JACK ASS “HE HE” NEEDS TO BE KICKED OFF.MODERATOR PLEASE DO THE JOB!

 
 
 
 
Comment by JAY
2008-03-24 03:26:31

This comment was for Dr. akbiswas

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-24 03:45:11

Everybody has their own feeling, i must respect that.

 
 
Comment by Preet sagar
2008-03-24 03:42:10

COME ON ALL VOTE FOR ANVESHA
SEE GAJ IS A CORRUPT MAN AND WAS USING PRAKRIT AND ANVESHA SHAMELESSLY FOR HIS OWN ENDS
GROW UP GAJ

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Sweety
2008-03-24 03:44:55

ANVESHA ROCKS!!
AISHWARYA IS NOTHING IN FRONT OF HER
IN FACT, IF IT WAS NOT FOR HYPE, AISHWARYA WOULD HAVE BEEN AT 9′TH OR 10′TH POSITION
ALL EXCEPT MANSI, ABEER WERE BETTER THEN HER
I think junta should wake up and vote for the best…But i feel the great director is manipulating results
And I know Kunal,Preetam,Shaan, Abhas,Vidya,ila Arun, all are with anvesha…including Vyom of course
the entire junta suports you anvesha
only realtives of this mad Guajarti family can support Aishwarya–rich brats
All know that gaj cannot change rules again and again for his aishwarya

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by trados
2008-03-25 02:53:05

Another example of racial comments [sic] from this creature called Sweety!!

 
 
Comment by Sweety
2008-03-24 03:46:39

Corruption is rampamt in chote ustad
all the contestnats’ aprents should have spoken up against aishwarya’s family as they did i saregam 2005
aishwarya was there in saregam 2005 and was thrown out because parents of other contestants protested against her
same should have happened here
but gaj is doing his best to appease rich gujaarti NRi and aishwarya’s corrput parenst

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by devkishin
2008-03-25 17:36:37

For sweety who says-”corruption is rampant in chhote ustad.”
To come to any conclusion that so and so is corrupt is rather an irresponsible statement if it is made without producing any proof. You are required to provide concrete proof to substantiate the charges. Can you sweety? I shall agree with you if you are in position to prove the allegations you are levelling agaist the management of chhote ustad.

 
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-24 03:48:56

(2)http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bKldYV3-S2o&NR=1
SHREYA GHOSAL : SAREGAMAPA CONTESTANT AS A CHILD;
COMPARE AND YOU WOULD REALISE BOTH ANWESHA AND AISWARYA ARE MORE ADVANCED

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
Comment by Muhammad Zubair, Karachi, Pakistan
2008-03-24 07:43:56

Thanks for shortcut for the clip.

I agree that the voice quality of Anwesha appears to be better at this age than that of Shreya.

In one of the episodes, Pritam had commented that on high pitch, Anwesha’s voice “patli (thin) hojati hay”. I have heard Shereya on this clip and her voice too became “patli” at the high pitch. I, therefore, believe that if Anwesha’s voice “patli horahi thi” (which I doubt), then she would overcome this problem with the passage of time.

 
 
 
Comment by Sweety
2008-03-24 03:55:04

MR PREET SAGAR
how do you know abhas and abhilasha are going around?
i did get the feeling in VOI, but i was not sure

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Avi
2008-03-24 04:06:16

Can anybody please let me know if it was decided in the begining of the show that the winner would be decided solely based on public votes ? I am not sure why do the rules change in the middle of the show ?

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by gooboo123
2008-03-24 04:13:01

Hello Sweety,

I am not so sure about the corruption that you are talking about in sa re ga ma pa. Could you throw some light on it ?

I am with you in terms of who should win this competition .. Anwesha.

But I would also ask you to refrain from throwing mud on gujjus as a whole community or any community for that matter. I am not a gujju but i think this is what divides the country and makes us vulnerable for other countries to take advantage of.

I know you are upset that despite doing her best a great upcoming singer … Anwesha will be robbed off a chance of victory and that too for a non singing reason. But that is what India as a whole country is made up of. You look at results starting from your 1st grade. Indians are just too loyal to their own kind, and money rather than talent.

And this is what kills you. That time and again talent is made to hide under the carpet. Time and again it takes a whole Mahabharat to take place before you find the truth.

Victory or no Victory … We love you Anwesha.

Sanjay

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Sweety
2008-03-24 15:00:14

yes, I can tell you doa google search on aishwarya in sarega,m 2005 when sachita won aishwarya was a contestant but aprents of other contestants wanted ash out so she left
ash is nothing but bogus…ash u will LOSE

 
 
Comment by Muhammad Zubair, Karachi, Pakistan
2008-03-24 04:42:57

Anwesha was far much better than Aishwarya in both the songs. It would be unfair and unwise if she loses in the finals. From my own point of view, Anwesha is the true “Chhote Ustaad”.

I do not know whey it is always Anwesha who has to sing duets etc. For example, the song Ga Re Man Piya was originally sung by two male and two female singers, Morni Baga Mein was sung by two female singers and last night’s song was also originally sung by Shreya and Krishnamurti. Shereya herself confessed that she goes out of breath whenever she sings this song. So, hats on for Anwesha that she sang it as near to the original.

Why don’t they ask Aishwarya to sing such songs. My own observation is that the judges and Gajendra are favoring Aishwarya in spite of the fact that Anwesha is better than her.

As was pointed out by one of the judges earlier, if Anwesha loses in the finals then it is “India’s loss”. I hope that this does not happen and I believe that the people of India, keeping in view that music is their religion, will not make a mistake and will chose Anwesha for the title of “Chhote Ustaad”

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Serious
2008-03-24 15:56:46

My thoughts exactly

 
Comment by fairy
2008-03-24 22:48:29

well said zubair bhai!
let them just get Aishwarya to sing “ami je tomar…mere dhola sun” and doodh ka doodh pani ka paani hojayega.cant get Anweshas performance out of my mind on that one!
I frankly dont care about the contest results…especially after seeing the results of previous contests….my best wishes are with Anwesha for a prosperous life and career.
fairy

Comment by Muhammad Zubair, Karachi, Pakistan
2008-03-25 04:57:06

Yes, Ami Jay Tomar, I think is the most difficult song I have ever heard. Incidentally, it is also originally sung by two singers, including Shreya Ghoshal and the male singer, who is a classical music Ustaad.

I had heard this song first time in Chhote Ustaad by Anwesha. Then for comparison sake, I found the original song on net and compared it with that sung by Anwesha. I was amazed to note that both the songs were nearly identical in melody. At some places Anwesha looked to be even better than Shreya.

When Anwesha had sung this song in Chhote Ustaad, Mr. Pritam told Shreya that they had completed this song in parts whereas Anwesha had sung this song in one go.

I do not think that Aishwarya can sing this song. You are right, if they ask Aishwarya to sing “Ami Jay Tomar”, it will fully expose her weaknesses.

 
 
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-24 06:27:00

VOTING:
WHO KEEPS THE RECORD??
HOW BHOPAL BECAME BIGGEST VOTER?
MAY QUESTIONS THAN ANSWERS ? THEN read THE FOLLOWING:
Truly speaking ,my gut’s feeling of this scary and fairy lands are imaginary
“jennie”. THE JENNIE IS KEPT IN THE BOTTLE, LIKE ALLAUDIN’S MAGIC LAMP!
“KIA KARO HUJUR? ISKO SCARYLAND ME BHEJO> JO HUJUR.”
IN my childhood ,it was EAST PAKISTAN:
EVEN great POLITICIANS used to FEAR A LOCAL JENNIE, AN UNEDUCATED MOLLAH BUT HE COULD SWAY THE WHOLE JUMMAH’S (NAMAZ)JAMAT,COMPLETELY!!THIS ILLITERATE MAN COULDN’T READ OR WRITE,was a “MASTER CRAFTER.” MANY educated people would fear him and gave him SALAM by touching his feet.HE WAS INDESPENSIBLE FOR HINDU-MUSLIM RIOTS AND POLITICS.SO his public offerings used to come from both sides> HINDUS USED TO THINK HIM AS “SAITAN” AND MUSLIMS USED TO THINK HIM AS “FARISTA”.
His income from making “TABIZ” FOR EVERY THING FOR THOUSANDS OF RUPEES;HE became one of the most succesful man, selling RELIGION AND IGNORANCE TOGATHER.
I WOULD LIKE TO SEE WHAT GAJJI WOULD SELL ON 5TH OF APRIL.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-24 06:31:39

correction: indispensable

Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-24 08:10:35

I have been thinking what kind of TABIZ can i sell? because the public is ready with full josh!

 
 
 
Comment by Manoj
2008-03-24 08:58:29

To Ronnie,

If you had watched all earlier episodes, they you might have noticed that recording of 2 episodes must have done in same day back to back.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Ronnie
2008-03-24 15:17:38

If contestants had time to change their wardrobe then their Moms definitely had time to inform their family by phone. That’s why Anwesha didn’t even bother to tell her DAD that she is in TOP 2 because he already knew the results! Pure DRAMA BAAZI By Aish and her DAD!

 
 
Comment by Avi
2008-03-24 09:53:42

Hi – Can anybody please let me know if it was decided in the begining of the show that the winner would be decided solely based on public votes ? I am not sure why do the rules change in the middle of the show ?

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Alia
2008-03-24 11:12:09

Devkishin…
Soz i mean sowi if u cnt undastnd wt i m writing cauz i duno hw 2 mke it MRE simple..newy all i sed wz THAT PEOPLE HU R AGAINST AISHWARYA LYK SINGH OR WOTEVA N R CALLINNG HER FAMILY DRAMABAZ NEED 2 GET A LYF I MEAN..LYK HW DA HEL CN DEY NT APPRECIATE HER SINGIN BTH R DESERVING …SO..DEY SHULLD NT GO ON N ON BOUT THAT HER SUR WENT OF MNY TYMZ.. N SHE DESNT DESERVE D TITLE OF CHOTE USTAD CAUZ IF SHE DUZ SUMTIN..IN HER SINGING FOR EG..PUTS HER OWN VARIATION..DEY SAY SHEZ YOUNG ND SHULD NOT PLY WITH THE ORIGINAL SONG …AND WEN ANWESHA DOES THE SAME DEY SAY SHE MADE IT SOUND MRE BEAUTIFUL…????????? newy bth r deservin

All u people learn hw 2 appreciate ppl hu hav sum kinda talent no 1nz betta den d other …dey hav der own qualities kk ….

HOPE U UNDASTND ma english nw cauz while typing i use alot of slang…as i do while speakin..! lolz newyz

gd luk bth ..xoxox BLESS

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-24 11:18:35

THANKS ALIA.
I NOTICED SOMETHING DIFFERENT HERE AND TRIED TO UNDERSTAND.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Alia
2008-03-24 11:21:45

loollzz..wot a trampp

SAGAR PREET OR PREET SAGAR …hu carez…

GET UR HEAD SORTED OUT….WOT DA FLIP R U ON BOUT..AISHWARYA CAN B A MUZIQ TEACHER …..
HOW BOUT YOU SING SUMTIN N V BLUDY JUDGE U I DNT EVN THINK UR VOICE IS EVEN WORTH 2 B JUDGED CAN U STOP THESE HARSH COMMENTS AGAINST A LIL CHILD..

OK ACCORDING 2 U mR..HU DID U WANT 2 B IN D TOP 2 HUN??

dey bth r truly deserviing so shut ur gob..i m tryin nt 2 swear … and …. and…. k duno y do i even bother all i can sy is if u hav 2 sy sumting against her

DONOT COMMENT …

low life

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by jy
2008-03-24 13:31:20

The comments on this blog are deviating from the talent concerning regarding this competition. Anyone who understands music and has watched Anwesha and Aishwarya would know who sang which song better. People are blogging with bad words for others..that’s just not fair. Why fight with strangers on topics noone knows the truth about.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by jatin
2008-03-24 14:33:52

Gaj uncle is so mean, he got Prakriti eliminated and now is again making money through public voting.
Anyhow Anvesha is going to win this contest, there will be a bombardment of votes in her favour from Calcutta and some other areas.
Anyways bad luck for Aishwarya, but the career of both the girls is secure.
Shreya Ghoshal gave a scintillating performance in Saturday’s episode. She proved that she is the best female play back singer at present.She is much above Alka Yagnik & Sunidhi Chauhan

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Preet Sagar
2008-03-24 14:50:24

hey alia…or whoever you are…who are you to judge singing you can’t even judge that aishwarya is nowhere near anvesha this is a simple fact of nature all the world who knows even saregam of music knows it
in top 2 can be anyone other than aishwarya…geetashri,sonia,jayant,areeb,shailey,prakriti,vyom…anyone except aishwarya who survives only on gaj’s pity
talent wise aishwarya can never reach anvesha all the guest judges know it except that biased alak ok

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Preet Sagar
2008-03-24 14:58:10

Dev crap or whoever
don’t try to show of in this blog. everyone knows who is better. i told you i know abhilasha and she loves anvesha. she and abhas love each other that does notr mean they cannot support true talent ok? they are singers of voi eacj one of them prefers anvesha. tehya ll know reality of ash.i can get abhilasha to write on this blog she is here with me and next xomment is by her

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Rupinder
2008-03-24 15:11:01

This Devkishin is writing nonsense and expects us to praise his knowledge of music.
You are nothing but a loser who does not know difference bwteen good and excellent
aishwarya is only good anvesha is excellent ok?
Don’t try to fool with partiality
I am a punjab ki kudi and i know good music
not like narrow-minded gujaratis who only support their own kind
punjabis hate such people we are not biased and we know music ok?

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by trados
2008-03-25 02:40:13

Rupinder,

Although you are saying that you are not like “narrow-minded gujaratis”, by making such racial comments you have only degraded yourself and shown your low level thought process [sic]. And FYI, I am myself from Punjab and it is shameful that there are many people like you not only in punjab but all over India.

Comment by JAY
2008-03-25 03:27:13

Trados
Before commenting like a fool, read all of Devkishin’s comments first O.K.? He is calling everybody stupid and a brat. Rupinder was just answering to his idiotic comments.

Comment by trados
2008-03-25 04:22:47

JAY…I had posted my comments after reading all of Devkishin’s comment only. My remarks were towards the racial comments made by Rupinder…got it or not? If Rupinder didnt like Devkishin’s comments, she could express the same but she should not make such racial comments like “narrow-minded gujaratis” etc.

 
 
 
 
Comment by rafisaabkafan
2008-03-24 15:13:34

Anvesha is a child prodigy.i for one do not care whether she wins or loses. she is a gifted singer who will make India proud of her.
All Anvesha lovers…do not even bother fighting. Let us support our Anu in whatever way we can. We all know who is better however eevn if Anvesha does not win it hardly matters in fact true talent never wins in these reality shows since voting ystem got introduced.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by devkishin
2008-03-25 12:04:50

Anwesha is heading for a great future in playback singing/glamour world on her own strength, support of her parents and the training she received from her sangeet gurus in West -Bengal.
God bless this jewel.

 
 
Comment by rafisaabkafan
2008-03-24 15:16:42

I think the honourable director is keen to make the less popular but over-hyped Aishwarya win. Aishwarya’s voice quality is soothing and she has knowledge of classical music. These are factors in her favour.
Otherwise Anvesha has technical precision and a thorough grounding in all the elementary nunaces of music which are hallmark of a GREAT singer. such singers are born once in a lifetime.
s for aishwarya, she is good but not extraordinary.
When something exraordinary comes our way, we are not sure how to encourage it. i wish ANVESHA DATTA GUPTA all the best from my entire family’s side.You are beyond this show for us.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by devkishin
2008-03-25 12:08:25

GREAT JUDGEMENT ON EXCEPTIONAL TALENT OF THIS SENSATIONAL BEAUTY FROM LAND OF MASTERS.

 
 
Comment by kvniranjan8
2008-03-24 15:42:21

Aishwarya is the truly deserving winner. I can bet that heroines will start to queue up in front of Aishwarya’s house to get her to sing for them.
Any heroine will prefer a sweet voice and good expression rather than technical perfection (Aishwarya is 90 percent perfect technically, she’s hard working and she’ll become 100 percent perfect)
Aishwarya is the extraordinary find which comes probably once every century.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Ronnie
2008-03-24 20:01:05

Yeah right!!! FYI, heroines don’t line up – the music directors do O.K.? And you ADMIT that Aishwarya is far from perfect – thats good! Sweet voices are dime a dozen. You heard Shreya right? One has to be that good or better to make it in bollywwod. Only one singer in my opinion has the capability to do that and that is our ONE AND ONLY ANWESHA.

 
Comment by devkishin
2008-03-25 12:10:58

NO DOUBT AISHWARYA AS WELL AS ANWESHA ARE GOING TO RULE THE WORLD OF PLAYBACK IN INDIA
MAY GOD BLESS THEM.

 
 
Comment by Ronnie
2008-03-24 16:10:53

Devikishin

I know you’re very old and you think everybody else is immature, stupid and a BRAT.What makes you such a PANDIT that you have to disagree with Everyone who likes Anwesha’s singing? Intelligent people who love music are blogging here. You are entitled to your opinion but Please DO NOT TRY TO DEMEAN EVERYONE .

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by devkishin
2008-03-25 12:14:40

RONNIE:THE SPIRIT OF HOLI IS OVER .YOU ARE HURT BY MY COMMENTS?I AM S O R R Y.( JUST LIKE AISHWARYA)

 
 
Comment by Lovely
2008-03-24 16:11:57

Mr. above please clean your ears
only ganecra singjh will que in front of aishwarya’s house no-one esle everyone else ahs amde clear whom they prefer
i was hoping this guy would not return to this blog as he had promised

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by devkishin
2008-03-25 12:18:01

YOU ARE RIGHT LOVELY. NO ONE STANDS IN Q BEFORE ANY PLAYBACK SINGER’S HOUSE IN MUMBAI. IT IS ONLY IN FILMS LIKE ABHIMAN

 
 
Comment by Lovely
2008-03-24 16:15:13

For the first time in show’s hisroty ABHAS mde clear whom he prefers. this too from a so-called neyral anchor.becuase evn anchors have ears unlike mr knvijaram
the remarks are made for MR KVNIRANJAN8
i agree with preet sagar thst abhas is a good singer and understands music.unlike that ishmeet whose favourite would have been aishwarya no doubt.s ee now who is doing better-abhas. bad atlent like ishmeet and aishwarya, whetehr they wion or not, cannot proceed.
now AISHWARYA will join PRASHANT and ISHMEET as worst winner in show hsitory…what a trio

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Rupinder
2008-03-25 05:56:26

Lovely,please don’t bring ishmeet into every posy. he si an aberration.
I agree with you Anvesha is far better then aishwarya and I also agree if aishwarya wins it will be a disaster..but lets leave ishmeet out of it ok? Punjab has produced far better talent than Ishmeet

Comment by trados
2008-03-25 07:54:11

Rupinder,
I am also from Punjab and after reading your posts, I am feeling compelled to offer you a piece of advice.

1. You are not a representative of Punjab. So stop saying things on behalf of Punjab state.
2. A true punjabi will be proud of his/her culture (which I think you are) but will also respect
other states and culture (Earlier you learn this better for you)
3. A true punjabi is firm but polite. I feel that you are firm but you lack politeness and etiquettes.
4. A true punjabi should be fearless, polite, humble and firm…

Again, earlier you learn all these, better for you.

I do not know about you upbringing, educational background etc but above are the minimum that one would expect from a punjabi. Apologies if I have hurt you, but if you can follow what I have said, you will see a sea-change in your attitude towards life…

 
Comment by devkishin
2008-03-25 12:29:44

HOW CAN YOU COMMENT THAT ISHMIT IS AN ABERRATION.I HAVE HEARD ISHMIT AND HE WAS AS GOOD AS OTHERS IN THAT SHOW . WE BADLY NEED PLAYBACK SINGERS FROM PUNJAB AS THEY POSSESS RARE GRACE AND CHARM IN ADDITION TO THEIR SINGING TALENT. I STILL REMEMBER SHRADHA FROM PUNJAB WHOSE RENDITION OF “KIS TARAH BHOOLEGA DIL OONKA KHAYAL–’- A NOORJAHAN HIT WHICH IMPRESSED ME IMMENSELY IN ONE OF THE EARLIER EPISODES PF GAJJI’S SAREGAMA.
I WISH I CAN SHOW YOU THIS RECORDING .

Comment by JAY
2008-03-25 14:11:37

Dear music lovers if devkishin thinks Ishmeet was as good as others like Toshi, Abhaas and Harshit then I have nothing to say. Now we know why he supports Aishwarya! Because he DOES NOT understand music at all! Next he’ll say Prashant was as good as Emon, Amit or Deepali!
No point arguing with him.

 
 
 
 
Comment by Pallavi
2008-03-24 16:18:45

All NRI’s are for ASnvesha. I see most bloggers are intelligent here. except maybe 3 or 4 Aishwarya fans who do not know the basics of music. perhaps they should get their ears checked as someone has suggested.

THE BEST IS ANVESHA AND AISHWARYA IS NOWHERE CLOSE TO EEVN SECOND BEST.GEETASHRI, SONIYA AND AREEB WERE ALL BETTER THEN HER BUT GOT ELIMINATED THANKS TO GAJ MAHAAN

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-24 16:44:18

Beauty,Health, intelligence and talent are not the monoploly of any nation,any race ,any country or any region ; it’s randomly distributed.
TRUE TALENT IS HARD TO KEEP DOWN.
In my personal life i have experienced that OVER AND OVER AGAIN.
FEW EXTRAORDINARY EXAMPLES :
1.FIRST ASIAN NOBEL IN LITERATURE IN ASIA >RABINDRA NATH TAGORE NEVER HAD ANY UNIVERSITY EDUCATION.
2.FIRST OSCAR AWARD IN ASIA IN FILM & ARTS> SATYAJIT RAY WAS REJECTED BY GOVT. OF INDIA TO SEND HIS FILM TO BERLIN> GOT BOTH BERLIN & OSCAR AWARDS.
3.BILL-GATE,HARVARD DROP OUT > BECAME THE RICHEST MAN> ESTABLISED MICROSOFT AT THE AGE,17YRS.
4.DHIRUBHAI AMBANI,SON OF A SCHOOL TEACHER,WITH 3RD GRADE EDUCATION STARTED LIFE AS A GAS STATION ATTENDANT,BECAME THE RICHEST CONGLOMERATION OF INDIA AND THE WORLD IN HIS OWN LIFE TIME.
IT’S 90% perspiration + 10% INSPIRATION TO NURTURE THE NATURE TO A FULL BLOOM.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-24 17:01:18

I see,Abhaas has improved tremendously:he has much superior voice quality (deep bass and melody)and he has got this anchor job through which he has been honing his skill, singing and presentation FAR BETTER than any ISHMIT > if he keeps up his self confidence and keeps improving,HE WILL outshine his height by miilion times.
SO this has been blessing in disguise.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by jay
2008-03-24 17:15:11

remark by HE HE should deleted immediately

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Ronnie
2008-03-24 17:17:41

Abhas, in the very begining, told the press in an interview that in his opinion Anwesha is the best singer among all the contestants of ‘CHHOTE USTAAD’.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by jay
2008-03-24 17:56:52

Anyone who understands music will know who has sung which song better. It was sad to see Shreya being not true to musinc as it was not expected from her. This is regarding the show on 22nd march.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Anand
2008-03-24 18:06:31

Mr Devkishen, From your posts, it seems like everyone in the world are kids, everyone in the world are fools, no one understands anything about “ash’s dramabaji”. Only you know everything and your 5 year old kid knows everything. Hats off to you. And btw, you are into big-time mud-slinging you know? First of all you can very well type without the CAPS LOCK on (that’s the first sign of your rudeness) and also, you have to retaliate to every single post with two intentions (a) You are right and (b) Aish is the best. Sure, the whole world is fool, whenever anyone says anwesha is much better, he or she becomes fool. Great! keep it up!
As far as all anwesha fans and supporters go, don’t listen to devkishen and keep voting for anwesha! She is great and as I said before, she could be the best thing that can happen to bollywood music industry in years to come!

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Rupinder
2008-03-25 05:54:26

well said Anand! Such people like Mr. devkishin should be banned from this blog. All he does is bug people who support anvesha.
he is frusterated because he is one of the few Aishwarya supporters here. get a life devkishin jee.
And don’t say anything about punjab..we are not ignorant fools. And we never voted for ishmeet ok..we understand music. We have talents like Rohanpreet and harpreet deol also, why do you bring only ishmeet’s name? your aishwarya is not much better then ishmeet.

 
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-24 18:15:49

Regarding EMOTIONS AND EXPRESSION:

People express their emotions very differntly> educated people who can control their emotions express less >they allow others TO READ THE HEAD LINES> even in distress their expression is subdued.
ON THE OTHER HAND; people who cannot control their emotions ,usually are uneducated(social & scholastic) lower socioeconomic groups >they are usually noisy,full of words and reach emotional HULLABALO with the slightest stimulus.
This overreaction from the hypothalamus ,not controlled by COTREX > is evident in behavior and with little observation can be noticed even by untrained eyes viz.kUNAL ,if you observe always speak first, speak unnecessary and inappropriate diction whereas shreya is reserved mostly.
There is a clear distinction between MRS.MAZMUDER and MRS.DUTTAGUPTA.
THE CLASSIC EXMPLE OF THE 22ND EPISODE WHEN TWO MOTHERS WERE ASKED THEIR FEELINGS FOR THEIR KIDS > ONE wailed up with emotions and brought down devine intervention as destiny and expressed GODLY choked with emotions > the other simply expressed how the idea came ,thanks to admin and saw BOTH children as “chotte ustaad” and her daughters.
DO I NEED TO SAY ANY MORE??
UNFORTUNATLEY, I HAVE SEEN MANY PROFESSIONAL PEOPLE ARE INCAPACITED WTIH THIS EMOTIONAL OVERLAY… I HAVE SEEN IN SURGERY ROOM , SURGEON IS PRAYING LOUD FOR DEVINITY…AND BLAMING GOD WHEN SURGERY FAILS FOR HIS OWN DEFICIENCY..

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-24 18:16:47

FEW TYPOS

 
Comment by JC
2008-03-24 19:46:28

KC
Its NOT MRS its MS or MISS.

 
Comment by JC
2008-03-24 19:47:01

Its NOT MRS its MS or MISS.

Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-24 20:00:59

Mrs.
Function: noun
Inflected Form(s): plural Mes·dames \m?-?däm, -?dam\
1 a—used as a conventional title of courtesy except when usage requires the substitution of a title of rank or an honorific or professional title before a married woman’s surname <spoke to Mrs.DOE
webster.com/dictionary/MRS

 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-24 20:02:19

CAN YOU READ A DICTIONARY?

 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-24 20:04:32

CAN YOU READ A DICTIONARY?
Mr. englishman,
please note
not its >it’s (means it is )

Comment by JC
2008-03-24 20:20:22

I thought you were talking about Anvesha and Aiswarya o.k.? CALM down O.k.? YOU should talk after all the typos you made! Man, where do get the time to blog here all the time don’t you have a job or something? Get a life!

 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-24 20:31:55

that’s none of your business jack ass! JC
CAN YOU READ and understand ENGLISH?
you DON’T UNDERSTAND BETWEEN MOTHER AND DAUGHTER !

 
Comment by JC
2008-03-24 21:04:00

I think he he was right you need to DO you know what and calm down!YOU REALLY NEED TO GET A LIFE MAN. DON’t YOU HAVE ANYTHING ELSE TO DO??
And lots of married women prefferd to be refferd as MS than MRS these days. Which era are you from?

 
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-24 20:18:27

By the way is your mother is Miss/MS?
I DON’T KNOW ANY MOTHER in India as miss /ms.
because they all wed first before become mother. unwed mothers are rare in india, unlike west.

Comment by JC
2008-03-24 21:12:18

YOU DON”T KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT INDIA MR AMERICAN ANYWAY! SO SHUT UP.

 
 
 
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-24 19:41:59

children learn social behavior by mimicry of their parents>well reflected in prakriti,anwesa and aiswyaria.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by drc
2008-03-24 20:21:44

Aishwarya is a mediocre singer with a great voice. Anwesha is an excellent singer with a good voice. This is where the difference lies…

Anyone can have a sweet voice and carry a tune, but how they manage sustain a tune and develop complete control over sur, taal, breath ..etc. is what separates an average singer from a great singer. Anwesha is the most consistent performer of the entire lot. She has hardly ever lost her sur, she manages to sing very difficult with such effortlessness and ease and in between all this, she is also capable of adding in several variations of her own in any given song! Her voice modulation is flawless and the fact that she is still able to hold her sur while attempting very low notes as well as the very high notes is truly commendable.

It was very obvious who the better performer was today. There is only one deserving contestant for the title of chhote ustaad and she is ANWESHA DATTA GUPTA.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Badria
2008-03-24 21:19:34

People can we all just behave in a mature manner and not make this a battle ground for personal issues & comments.
Anvesha or Aishwarya winner or loser…fair or unjust …that should be all that is discussed…Not who you are and and where you are from and name calling….Shame on all who have done so. Pull your socks up and come on guys lets get back on track…Anvesha will be the winner if voted / judged FAIRLY..heeheheheheheheheh…..

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-24 21:44:03

no one can give an honest remark here,some are outrageous in their manners and netiquette,has no decorum >drives you insane!

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by trados
2008-03-25 02:48:19

I totally agree!!! Unless people learn such basic manners and etiquettes, India will remain a 3rd world developing country. Really sad!!

 
 
Comment by kvniranjan8
2008-03-25 02:34:24

Aishwarya’s got the greatest gift from God, a great voice. Perfection is an acquired quality, practice makes perfect, but no amount of practice can make a fabulous voice.
Princess Aishwarya, you’ll be the future Lata Mangeshkar. Don’t worry whether you’ll win now, lose or draw (joint winner), in the long run you’ll be the Queen

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by trados
2008-03-25 02:45:30

kvniranjan8,

Although I do not watch this show regularly and I do not favor any particular contestant, I appreciate your comments where you are expressing your opinion about one contestant without degrading or defaming the other contestant/s. This is the sign of a genuine person. Keep it up!!

Comment by kvniranjan8
2008-03-25 03:59:36

@trados

Thanks a lot, pal. I’d like to request all the bloggers here to follow ur advice. No personal attacks, either on other contestants or on other bloggers, pls.
Musical criticism of other contestants is acceptable

 
Comment by devkishin
2008-03-25 17:46:13

I FULLY AGREE WITH KVNIRANJAN8 AND TRADOS, TO BE IMPARTIAL IS DIVINE! KEEP UP THIS SPIRIT.

 
 
Comment by Pallavi
2008-03-25 05:50:44

mr whoeevr
stop showiong your ignorance. you are music-illiterate person

 
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-25 03:43:28

any body can tell me the song abhaas dedicated to shreya” tumko pya jaise yeha koha hu” the waltz. lyrics and which song from which movie?
thanks

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by trados
2008-03-25 04:16:56

It is from from Om Shanti Om…just google for lyrics and you should have no problem in finding it..

Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-25 04:27:44

thanks

 
 
 
Comment by deven
2008-03-25 05:29:30

you guys have a lot of time arguing/fighting :) anyway, I also wasted some time reading most of these comments, then realize, this is what all makers of program like to achieve… anyways, shreya took breathe away with her performance… I have seen so many live performances, nothing was like this… her singing is as beautiful as she is… Anwesha and Ash has to go a long way to reach upto her level, but both of these girls have a lot of potential for sure.. everyone has their own favorite.. this doesn’t mean we shud pull otherone down.. for me Anwesha has an edge over Aishwarya…

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by devkishin
2008-03-25 17:48:46

100% SANE VOICE DEVEN. HATS OFF TO YOU.

 
 
Comment by Pallavi
2008-03-25 05:48:20

Ronnie,
Thank you for saying Abhas’s interview where abhas has clealry expressed ANVESHA is best. obviously Abhas is a singer who knows music. unlike people like Devkishin, sa, vd, alia and Kvniranjan who pretend they know a lot but expose their ignorance of music.
Such people should not write in such blogs because they bring down its standrds.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Pallavi
2008-03-25 05:49:43

if we had to judge aishwarya indepenadnt of hype and a few ignorant peiople, everyone can say she did not deserve top 2 position.Geetashri was far more deserving, she was close to anvesha in technique but got eliminated thanks to dirty poiltics.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by sheila
2008-03-25 06:14:52

Hi all, would just like to say Voi singers on the whole are emerging better then saregama singers. Look at ABHAS and ANVESHA. such phenomenal talent.They will rule the music industry in days to come. perhaps with a little competion from Abhas’ beloved(as i found out from this blog) ABHILASHA.
Would like to see abhas, anvesha and abhilasha as huge singers in days to come. I also like Emon chatterjee of indian idol 3 and poonam from saregam. oh,not to forget Aneek. Thank you for briging such talents to us through reality televison.
Maybe one day Abhas will be best playback singer male and Anvesha female. hope that does not make Abhilasha jealous.. ha ha

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-25 06:47:35

Final decision:
i think Gajji has changed the format for the final because the judges are unable to distinguish the two finalists as they are both deserving > judges refused to do any further and left the final decision to the public picking ; whoever the public wants.
so now, the public to decide the chotte ustaad grand finale.
public have their own views and i would expect to share their views WITHOUT mud slinging. you are all matured ,so please express yours and let other express their views.
Thank you

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by trados
2008-03-25 07:31:49

Hey doc….what are you talking about? Already there are some 250 comments posted here and you are still asking people to post their opinions?

Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-25 07:52:20

final thoughts, my friend.we donot have many days left and i am leaving after spring break,i had a wonderful time, learnt manythings about NEW india and wonderful talents at such tender age. Actually this was my first experience.
thanks

Comment by trados
2008-03-25 07:59:22

Are you saying that you visited India for first time?

 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-25 08:16:20

after 30yrs.first in delhi.wonderful> i feel at home> but lots of change, NEW INDIA.

 
 
 
 
Comment by jack
2008-03-25 08:58:30

after seeing this episode one thing I would like to say that why the judges are not making true comments on the songs of aish and annu are singing….

in “Bairy piya” aish made at least 6 mistakes … which can be detected by any one ( no need to have musical funda…) … if bad comments are gven for prakiti’s singing then why not aish this time…. I think this is the worst performance by aish till so far….
even annu made 1/2 mistakes in ” kambaqt ishq”… in male voice part ( sukhwinder singh’s part) I think she could not reach at that scale of male’s voice…
BOTH AISH AND ANNU ARE HAVING SOME PROBLEMS WITH THEIR VOICES… I THINK BECAUSE OF TOO MUCH PRESSURE AND CONTINOUS SINGING …. THEY SHOULD BE GIVEN A BREAK BEFORE FINALE….

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Ronnie
2008-03-25 19:46:36

Jack
Man you’re so naive! The Judges know ,Specially Kunal,who the best singer is and that is obviously Anwesha. Gajji wants Aish to win – you want proof?
Here it is :
1. Aish rides like a Queen on her own elephant and the rest had to share because Gajji has no money to rent 3 elephants.Then at least he could have put all of them on one elephant right?

2.In the episodes preceding Bhopal, Anwesha was given garbage songs to sing when Aish got Albela and chori chori. Supposedly Anu had no control on song selection when others had some flexibility! How unfair is that? He just wanted to bring Aish somewhat close to Anu’s standard. That’s not favouritism then what is?
3. When Kunal didn’t want to give Aish any marks after ‘AYE RE ‘ , he was forced to do so by Gajji. But nothing was said to Preetam And Shreya (OBVIOUSLY THEY LOVED DOLA RE DOLA) and they were not ordered to to give marks! There is no set rule in this show and that’s just amazing!It’s A ONE MAN SHOW!!
4. How Bhopal and Jaipur were chosen ?? Surely they can’t be the highest voters! ThOSE PLACES were chosen to promote Abhas and Shreya(who was born in Rajasthan)obviously.And Pratriti was the favourite in Jaipur?- please give me a break o.k.?
So Gajji is doing whatever He wants. Now he changed the rules again to 100% Public voting so that His favourite Aish can win. He knows very well that all the judges know music very well and they are going to vote for the only superbly talented singer, ANWESHA.Why all the farce?? Lets just annonce Aish as the CHHote Ustaad ALL RIGHT?lET’S NO PLAY ANYMORE GAMES!

 
 
Comment by devkishin
2008-03-25 10:53:34

judges comments are meaningless now since all the powers to decide the winner have been given to voters.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by jack
2008-03-25 12:04:34

@ devkishin,

is this the reason behind not making comments on bad performance?

if they can do this then what is points of believing all those comments they made before?

if kunal can not compromise with his musical sentiment then why he was silent after listening ais’s performance?

Comment by devkishin
2008-03-25 12:40:32

LET US FORGET THE PAST BITTERNESS GENERATED BY PRAKRITI’S ELIMINATION. THE JUDGES WERE ATTACKED BY ALMOST EVERYONE BECAUSE OF THEIR HARSH COMMENTS AND THAT HAD ADVERSE EFFECT ON THEIR MINDS. THEY WERE JUST SPECTATORS AT JAIPUR AS THEY WERE GREATLY SHAKEN BY THE COMMENTS OF THE VIEWERS AS WELL AS PRAKRITI’S AUNT RITADEVI.
I PERSONALLY WILL MISS THEM. THEY WERE JOLLY INDIVIDUALS.A GREAT ENTERTAINERS.

 
 
 
Comment by devkishin
2008-03-25 10:58:48

The Delhi episode has either been already recorded or in the process of recording. The voting trends are likely to be announced in the episode to be telecast on Friday

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by devkishin
2008-03-25 11:06:26

aAfter two episodes at Delhi most likely to be recorded on the same day one more episode is likely to be recorded at Mumbai for Friday ,april the 4th telecast. The finale on 5th april is likely to be a deffered telecst of a recording on same day. The show generally commences around 6/7 pm and the telecast around 8/9 pm

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by sheila
2008-03-25 13:40:46

I agree with jack.the judges are not giving public correct guidance. How will people then know that Anvesha needs to win? judges should take a stand here.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by JAY
2008-03-25 13:50:01

Trados

Where were you when S A and Kvniranjan8 made those racial remarks against the bengalis?? I didn’t hear you say anything when Devkishin made comments like a total Hindu fundamentalist! Please try to be fair – don’t just pick on an individual!

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by trados
2008-03-27 04:47:29

JAY,
I want to make one thing very clear…I am against each and every individiual who is making racial comments here…I am not going to except such behaviour from any one whether that person is SA, niranjan, rupinder or whomsoever…For past few hundred years people divided and ruled over India…India has lost enough..I will not let this happen again. My balls are on fire and I will fight with each and every racist till my last breath..Hope I am making myself clear!!!!!

 
 
Comment by JAY
2008-03-25 14:12:38

Dear music lovers if devkishin thinks Ishmeet was as good as others like Toshi, Abhaas and Harshit then I have nothing to say. Now we know why he supports Aishwarya! Because he DOES NOT understand music at all! Next he’ll say Prashant was as good as Emon, Amit or Deepali!
No point arguing with him.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by devkishin
2008-03-26 08:18:20

Ishmit was the only contestant who possessed cinematic voice.His voice will suit any top male artist of the present era. Thats all. No further comments .I have just expressed my personal opinion and I stick to it.

 
 
Comment by jack
2008-03-25 14:25:39

@ devji,

perhaps, u r right that we shud forget everything, concentrate on music only and look ahead…. as far as ppl of this forum keep discussing on music only just by being honest to their soul…..
some ppl are fanatics … which I think are very common in every reality show… and there is no harm of admitting that….

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by deven
2008-03-25 15:54:30

After listening to all mp3 songs of Anwesha, I listed the following songs as exceptional:

Aao Na – perfect singing, it is a listening pleasure, shows she can hit a big time as a commercial singer.

Ami Je Tumar – I know if I’ll point out mistake in this song, people will kill me.. First word came out of my mouth when I first heard her rendition is “WOW”.. after hearing a lot many times, I could see some nasal touches… as Shreya has pointed it out clearly, she can improve on this easily.. which means, wait, you will going to see a top class singer soon..

Hum dil de chuke sanam – her rendition can take your breathe away.. I compared it a lot with the original.. definitly this one sounds much better than the original.. mistakes are there, but can be easily ignored..

Nimbuda – I recommend you to hear the original and anwesha’s rendition… words sounded more clearer coming from anwesha than kavita.. check it out..

Mujhe Rang De – I have the original in my audio CD and I always use to skip it.. but I could not skip anwesha’s one.. here I won’t say that she sang it better than original.. no ways.. but something in her voice make you listen to it again and again.. No Nasal thing.. She has already improved a lot.. and surely ready for playback.. beware Shreya finally u have a strong competition coming ur way :) ..

Mausam Ki Adla Badli mein – Listen to this rendition carefully.. she didn’t miss out the best part of it.. I searched for this song on net after listening to this..

Jane Kiya chahe man – After listening to the audio of this song, I was thinking that her rendition shall be made part of that movie audio CD now, cos it is definitly better than Zubin’s version :)

It is hard to fit all songs’ review here since she sang all of her songs sooo well :) … I saw that one too where (tune chor) Pritam gave bad comments to her and made her cry.. I was so furious at him on that episode :) .. I liked the way Salman treated him in a later episode..

I am big fan of Anwesha and therefore liked all her songs.. she made mistakes couple of times in her songs, but overall she was very consistent.. Her voice is a listening pleasure.. She seems to have an excellent knowledge of music at this age.. above all she is sooo humble.. You should give credit to her to sing all those songs so consistently well, which I could not see it any other contestants from this or anyother shows..

This doesn’t mean that Aishwarya is not upto the mark to compete against her.. There were some of songs where she scored over Anwesha (whatever may be the reasons).. Her standout performances were Albela Sajaan and Chori Chori.. She sounded better than Anwesha in “man kiyon Behka” duet..

Also I heard “man mohana” from Aishwarya and “Ek Radha Ek Meera” from Anwesha many times.. Well, Aish song was much tougher and and she sang it really well.. but Anwesha made her song more beautiful by her singing.. Aish got most of the praise in that episode while Anwesha didn’t get much.. this was definitly not fair…

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by deven
2008-03-25 16:12:05

Just heard “Hum Dil De Chuke Sanam” from Anwesha again.. I get goose pimples all the time I hear her rendition of this song and this time was no exception.. this is called consistency :) .. Whatelse you want in a winner… anyways, We haven’t seen a deserving winner in any of the reality shows… See the examples.. Indian Idol 1 – abhijit sawant won while Amit sana, the runner up was better.. II2 – Sandeep was not deserving to be in final and still he won.. Karunya was much much better.. singers like monali thakur and Amit were eliminated much earlier.. II3 – there is no comparision of Amit and Prashant.. Prashant himself admitted many times that Amit is the best, still he lost.. Saregamapa last year has Poonam, Amanat and Raja who were in that order as per their singing quality, still the person deserving to be on 4th position won.. Saregamapa Lil champ.. the best contestent was Smita Nandi.. she was made to eliminated by judges biased comments.. Anamika won.. she was better than other top 3, but defintly no where close to Smita.. SVOI, definitly Abhas was better than other lot and I was just surprised to see ishmit and harshit as top 2, and toshi eliminated much before… wow…

So no surprise if Anwesha doesn’t win this…

I like the way Gaji manipulated the voting systems timings… 50% judges 50% janata, till Prakriti was there… once she was gone, focus shifted to earn the maximum money from janata.. reason given, judges feel offended by janata’s comments or something.. give me a break.. how easy to fool indian janta… they will give votes in crores and make these people rich on the name of these talented kids…

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by JAY
2008-03-25 19:08:59

i agrre with you about everything but in my opinion I think Aneek was much better definitely than Raja , who was a besuara,and somewhat better than Amanat. About Poonam and Aneek , I don’t know, they were both equally good.

Comment by deven
2008-03-26 01:23:06

u know what.. I need to agree with you here.. initially I used to think that amanat is better than raja and aneek.. I downloaded mp3 of all these singers.. I have all songs of amanat, 4-5 songs of Raja, all songs of poonam and 2 songs of Aneek.. After giving a careful listening to all, I concluded this.. Poonam sounded the best of all.. Aneek’s 2 songs “In Dino” and “Chand Mera Dil” were excellent.. Raja sang those two songs “mahiya” and “naina thag lenge” well, but otherwise he was bad in most of his performances.. Amanat has a big drawback.. he pronounces “yeh” as “je” and that spoils most of his songs.. but I still say, “Poonam” was the best singer there in all means.. In my opinion only :) Let’s see if she is so good, she can prove it in coming future… Only if our brilliant Anwesha give her a chance :)

 
Comment by Martha
2008-03-26 08:20:38

Jay
I agree with you.Poonam and Aneek were a class apart. They fall in the category of Anbhas, Anvesha. That is called perfection, dedication, love for music which sounds in every note.

If we listen to Poonam and Anvesha, we see the enermous female talent we have in india. both have that passion which unites them.they come from different backgrounds, fiancial and social settings are different, poonam is 26 yrs old and Anvesha 14 yet the common factor is a love for singing, a quest for perfectibility and a search for the divine through singing. i am not even going into technical aspects becuase both are near perfect. i just want to say that these two are singers which can bring tears to your eyes.

Abhas and Aneek are young adults at 18, more headstrong as boys that age are bound to be and definitely excellent singers. i want them to be Mohammed rafi and kishore Kumar of future. i feel Abhas was a little distracted because of his obvious fondness for Abhilasha and the two were definitely in love.i could make that out,and that took a toll on both Abhas and Abhilasha’s immediate focus. Same for Aneek. Though there was nothing between him and sumedha, all the hyped romance made it out to be a big deal.But these boys can do very well.

 
 
 
Comment by deven
2008-03-25 16:31:16

Whatever anybody says about the program, it’s dramabazi etc.. we are here becos we liked it.. I don’t have a star tv channel here in US, but I follow it regularly starting with spoiler result and then videos of the friday and saturday’s shows.. mostly I used to watch Anwesha’s and Aishwarya’s performances, but then I started looking into other things that were surfacing, like ill treatment of Prakriti etc… Well, I noticed that with all her limitations, she was not that bad.. Go by her age, she has done a good job.. comments given by all judges to her were not fair at all.. true, somebody pointed it out that too that way judges never pointed the mistakes done by Aishwarya.. she was not as consistent as Anwesha… why prakriti was always targetted.. why pritam has to comment that we should stop eliminating kids as it affect them?.. did he and other ever think the same about Prakriti, whom they insulted like anything?.. all those episode make me boil with anger for these guys…

And by the way why we are dividing India by these regionalism things… by asking darjling to vote for prakriti.. bengal for anwesha and gujrat for aish.. these shows are creating more problem for us, indians.. why can’t we learn from movies like “Chak De” if we can’t think about these things ourselves.. why prakriti is asked to say “jai gorkhaland”… all of these are so ridiculous.. we are injecting all these in kids… here also we are fighting with eachother based on regionalism… future doesn’t look that bright for India…

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-25 18:46:49

i think kunal is more abnormal than pritam.

 
 
Comment by Preet Sagar
2008-03-25 16:37:29

DEvshikin ji is an undecuated man. he thinks Ishmeet is good, when a punjabi herself says that Ishmeet was an aberration. Way to go d4ev ji. you are extremely biased.
no wonder you support Aishwarya. she is here only on gaj’s daya we all know that. I think mr dev should be banned from this blog.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by devkishin
2008-03-26 08:24:46

KINDLY REFER TO MY COMMENTS ON ISHMIT HEREINABOVE
GOD BLESS THIS GOLDEN TALENT PROM THE LAND OF FIVE RIVERS.

 
 
Comment by deven
2008-03-25 16:40:47

I guess after mughals and british, it is chinese to exploit this weekness of ours to rule on us :) Just mentioning chinese, but it can be anyone… they just need to see Chote Ustaad and see people fighting over here to exploit our weekness.. we can never unite… after 70+ years we were not in world cup for our national game, hockey… all of these pointing to same one thing that we are not united… It is high time that we shall start learning this fact, appreciate the real talent and help them to come up for our betterment.. give them all facilities to rise… our future is dependent on how this young generation take it forward… kids like Anwesha, Aishwarya, Prakriti, Vyom etc are all well talented.. we shall give them a healthy platform to grow… same goes for all other fields.. keep them away from regionalism, castism, racism etc… there shall be only one focus… growth of India.. and that I guess is the essence of “Chote Ustaad” as well…

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-25 18:44:15

100% correct

 
 
Comment by Preet Sagar
2008-03-25 16:47:33

AISHWARYA is worse than ISHMEET at least ishmeet did not bribe anyone
he at least won only on popular support not plitics

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by jay
2008-03-25 16:50:05

Anwesha, looking at songs you have sung in past, I think you should sing classical songs in your next performances – at least include one classical in most of your remaining performances – on 28 march/29 march, 4 april , 5 april as well.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-25 19:23:27

FOR ANWESHA:whatever song Anwesha chooses should include her strength :1.high pitch 2.classical nodes
These two will bring her noticeable and on higher octave she has no parallel. shreya’s comment”she has surpassed me”(the song dola ..dedicated by anwesha) is a true tribute to her accolade.
pop types are cheap never suits her voice> ref:Talat Mahmood<king of Ghazal used to advise his students :not to shout,not to speak very loud etc.
vocal cord does stretch after shouting in a game, makes it hoarse but tear or nodule also takes permanent damage.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by deven
2008-03-25 19:41:53

I think Anwesha has sung non-classical songs quite well too. Listen to Aao na, jaane kiya chahe man, Mausam ki.. she has such a sweet voice.. Her classical background reflects in all of her renditions… she has a very sober and intelligent personality too.. even her stage presence looks good.. I found her parents really well mannered and good.. Her mother always bear a composure of a very good personality, which reflects in Anwesha’s on stage presence as well… and talent of this girl… oh my God !!! I have her songs in my IPod and I prefer listening to her over “Jannat” and “Metro” songs.

Aish is no less though… see the video of her in youtube, where she has sung “chalo tumko lekar chalein” song when she was much younger.. that was amazing too.. she is a nutkhat kid.. watch her video of chori chori.. how coolly she sung that song while doing all those isharas to Salman… I have seen contestants and judges getting subdued by his presence and remarks in Saregamapa and here too.. But here I saw a girl who boldly presented herself and performed wonderfully.

And how can you forget Prakriti.. At this young age, how well he performed in front of such a big audience.. I bet you take her to a recording studio and you will find a unique, pleasing voice like no other.. If people liked Monali Thakur in race songs, surely they will find something new in Prakriti’s voice too..

I didn’t listen to other contestants of the show, so I donno how good or bad they are.. But these three deserves to be praised and liked by all.. Once, this show will get over, we’ll feel a big void, but we’ll forget them like the contestants of other shows.. so my heart says, why can’t this shows go on and on, and we keep on listening to these gems week after week.. It may sound silly but I feel so proud to see their performances as if they are my daughters :)

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Anonymous
2008-03-26 06:52:52

Do you happen to have the video of Aish’s ‘tumko lekar chalein’? I can’t find it anywhere on youtube!

Comment by deven
Comment by Anonymous
2008-03-26 23:08:40

Thanks so much deven!
You’re right, she was pretty good even at that young age. Was she singing in front of the Mangeshkar sisters? I think her voice-quality has matured substancially since then though…

 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-28 02:51:36

Thanks deven for the videolinks.
This child ,AISWYRIA from very early age has been trained to be a singer and stage presenter.
most amazing is her stage free appearence.
i would like to give speacial thanks to parents who understood this child potential and helped the journey.

Thanks.

 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-28 02:52:51

AISWYARIA

 
 
 
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-25 19:44:51

FOR AISWYARIA:
she has breathing difficulty so she might not keep a sutained pitch for a period.medium pitch suites her best.she may rise to the heigh but has to fall sharply instead of slope.some may not like that.
she also has classical-node interrupts for a better performance.she definitely accentuates her pronunication of Hindi lyrics better than any body else >gives her the edge and makes the song meaningful.
she is very stage free and her facial expression and gestures are very matured for live performance.she is unparalleled.
Even when she speaks she gestures with hand and eyes> when she sings her facial, eyes ,body curving and free hand swings out her hip gives her perfect stage appeal of a woman singer than a child.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Ronnie
2008-03-25 19:47:47

Jack
Man you’re so naive! The Judges know ,Specially Kunal,who the best singer is and that is obviously Anwesha. Gajji wants Aish to win – you want proof?
Here it is :
1. Aish rides like a Queen on her own elephant and the rest had to share because Gajji has no money to rent 3 elephants.Then at least he could have put all of them on one elephant right?

2.In the episodes preceding Bhopal, Anwesha was given garbage songs to sing when Aish got Albela and chori chori. Supposedly Anu had no control on song selection when others had some flexibility! How unfair is that? He just wanted to bring Aish somewhat close to Anu’s standard. That’s not favouritism then what is?
3. When Kunal didn’t want to give Aish any marks after ‘AYE RE ‘ , he was forced to do so by Gajji. But nothing was said to Preetam And Shreya (OBVIOUSLY THEY LOVED DOLA RE DOLA) and they were not ordered to to give marks! There is no set rule in this show and that’s just amazing!It’s A ONE MAN SHOW!!
4. How Bhopal and Jaipur were chosen ?? Surely they can’t be the highest voters! ThOSE PLACES were chosen to promote Abhas and Shreya(who was born in Rajasthan)obviously.And Pratriti was the favourite in Jaipur?- please give me a break o.k.?
So Gajji is doing whatever He wants. Now he changed the rules again to 100% Public voting so that His favourite Aish can win. He knows very well that all the judges know music very well and they are going to vote for the only superbly talented singer, ANWESHA.Why all the farce?? Lets just annonce Aish as the CHHote Ustaad ALL RIGHT?lET’S NO PLAY ANYMORE GAMES!

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-25 19:58:10

remarkable observations!very good.

 
Comment by Avi
2008-03-25 23:00:45

Great points touched Ronnie. I hate this un-ethical and dishonesty in “DES” that goes on ! ahh! When shall we become honest in our activities!

Comment by Martha
2008-03-26 07:43:00

WELL SAID RONNIE!! EVERY OBSERVATION OF YOURS IS 100% CORREXT. GAJJI CHANGES RULES ACCORDING TO HIS CONVENIANCE.
Just see earlier he made 50-50 gormat and now in finals, just to benfit ash, he has made it pure public voting.
So many times he promotes his favourites. And the ballot voting is a hoax

Comment by daddu
2008-03-27 04:39:54

martha…if you have problem with this guy called Gajendra Singh…why dont you start your own show? People like you who do not do anything except pointing fingers are of no use…just try to sing a song in front or give a lecture in front of 10-15 people and you will realize how tough it is…bamboo laag jaata hai..samjhi kya?

 
Comment by Rupinder
2008-03-27 13:48:55

Why don’t you mind your business daddu? perverts like you should go to other blogs, not blogs for music lovers. People like you just know how to make negative comments.

 
 
 
 
Comment by deven
2008-03-25 19:58:44

guys, sorry for the typo in my comments above.. I wonder, if I can make mistake in writing, we shall spare these girls who are performing live in front of such a big audiences, instead of degrading them (for kunal and shreya).. We shall ignore their small mistakes as they are very young and have to sing in one take..

drama etc are introduced by the makers of this show and not by these contestants .. they have come here with bundle of talent.. our job is to appreciate their talents and not find faults.. at this age, they themselves knows much more than all of us here about music.. they have time to work on their shortcomings and become top stars in future.. We shall feel ourselves privileged to see these talents in our times..

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-25 20:07:27

i must admit these youngsters those who are participating in this analysis have more knowledge of MUSIC,SOCIETY and indian politics than me. they may not know the past but they are well-groomed wtih their observations and inference.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-25 20:11:20

There is a tell-tale sign of the end result.

 
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-25 20:22:07

i have one question : i would request for a sure answer nothe guess!
question:two parts.
1. who decides the song for each contestant?
2.is these are all pre-recorded and then lip-synching on stage? or live and not pre- recorded.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-25 20:32:04

correction:
2.are these all pre-recorded?

Comment by jack
2008-03-25 21:42:37

starting with Dr. Biswas,

all these reality shows have their own music directors who are responsible for selecting songs, preparing tracks etc. It is obvious that the last words are given by Gajji. In some of the ocassions lip singing are there. Because sometimes producers do not want to take risks in front of huge crowd. One example: just see carefully the last part of this episode : shreya ghosal’s singing is prerecorded….

adding something to Ronnie… my predictions:

1. Anwesha is going to get maximum votes in Delhi … she is going to get the ” Taj” this time…

2. After seeing the above thing the aish’s fan will give more and more votes …..
just think over it …. what a plan from gajji… it is no different from Ekta Kapoor’s serials….

Comment by deven
2008-03-26 01:10:18

Oh My Gosh.. U r right.. Shreya’s performance was lipsynched.. I watched it carefully and could able to see the traces of it.. Shaqs feel dejected as I thought her live performance was the one of the best.. I was thinking that she has given a good reply to Anwesha, but I was wrong.. Now I feel that even Anwesha has an edge over her.. Listen to “Barso Re” song by Anwesha.. Shreya sang mukhra after Anwesha finished singing and defintly Anwesha was sounded much much better.. In Ami Je Tomar song, Shreya just sang one line and her breathing was clearly audible, while Anwesha’s version was smooth..

Let Anwesha come to recording studio once.. Salman has rightly said to these guys that these kids will take their job away.. the way they took it from Alka, Anuradha etc..

 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-26 02:07:42

I have never seen any live performances which are NOT pre-recorded in USA (they are highly technical with lights and sound in such a way that even at the first row audience would never be able to detect)viz. Boyance and Hulio Iglesias ;they are all pre-recorded and tele-prompted even to the last smile.
Boyance’s movement is so fast and electric that will mesmerize you on stage,her voluptuous figure and dynamite energy will charm the audience and gives no space to feel other way.(FOR first time, you will realise WHAT A BLACK BEAUTY MEANS )
HULIO IGLESIAS: Voice was meant for love songs;ETHEREAL ,his spanish accent with melody will penetrate your heart in such a way that you don’t need to know the spanish lyrics!BEFORE YOU KNOW, YOU ARE ALREADY IN LOVE!

 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-26 04:41:30

Boyance > Beyonce’ (she is Louisiana Creole)

 
 
 
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-26 01:20:09

QUESTIONS:
1.What benefit Gaj ji gets out of public voting?
2.why does he select cities like Bhopal ,jaipur than other cities?

3.How does he manage his financial gain from these reality shows ?..is it through indian tv channels or commercials?

4.what is the position of Gajji in Bollywood film industry?

Please give an honest answer<not guess!
Thank you

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by kvniranjan8
2008-03-26 02:38:15

If I had money to buy 2 albums, I’d go out and buy one of Aishwarya and one of Anwesha.

If I had money to buy only 1 album, I’d buy one of Aishwarya and steal one of Anwesha.

If I had no money, I’d beg for one of Aishwarya and borrow one of Anwesha.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by devkishin
2008-03-26 08:37:46

EXCELLENT WAY OF EXPRESSING YOU OPINION ON THIS BLOG .SUCH GEMS CAN COME FROM A GREAT HUMOURIST.KEEP IT UP KVN

 
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-26 03:38:12

DESTINY,devine intervention, GOD SENT, SUPER NATURAL,RAM RAM,AVATAR,ALLAH’S FARISTA, TABIZ,astrology ,numerology and fortune tellers who always refer “nata mastak’” flowery language,”emotinal hullabaloo” = fake and idotic to my dictionary(Some people say it’s humble expression ,some say soft indian culture, TO ME IS A CONCEALING IGNORANCE)
hard work,honesty and decency >gets a beating in India !! (I SIMPLY, ADORE THESE YOUNGSTERS WHO STRUGGLE AGAINST THESE CORRUPT SYSTEM IN INDIA! WE BLAME THESE INNOCENT YOUTHS!!) will the truthful and real talent win? will a talent be honored in a country,where “staya meyba jayatye’ becomes “asythya meybo jayate” IN REALITY.
WHERE WE DON’T HESITATE TO ADULTERATE BABY FOOD! WORSHIPPING DURGA STATUE BUT KILLING LIVING DURGA IN WOMB!

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-26 03:40:44

TYPO;sathya ,asathya …

 
 
Comment by deven
2008-03-26 04:24:18

sorry guys.. more I listen to both of them, more I am inclining towards Anwesha.. She is coming in my list of top singers now.. well for me ultimate singer is Lata, followed by Shreya.. for me third is poonam.. and the fourth entry is of Anwesha… I guess the way things are going, soon Anwesha wud be after Lata (whom nobody can replace)..

Now it doesn’t matter whether Anwesha wins or not. More important is she should get some projects so that we get to hear her recording room voice.. I want to confirm whether she can beat shreya or not..

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by well wiisher
2008-03-26 04:28:04

Hi all.today I saw 22nd episode.All who r telling that Anwesha is far better than Aish ,then please check out once.I agree Aish devdas song has some mistakes,but Anwesh’s dola re dola is also not cpmparable to Srey’s ,too much nasal voive.So both are eqal.Far more to learn to get upto Shreya.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-26 06:25:03

FOR WELL WISHER (YOUR NAME IS MR.HYDE & JACKLE)
There is no nasal intonation in high pitch in “dola rey>ANWESHA IS NOT UNDER ANY ORDINARY TALIM MAN >SRI JAYANTA SARKAR (DISCIPLE OF PANDIT AJAY CHAKRABORTY),CLASSICAL GURU OF TOP OF THE LINE IN CALCUTTA. IDOTIC EXPRESSION to feel good by repeating some loose comments by shreya Ghosal will not prove your expertise.DID
YOU HEAR WHAT SHREYA GOHASL SAID”SHE PASSED MY RANGE! WHEN I CAME TO THE STAGE I CLOUDN’T SPEAK” MANY PEOPLE HAVE no knowledge and simply blab their MOUTH!
THEY DONT’ KNOW WAHT THEY ARE SAYING! SHREYA GHOSAL’S CHILDHOOD TRAINING IS FAR FAR BEHIND ANWESHA DUTTAGUPTA >FROM MUSICAL GENIUSES OF CALCUTTA. THE RAJASTAHN DON’T HAVE THAT! IT IS THE MUSICAL MECCA OF INDIA .JUST VICTIMISED BY DIRTY POLITICS OF INDIA.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bKldYV3-S2o&NR=1
THIS IS EARLY SHREYA GHOSAL >COMPARE IT ,MAN!!

Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-26 06:47:25

http://www.hummaa.com/popplayer.php?id=121871&pltype=lc&plrtype=song&plsrc=&param=&rand=0.5863991956447666
9 YRS OLD ANWESHA RECORDED THIS.
JATILESWAR MUKHOPADHYA IS NOT AN ORDINARY COMPOSER TO GIVE THIS SONG TO A 9YR OLD,BECAUSE SHE DESERVED IT
HER BENGALI CLASSICAL SONGS ARE UNPARALLELED. SMT. LATA MANGESHKAR HAS SUNG MANY BENGALI SONGS WITH MELLIFLUOUS VOICE BUT IT LACKS BENGALI ACCENT (LAZA), VITAL TO BENGALI LANGUAGE -IT’S NOT POSSIBLE FOR A NON-BENGALI TO SPEAK BENGALI THAT WILL EXPRESS DIFFERENT EMOTIONS..IN EACH DIFFERNT ACCENT!!!

Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-26 07:27:35

That’s why lata mangeshkar and many other Non-bengali great atrists didn’t try with Rabindra sangeet because to give emotions of Bengali lyrics is the most difficult.they all tired experiments but results were far from expectations.
where lyrics comes alive ,carrying a deep message of whisper that will decipher to unison only , is rabibdra sageet; many songs even carry several ragas in combinations to express that deep underlying (”bhav”)philosophy.
it creates that celestial feelings of upanishads and brahma snageet alltogather.Many english renditions have become insipid creations that have completly changed the texture of Music.

 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-26 07:28:58

I appologise for few typos

 
 
 
Comment by devkishin
2008-03-26 08:45:16

GENUINE COMMENTS FROM A REAL IMPARTIAL MUSIC LOVER. I TOTALLY AGREE WITH YOU . KEEP IT UP MAN.THE ALMIGHTY HAS BLESSED YOU WITH SOME RARE QUALITY OF INDEPENDENT AND PROPER JUDGEMENT-A RARE COMMODITY NOW A DAYS!
WELL SAID -well wiisher.

 
 
Comment by Anonymous
2008-03-26 05:22:47

Hey Anu fans, less talk more vote!
I’m 1oo% positive that she is lagging behind in votes. Instead of trying to argue who is better between the two A’s, Aish fans are doing the right thing and are voting their heart out for their favourite. They are far ahead in the voting, trust me. The reason why there are hardly any Aish fans in this blog isn’t because she doesn’t have any fans, it’s because they are all frantically voting for her! Anwesha fans are too busy trying to prove that Anu is better. We all know this! Now go vote for her!
A reliable source has informed me that Anwesha is very much behind in the online voting. So go sign up with multiple ID’s and vote for her (You can vote 20 times). There’s not much time left! Once she’s lagging, she’ll have a hard time catching up, she will lose this for sure!

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Martha
2008-03-26 08:23:39

Jay
I agree with you.Poonam and Aneek were a class apart. They fall in the category of Anbhas, Anvesha. That is called perfection, dedication, love for music which sounds in every note.

If we listen to Poonam and Anvesha, we see the enermous female talent we have in india. both have that passion which unites them.they come from different backgrounds, fiancial and social settings are different, poonam is 26 yrs old and Anvesha 14 yet the common factor is a love for singing, a quest for perfectibility and a search for the divine through singing. i am not even going into technical aspects becuase both are near perfect. i just want to say that these two are singers which can bring tears to your eyes.

Abhas and Aneek are young adults at 18, more headstrong as boys that age are bound to be and definitely excellent singers. i want them to be Mohammed rafi and kishore Kumar of future. i feel Abhas was a little distracted because of his obvious fondness for Abhilasha and the two were definitely in love.i could make that out,and that took a toll on both Abhas and Abhilasha’s immediate focus. Same for Aneek. Though there was nothing between him and sumedha, all the hyped romance made it out to be a big deal.But these boys can do very well if they give music their all like Poonam and Anvesha have.

I don’t think poonam and anvesha are better in terms of technical stuff. its just that they did not let love, romance, family, friends in fact anything come between their ove for music. Abhas and Aneek should learn from them

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Avi
2008-03-26 11:58:58

Martha – Please try to listen more carefully and then pass a statement like “…anvesha are better in terms of technical stuff”… I do not know about Poonam but Anwesha is hardcore technical… You can visit her website and get to know about her technical acheivements/awards.. she is thorugh trained I will strongly disagree with you. She is probably one of the most techy competitior that has happened in the history of reality singing shows in the last decade.

 
 
Comment by jack
2008-03-26 08:25:07

I really love the way KVNIRANJAN8 has been supporting Aish… he is a fan of Aish and he accepts that…I really appreciate his sentiments…

It should be the way of being a fan of anybody … Aish is having a huge potential to become a good play back singer and we all know that…. KV is standing behind her in bad time also… great going …

and voting can make a winner but can not make a good singer… if any body deservs to be a successful singer he/ she is definitely going to be ….

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by daddu
2008-03-27 04:35:54

jack…tu bahut sahi baat bola re…

 
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-26 08:26:20

EXCELLENT !!!! I AM GETTING YOUNGER!!!
140 VOTES SENT TO ANWESHA DUTTA GUPTA.MANY OF THESE YOUNG FREINDS 100% CORRECT >I AM HERE IN DELHI>> TEMP IS VERY HIGH >EVERY BODY SAID THE SAME, ONE OF OUR FRIENDS SAID BEFORE. WE FINISHED OUR MOBILE QUOTA FROM 3 MOBILES.ANY FURTHER SUGGESTION?
IS SMS VOTING IS AS MUCH ACCPETABLE AS ONLINE VOTING???
ANY OTHER SECRETS? OF THIS GAME>PLEASE ADVISE>HELP.
THANKS

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-26 16:59:26

2)For each has to decide out of the two according to his/her choice.
some people have suggested to vote for both,DOESN’T MAKE ANY SENSE.THE CONTESTANTS ARE TWO AND ARE YOU VOTING BOTH ?>TOTALLY ILLOGICAL.
you will have to take a decision for one but as i said that doesn’t mean the other is LESS deserving.It’s personal choice:PURELY on each sense of judgement> i would request people to respect other’s views.
Thanks.

 
 
Comment by Martha
2008-03-26 08:30:10

I just feel that in the age group of 16-24 young adults are bound to be more hedonistic. Abhas and Abhilasha fell in love and that became a priority for them.nothing wrong in that! But that did take a toll on their singing and performance, especially young Abhilasha. Abhas manged better but at times their love for each other overtook their love for singing.
I do want to see them married and they will definitely make a talented couple. Same goes for Rahul Vaidya and Prajakta Shukre of indian idol 1, Puja and Emon of indian idol 3. They became distracted and that is not the best thing to do in a reality hsow.

However singers like Shreya and Sunidhi in past and Poonam and Anvesha in present have given music their 100% focus. they are bound to do well, because even Anvesha could have been distracted because of vyom and poonam because of raja. Both raja and vyom were more than a little interested in them. however I salute their spirit of commitment to music.

that is hwere I feel poonam and Anvesha scored over equally good Aneek and Abhas– commitment, passion and love for their art.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Avi
2008-03-26 11:53:19

Ahhh… no more page 3 news please who is with whom an all…

Comment by Martha
2008-03-26 12:59:32

Mr avi it is not page 3 news. i am just commenting. iI was genuinely dissapointed with Abhilasha’s lack of focus. that was the main reason of her vote out. A 17 yr old girl should know that music is her first priority in a musical show.
And Abhas himself is doing well now-why? because he has no distraction and Abhilasha is not present all the time. otherwise 2 great talents would have been ruined.
Abhas and Abhilasha are as good as Anvesha here. And i am not saying Anvesha is not technical– she is. i am just saying her love for music dominates over anything else.

 
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-26 16:31:47

FLARE OF HORMONES:
14yrs/15yrs hormones at peak climb> reaches its best 18yrs/19yrs>makes its gradual slope>so is AMOR> love.puppy love .lust. everything.
to rein the 5 horses is very difficult >
AS strong sense of Guidence takes place due to circumstances where socio-economic factor may sway your decision,religion is another one>
Every profession requires its severe disciplines to climb to top,sometimes sacrificing others> parents,specially mother’s influence is very important.
Brain and Body will surivive the tidal waves and by 22 if undergraduates have been finished, a definite course of life has been chosen: IS THE BEST TIME TO CHOOSE A PARTNER: a girl and boy should be of equal age they both at that time fully matured(many claim early puberty to girls make them more matured to 22yrs ,no her perspective is a little different from boy because of social upbringing>A middle class AMERICAN white girl ,she is well balanced,very matured,physically fully developed and assertive than others even in AMERICA.Middle class of america with one parent income of $80-$120k[2 parentsx2] is RICHER than a rich in India and even to european COUNTERPART. less industrialised nations have more conservative social structure, pace is slow.
LATE chooser >in GRAD SCHOOL is risky most good looking ones are all taken>beggers are not choosers>then you will have to depend on LUCK THAN CHOICE but i wll not recommend.
WHO will be HAPPY?depends on many factors of value system of two indiviuals>their education,health,social circumstances.IF IT STIKES THE UNISON >YOU WILL BE HAPPY>if it strikes the discord >YOU ARE IN HELL!

Comment by Preet Sagar
2008-03-26 16:42:14

how would you explain this with regard to Abhas and Abhilasha? they were 17-18 yrs old and do you support their love or not?

Comment by daddu
2008-03-27 04:30:45

Preet Sagar, you are talking rubbish…why the hell are you concerned about such matters? Hell with them and let them do what ever they want…lets mind our own business…logo ke phatey mein taang dalna aachi baat hai…tum sudhar jaao isi mein tumhari bhalai hai

 
 
 
Comment by daddu
2008-03-27 04:32:23

martha…teri bakwaas baandh kar re…

 
 
Comment by DEVKISHIN
2008-03-26 08:52:50

IF YOU LIKE BOTH ANWESHA AND AISHWARYA-GO VOTE FOR BOTH OF THEM WITHOUT ANY FEAR. BOTH BADLY NEED SUPPORT FROM ALL GENUINE MUSIC LOVERS.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by gooboo123
2008-03-26 11:28:44

Hello Devkishinji,
Ae bhidu ….. we are not doing “daan dharma” here.
I wish, I just wish that one day you will realise that passing comments the way you do irritates people rather than creating good impression. You behave like a gandhivadi person here but we all know that that is just a mask.

You have shown your true colours time and again trying to depict Narendra Modi as Gandhi, Aishwarya as Lata and Gajji as Raja Harishchandra.

You keep on writing in bold letters irrespective of knowing that writing in bold letters indicates bad manners. Lest you dont care.

What i would suggest is ……..If you have nothing new to say …….why dont you just keep your mouth shut or must i say your fingers on hold from typing and listen to what people want to say.

Of course it irritates you no end that A person is getting more favourable responses here than the other (who happens to be your favourite).

As far as your view on Ishmit goes ……I have one thing to say……. We are not sitting here to vote for people who have the cinematic voice but we are here to determine who is a better singer.

And after being with Gajji (as you have said that he is your pal) you havent realised what this show means (Ohh i got it wrong……combination of you and Gajji means doom as far as the real reason for the show is concerned)

But anyway let me tell you that we are here to determine who the better singer is not who has a better voice but poor sur.

If you cannot vote for a better singer do not advice others to do what they should do.

Sanjay

Comment by devkishin
2008-03-26 11:52:02

FOR GOOBOO123
AT LAST YOUR DIRTY LANGUAGE HAS EXPOSED YOU FULLY.
YOU ARE GOOD FOR NOTHING FELLOW WHO DOES NOT DESERVE ANY RESPECT. FIRST DESERVE AND THEN DESIRE.
IF YOU ARE AN NRI AND BEHAVE IN THIS MANNER VERY SOON YOU WILL BE THROWN OUT IF YOU CONTINUE TO BEHAVE IN THIS OBNOXIOUS MANNER.
GET LOST.

 
 
 
Comment by neha
2008-03-26 10:08:41

hi anwesha i love your voice hey anwesha mujhe kaise pata chalega ki tum mere msg padti ho plssssss reply

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by daddu
2008-03-27 04:26:03

woh tere message nahi padhti re…sab log tere jaise VELE nahi hote…

 
 
Comment by kvniranjan8
2008-03-26 10:21:45

@jack

Thanks a lot, Jack. Really appreciated.

There’s nothing great when I support Aishwarya. I’m completely convinced that she’s BEST, she’s better than Anwesha, she’ll be the greatest playback singer ever, she’ll also be a great classical singer, a great ghazal singer, etc. I hope that she’ll also sing some other language songs like Bengali, Marathi and even some South Indian songs. I’d like to bet Dr.A.K.Biswas that she could sing Rabindra Sangeet as good as anyone else, if given an opportunity.

I’m a committed fan of her for life and will be so even if there are bad times for her (I don’t agree that this is a bad time for her). I won’t be true to myself if I don’t support her if bad times come.

It doesn’t matter if 1000 people attack me verbally. The only way I can go silent is if someone put a gun to my head or showed a knife. Then, to save myself I’d have to back down but that won’t stop me from knowing inside that AISHWARYA IS THE BEST.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Avi
2008-03-26 12:01:34

I think KV has full right to beleive in Aishwarya and support her.. please let us not do any more “tu tu main main”.. does not look good… Every body has a different taste and choice so be it.. both of them are good and have their own plus and minuses.

 
Comment by devkishin
2008-03-26 12:34:15

VOTE FOR AISHWARYA IF YOU ARE A GENUINE LOVER OF MUSIC AND UNDERSTAND THE REAL MEANING OF MELODY.
AISHWARYA IS MELODIUS WITH GREAT EXPRESSION, TRAINED IN CLASSICAL SINGING ,EFFORTLESS,EXCELLENT IN ART OF MODULATION,VERSATILE AND GREAT POTENTIAL IN SINGING. SHE IS UNDOUBTEDLY THE SENSATIONAL SINGER OF THE FUTURE.
SHE IS THE YOUNGEST AND THE SWEETEST VOICE FROM THIS PART OF THE WORLD.
DESPITE HAVING BEEN REPEATEDLY ACKNOWLEDGED AS A GREAT SINGER BY KNOWLEDGEABLE JUDGES IN THE SHOW SHE IS SAVAGELY TARGETED BY VESTED INTERESTS TO SPOIL HER IMAGE, IMAGE OF HER PARENTS AS WELL AS THE IMAGE OF MILLIONS OF HER SUPPORTERS ALL OVER THE WORLD.THIS BEHAVIOUR OF ANTI-AISHWARYA BUNCH IS OUTRAGEOUS AND UNACCEPTABLE IN A CIVILISED SOCIETY THE ENTIRE GROUP OF SUPPORTERS OF HER OPPONENT IS RESORTING TO FAIR OR FOUL MEANS TO ENSURE HER DEFEAT.THEY STAND EXPOSED AS GREAT BULLIES.
IF TODAY SHE IS IN FINALS OF CHHOTE USTAD SHOW IT IS ENTIRELY ON THE BASIS OF HER UNDISPUTED GREAT TALENT , MASSIVE SUPPORT OF HER ADMIRERS AND THE IMPARTIAL AND KNOWLEDGEABLE JUDGES.
SUPPORT PURE MELODY,THE SWEETEST VOICE AND A FEARLESS ANGEL WHO IS STANDING FIRM DESPITE VICIOUS PERSONAL ATTACKS ON HER AND HER FAMILY MEMBERS.
WAKE UP TRUE MUSIC LOVERS AND VOTE FOR THE REAL TALENT BEFORE NEFARIOUS ACTIVITIES OF HER MISGUIDED ADVERSARIES SUCCEED.

 
 
Comment by jack
2008-03-26 12:37:50

YUP..that is what I am talking abt …

some pppl support Aish some Annu and some ppl support Music… Enjoy the program fully …. it is quite evident that ppl know what is going around and how gajji and star plus are playing cards of sentiment and politics ….. but any way how does it matter…. as long as we r getting good music the rest should be ignored…..

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Preet Sagar
2008-03-26 13:05:44

Hey mr. Devshkin do not pretend to be a know all. you are already exposed and nobody enjoys reading your commenst after every post. No wonder people are abusing you and still you are so thick-skinned. grow up mr. dev

As for martha,do not write anything about Abhas and abhilasha. i ahve already said i know abhilasha and so what if she and abhas are going around? they will soon get married and you have no right to write such things.
Abhas and abhilasha belong to decent families and if they fell in love, it is not their fault. be broad minded. I do not think their love influenced music. love and music are 2 diff things. i hope people support me here, Abhilasha is aregular net surfer and she will be hurt if she reads these comments.
Abhas and Abhil;asha will be roop kumar rathod and sonali rathod of future.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by devkishin
2008-03-26 15:17:46

preat sagar: quite childish.these comments do not need any reply .single-track mind.

Comment by Preet Sagar
2008-03-26 16:30:28

What do you mean by childish? please explain kindly.

Comment by daddu
2008-03-27 04:23:47

tujhe mirchi lagi to mein kya karun…teri naani mari to mein kya karun

 
 
 
 
Comment by sheel
2008-03-26 15:33:17

Hi Devkishin, somewhere you have mentioned you have atteneded some recordings or something. Were they of Chote Ustad. In any case, do you know how the contenstents get thier songs – I mean song selection , who sings which song.
Thanks.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by devkishin
2008-03-26 15:58:38

By criticising Aishwarya, her parents, the judges, even the director who is in this business for 15 years,millions of voters who voted for this young gujarati girl on basis of string of her mind blowing performances you have not only exposed yourself as good for nothing self-proclaimed music experts but you have challenged the very credibility and integrity of the show and its organisers.you have attacked the very foundation of this great spectacle for your own dubious ego and selifish motives.
The entire world is watching your antics in disbelief. Your behaviour against young innocent girl is most reprehensible to say the least. You have deeply hurt the feelings of young teenager-your this behaviour is worse than the comments of judges over Prakriti’s performance as atleast they did not condemn her parents. All those who raised their voice to criticise the judges at that time are now stand fully exposed as the great pretenders and hypocrites.
The humanity must be shedding tears at your cruel means of garnering the support for the contestant of your choice!shame on you!

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Sheel
2008-03-26 17:55:55

Almost everyone here is forgettnig or not taking into account the song selection. The song selection process is not clearly indicated to us. At times, it is found that The song selection has not been in the hands of contestents. Recently at one point, difficult and nice songs have been given to Aishwarya. And simpler non-famous songs to Anwesha.
So Answesha has had less chance to show off her talent. She also could have sung nicer and difficult songs that public would like. But she was not given this chance. If given, zero doubt she would sing it amazing. So we cannot say Aishwarya has shown versatility. There are some songs which had they both sung, then it would be fair comparison. This is simply an unfair comparison that we are doing right now.

 
 
Comment by jack
2008-03-26 16:15:15

@ devji,

is the above comment 4 everyone….who r writing against Aish?

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Rolly-polly
2008-03-26 16:38:42

Wah wah kya speech hai mr. dev hum to impressed hain by your rhetorical powers
However pls don’t insinuate all anvesha fans are bad
We are jsut angry with the unfair way in which show is constantly highlighting aishwarya
i used to like both but this attitude of star pluz creative team and chote ustad team got on my nerves and now I don’t like Aishwarya at all
These things will not go unnoticed by viewers we are not fools.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-26 16:47:43

For each has to decide out of the two according to his/her choice.
some people have suggested to vote for both,DOESN’T MAKE ANY SENSE.THE CONTESTANTS ARE TWO AND ARE YOU VOTING BOTH ?>TOTALLY ILLOGICAL.
you will have to take a decision for one but as i said that doesn’t mean the other is LESS deserving.It’s personal choice:PURELY on each sense of judgement> i would request people to respect other’s views.
Thanks.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Ronnie
2008-03-26 17:23:35

Yes I agree. Please don’t waste your time and money by voting for both – because it doesn’t make any sense at all.Just go with your heart and vote for your favourite singer.

 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-26 17:36:59

symbolically,in last show,they were wearing two colors .anwesha in Blue and aiswyaria in Red.
you choose your own > My family and i had to decide to go for ANWESHA after we discussed at our family meet.we all came to Delhi to see this DELHI LIVE SHOW for this spring break!
so please take your choice and vote!
Thank you

Comment by Ronnie
2008-03-26 17:53:53

@Dr.akbiswas

How was the Delhi show? What songs did Anu and Aish sing? Let us know what you think of their performances. Please give us your feedback. Thanks.

 
 
 
Comment by Ronnie
2008-03-26 17:13:05

All Music lovers and Anwesha fans please vote, vote and vote! You saw Anonymous’s post – Anwesha is lagging behind in online voting by a wide margin and this is from a very reliable source. So, please let’s not waste anytime arguing with Devkishin. Devkishin doesn’t think it’s Cruel when he calls every Anwesha supporter Stupid, Immature and a Brat!! He used to say he is a fan of EVERYONE but now we know the truth! He likes Aish and that’s perfectly fine but stop attacking every Anwesha fan o.k.? But, that may be too much to ask from this fanatic.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-26 17:51:15

i totally agree** please don’t waste time ,if you want to vote then vote for ANWESHA immediately.( I have heard the same in delhi -public > i have also heard from USA THAT NRI guj are voting like crazy!)
so please blog less and VOTE MORE FOR ANWESHA.
each email ID can vote 20 votes.in sms, there is no ceiling!! please confirm that!!
thank you all

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-26 17:58:34

not all are liberal people ,some are very community oriented> biased >these we should avoid at this stage of final>so please vote and avoid these remarks!!
thank you again

 
Comment by Ronnie
2008-03-26 18:46:11

Sometimes they are taking more than 20 votes online but I don’t know whether they are going to be Counted.For SMS votes I think the same rule applies- just 20 votes for each number. But if the server allows you to vote then WHY not let’s just vote to our heart’s content! But We really don’t know whether the extra votes are going to be counted or not.

 
 
Comment by Sheel
2008-03-26 17:57:13

Almost everyone here is forgettnig or not taking into account the song selection. The song selection process is not clearly indicated to us. At times, it is found that The song selection has not been in the hands of contestents. Recently at one point, difficult and nice songs have been given to Aishwarya. And simpler non-famous songs to Anwesha.
So Answesha has had less chance to show off her talent. She also could have sung nicer and difficult songs that public would like. But she was not given this chance. If given, zero doubt she would sing it amazing. So we cannot say Aishwarya has shown versatility and she is better singer. There are some particular songs which had they both sung, then it would be fair comparison. This is simply an unfair comparison that we are doing right now.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-26 18:12:55

Lastly and not the least: how much liberal thoughts come to people was clearly demonstrated no other than two mother’s statements: MRS MAZMUDER SAID” SHE FEELS PROUD AND DEVINE ;IT’S DESTINY FOR HER CHILD TO BE CHOTTE USTAAD.”
MRS.DUTTAGUPTA SAID” BOTH ARE CHOTTE USTAAD AND BOTH ARE MY DAUGHTERS”
This leaves NOT a shade of doubt how two mothers think.
Many of us are liberal and respectful ,others are different in selfish ideology!

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Jay
2008-03-26 18:31:09

I know for sure that the Delhi episode was recorded on Mar 21/ 22. Whatt IS THIS BISWAS SAYING?? Please explain??

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Ronnie
2008-03-26 18:47:19

Sometimes they are taking more than 20 votes online but I don’t know whether they are going to be Counted.For SMS votes I think the same rule applies- just 20 votes for each number. But if the server allows you to vote then WHY not let’s just vote to our heart’s content! But We really don’t know whether the extra votes are going to be counted or not.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by jack
2008-03-26 20:41:04

Dear all,

This is the rules of voting …. Keep voting for ur fav contestants…..

1 SMS :Maximum number of entries that the viewer can send via this medium is 20 votes per number per contestant per voting cycle valid. In the event, a viewer sends more that 20 SMSs casting his/her votes, the votes sent after the first 20 SMS shall not be counted and will be considered null and void. Thus, for e.g., a viewer has sent 30 SMS casting their votes, then the vote casted by the viewer vide SMS 21st to 30th SMS would not be counted and would be considered null and void.
2 Interactive Voice Response : Maximum number of entries that the viewer can send via this medium is 20 votes per number per contestant per voting cycle valid. In the event, a viewer sends more that 20 entries casting his/her votes, the votes sent after the first 20 calls shall not be counted and will be considered null and void.
4 http://www.indya.com : Single E-mail I.D- Maximum number of entries that a viewer can send via one e-mail i.d. is 20. In the event, a viewer sends more than 20 entries casting his/her votes via the same e-mail id., the votes sent after the first 20 e-mails shall not be counted and will be considered null and void.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-26 21:08:46

TO VOTE:
1.ONLINE:RIGHT HERE > GO UP TO THE HEADER OF THIS WEBSITE > SEE VOTE> IT WILL REDIRECT TO INDYA.COM VOTING SITE>LOG IN OR REGISTER FIRST THEN LOG IN AND VOTE TO YOUR CANDIDATE>

2.SMS ::SAME AS BEFORE> VOTE>SMS AND IT WILL TAKE YOU TO THE SITE FOR SMS MESSAGING.

PLEASE VOTE TO THE RIGHT TALENT OF YOUR CHOICE.
THANK YOU

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-26 21:12:45

sorry !2.SMS SITE IS NOW JUST BELOW ONCE YOU CLICK VOTE****PLEASE NOTE
THANK YOU.

Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-26 21:30:07

please note >>
1.YOU CAN VOIP from your computer
2.FROM USA: dial 1-712-858-8883, a phone number in Iowa. After selecting the language for voice prompts, you’re instructed to dial 011 followed by the country code and the number that you want to reach. In a moment, you’ll be connected to that number.ACTUALLY IT WILL BE 2.5 CENTS /MIN INTERSTATE.
3.FROM INDIA >please let me know if that is possible on land line from delhi ( i am visitng) or any city ?if yo u know!!
3.PLEASE POST ANY FROM CANADA? I REQUESTED 3PERSONS HOW COME NO POSTING YET?
PLEASE HELP FOR THIS VOTING EPISODE
THANKS

Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-26 21:54:56

PLEASE NO FURTHER COMMENTS!!
ONLY FOR VOTING EPISODE NOW!! IT’S VERY IMPORTANT! PLEASE GIVE US INFO FOR LANDLINES FREE**** CALLS FROM:
FROM:
1.INDIA
2.USA
3.UK
4.CANDA
5.AUSTRALIA
TO HELP THE FIRENDS.********
NO WASTE OF TIME
ACTION PLEASE******
THANK YOU

 
 
 
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-27 00:32:07

SPECIAL INVITATIONS TO PAKISTAN AND BNGLADESH FRIENDS:

PLEASE VOTE FOR ANWESHA DUTTAGUPTA
TO PAKISTANI
“Mere pakistani bhayo aur Bhaino,
AAP KI AKHRI MOUKA HAIN,AAP AAP KI PASAND VOTE KYE JYEH. MYAIN JANTA HU KI AAP ANWESHA KO JIADA PASAND KARTYE HAIN.AAP EK ITIHASIK MUSIC COMPETITION KI HISSA BANTYE HAIN.”
sukria

FOR BANGLADESHI:
“sudhi banglar bandhura,
apnara ayei bangla meykye vote karun.bangalir Garba aye meye ke samarthan karun”
ashesh dhanyabad.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Ronnie
2008-03-27 01:29:06

I just found out that Aish sang ‘Soni de nakhre’ and ‘In dino’ and Anu sang ‘Mahi ve’( got standing ovation from the audience and the judges)& ‘o meri jaan’ in Delhi.Guest judge was Shilpa Shetty. Harshit Saxena also was there and sang “Jabse se tere naina” and Mika sang Mauja hi mauja.Anu and Aish also did a Jugalbandi with Mast kalandar.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by kvniranjan8
2008-03-27 02:21:43

While I completely agree that the fans of Anwesha have the right to support their favourite, their arguments are clearly biased, one sided and illogical.

1.Gajji desperately wants Aish to win at any cost. If so, why would he admit Anwesha into the contest? A few weeks back, the father of one of the contestants from Kolkata who didn’t make it, was reporting that Anwesha did NOT even attend the Kolkata auditions. (I’m happy Anwesha’s in the contest, otherwise Aish wouldn’t have any worthwhile challenge).
But the point is that Anwesha was taken directly by Gajji without an audition.

2.Whenever Aish sings superbly, which is most of the time, these fans say Anwesha was not given good songs. When Anwesha sings well, this argument is not mentioned.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Ronnie
2008-03-27 02:48:17

Anwesha was taken because she was the runner up in SAREGAMAPA ZEE Bangla( Although she deserved to win but they were looking for more of a pop star than a classical singer). Aneek got in the same way. Of course Gajji wants good competition in his show otherwise nobody is going to see this show and He is not going to get all that money through voting right? But WHO’S going to win?? Is it up to us the voters or is it predetermined?? Well that is a million dollar question.

 
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-27 02:39:16

http://www.startec.com/US/EN/products/landing/CallIndia69.jsp?mediacd=ONL_ADG&WT.srch=1&WT.mc_id=999&gclid=CKnJjfGfrJICFRM8awodtmOhQg

I SPOKE TO DIRECTOR MARKETING STARTEC GLOBAL: GUYS 90 MINUTES FREE CALLING TO INDIA.
NO CONTRACT
NO CHANGE OF LINE
GUYS TAKE THIS THEN OVER .I THINK IN 90 MINUTE YOU WILL BE ABLE TO FINISH VOTING.
FROM USA & CANADA >PLEASE VOTE FOR ANWESHA.
THANKS AGAIN.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-27 02:40:02

SWING INTO ACTION ,PLEASE

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-27 03:54:09

http://www.aaj.tv/blog/
please make vote appeal for anwesha here in aaj tv blog pakistan

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-27 03:56:28
(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by kvniranjan8
2008-03-27 04:05:23

@Ronnie, others

That’s what I mean

1.If Aishwarya sings well and Anwesha sings poorly, they say Anwesha was given bad songs.

2. If Bhopal votes for Aishwarya, they say why was Bhopal selected?

3. If judges are reluctant to give marks because it has no effect on the result, they say judges were prevented from giving poor marks to Aishwarya by Gajji.

4.If judges give all Sartaj Sarvottam to Aishwarya, they say that Gajji forced them to do so.

5.Aishwarya getting more votes for them means money power.

6.The public supporting Aishwarya in millions means they don’t know anything about music and only these fans know everything there’s to know about music.

In other words, as long as the rest of the world doesn’t toe their line and bow to their viewpoint, they’ll keep complaining.

Anyway, whoever wins in this public voting tug of war, it’ll just be a victory of muscle power and money power.

The result of this contest makes NO difference as far as the future in the music industry is concerned. Both AISHWARYA and ANWESHA have a huge demand among the public, so both will become playback singers. After that it’s upto them as to who performs better over time. They have plenty of time on their side.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Ronnie
2008-03-27 04:28:40

FYI ANWESHA never sang poorly. That’s why she GOT SARWOTTAMS from all the judges all the way o.k.buddy?? Are you related to Aish by any means?

 
Comment by Ronnie
2008-03-27 04:44:11

First of all Anwehsa never sings poorly.We all know Anwesha had no choice and AISH had some choice in selcting songs O.K.? And this is from a very reliable source. Did KUNAL really want to give a sartaj sarwottam to Aish?? Please give me a break! He was forced to grade Aish when he didn’t want to. And the rest of your comments are so ****** that I don’t even think they demand a response.

 
Comment by Jay
2008-03-27 04:47:34

@kv8
You are really making a fool of yourself!

 
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-27 04:09:45

http://www.anindianmuslim.com/
ehy tahedil se aap ki mesus ho raha hain ki insaf ki madat karey aur anwesha ki upar aap ki pyaar barkar rakhye.
Allah hafiz

Nb>main urdu ki haraf se aap ki akbar mye jarur yeah arji pesh krunga>yeah server isko support nehi karte.insaf ki hifazat aap ki upar hain.sare hindustan ki muslim bhayeo aur bhaino,aap iski hissa banye!

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-27 04:16:30

please make your vote appeal to the above MUSLIM SITE, for those who may not visit this site.
make vote appeal but make sure give links to see ANWESHA’S video and voting sites.
thanks

Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-27 04:26:50

I am making vote appeal in urdu and putting those in urdu alfaz in urdu news sites.we need to mobilise the votes FROM ALL SECTORS FOR ANWESHA.
I would liketo thank my youngsters who made me understand the very system of this game.i am new to this system but inshalla, we will reach there. inspring both pakistani and Bangladeshi would favor the votes for anwesha.they are great music lovers !!so, please move in that direction.
thanks

 
 
 
Comment by Ronnie
2008-03-27 04:30:54

@kvniranjan8
FYI ANWESHA never sang poorly. That’s why she GOT SARWOTTAMS from all the judges all the way o.k.buddy?? Are you related to Aish by any means?

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by trados
2008-03-27 04:50:08

Aye ronnie…tu aedda hai kya?

Comment by Ronnie
2008-03-27 04:53:10

What! Say that again!

 
 
 
Comment by Jay
2008-03-27 04:49:16

First of all Anwehsa never sings poorly.We all know Anwesha had no choice and AISH had some choice in selcting songs O.K.? And this is from a very reliable source. Did KUNAL really want to give a sartaj sarwottam to Aish?? Please give me a break! He was forced to grade Aish when he didn’t want to. And the rest of your comments are so ****** that I don’t even think they demand a response.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Ronnie
2008-03-27 04:51:16

Jay
thanks for posting for me!

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by daddu
2008-03-27 04:54:49

ALL…stop this bullshit NOW. Its enough!!!

Enough man hours have been wasted to this NON-productive and wasteful activity of watching this show, writting comments and throwing shit at each other.

GUYS…Forget about this show, contestants and all the nonsense. They are making money and not YOU. Think what you can do for yourself, your family and this country. Start slogging your BUTTS off on some good and productive activities and stop wasting your time on such useless activities.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Ronnie
2008-03-27 05:02:57

Totally agree with you bro.

 
 
Comment by Ronnie
2008-03-27 05:06:34

For all VOI lovers: I just found out that Aish sang ‘Soni de nakhre’ and ‘In dino’ and Anu sang ‘Mahi ve’( got standing ovation from the audience and the judges) &‘o meri jaan’ in Delhi.Guest judge was Shilpa Shetty. Harshit Saxena also was there and sang “Jabse se tere naina” and Mika sang Mauja hi mauja. Anu and Aish also did a Jugalbandi with Mast kalandar.Adios!

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by devkishin
2008-03-27 08:04:02

VOTE AS MUCH AS YOU CAN FOR AISHWARYA THE DARLING DAUGHTER OF THIS COUNTRY AND GIVE FITTING REPLY TO FANATICS LIVING IN THEIR FANCIFUL WORLD.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by well wiisher
2008-03-27 08:05:31

Who is this Dr akbiswas….must be an agent for voting..the time he is wasting here for supporting anwesha,if half of it he will spend with his family,if he has any,then it will change his life.common Dr..whom ever will win,won’t make any difference in ur life.And both r so talented that u can’t stop anybody’s career.so cooooooooooooooool

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-27 08:29:48

USA,UK ,CANADA,BANGLADESH,PAKISTAN MUST VOTE FOR ANWESHA.

 
 
Comment by devkishin
2008-03-27 08:10:29

COME ON INDIA USA UK AFGHANISTAN VOTE AISHWARYA IF YOU ARE A TRUE LOVER OF REAL TALENT LET THE GROUP OF IGNORANTS SAY WHAT THEY LIKE .BY INSULTING AISHWARYA THEY HAVE ONLY SLAPPED THEMSELVES AND SANGEET

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by devkishin
2008-03-27 08:23:49

AISHWARYA IS REPORTEDLY BEHIND THE OTHER CONTESTANT IN VOTING .ONLY FEW DAYS LEFT TO HELP THIS YOUNG MAIDEN-A REAL ANGEL WHO HAS BRAVED THE VICIOUS ATTACK UNLEASHED BY A SECTION OF RACIAL ELEMENTS.
VOTE AISHWARYA AS MUCH AS YOU CAN.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by jack
2008-03-27 08:27:45

VOTE FOR A……….
VOTE FOR A……….
VOTE FOR A……….
VOTE FOR A……….
VOTE FOR A……….
VOTE FOR A……….
VOTE FOR A……….
VOTE FOR A……….
VOTE FOR A……….
VOTE FOR A……….
VOTE FOR A……….
VOTE FOR A……….
VOTE FOR A……….
VOTE FOR A……….

HA HA HA ….. KOUN KYA DISCUSS KARNA CHAHTA HAIN SAMAJH MEIN NAHI AA RAHA HAIN …..ONE THING IS CLEAR N THAT IS ” VOTE FOR A…….”

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by devkishin
2008-03-27 08:32:50

NAME AISHWARYA APPEARS FIRST EVERYWHERE -IN WORLD BEAUTY CONTEST-IN ENGLISH DICTIONARY AND IN DIVINE AND MELODIOUS MUSIC. OUR DARLING DAUGHTER IS NO LESS.
THEN HOW CAN SHE TRAIL IN VOTING?
VOTE AISHWARYA WITHOUT ANY FEAR AS THE ALMIGHTY ALWAYS TAKES CARE OF HIS FAVOURITES.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by Dr.akbiswas
2008-03-27 08:35:33

TAHADILSE SUKHRIA ADA KARTA HU KI SARE LOK ANWESHA KI VOTE KAREY AUR SACHHAi KI INSAF KAREY!

(Comments wont nest below this level)