This was the worst episode of Chhote Ustaad. Behaviour of the crowd by biased. Morever, judges have now completely biased. They are trying their utmost to pressurise Anwesha by giving easy songs to Aishwarya, ignorning her mistakes in singing and still encouraging her by giving Sartaj Servottams. On the other hand, they are giving meaningless and never heard of songs to Anwesha.
I have no hesitation in saying that the entire team of Chhote Ustaad is involved in making Aishwarya win.
However, I must say that these bad tactics cannot keep away a nice and talented singer Anwesha from becoming a big star in Bollywood.
From my side both Aishwarya and Anwesha may go to hell. I care less. I am not voting for any body. I am saving my votes for Ishmeet in the next show Superstar.
yesterday Kunal ganjawala displayed his racist mentality by taking every religion’s name except for sikh religion. This shows how sikhs are ignored by the people of our country. No wonder why Ishmeet had to suffer so much racism in the show.
Rupinder, I am sad that inspite of being a sikh u could not understand my views. Your stattement regarding aishwarya’s day paying me was childish.
These reality shows have become a medium for some ppl to show their anger and disgust for sikh community as a whole. Some people just cant tolerate a sikh guy coming forward in such shows. Gajendra singh also made sure that is no sikh participant in chotte ustaad. He also has a racist mindset. Despite winning Ishmeet has been insulted because he belongs to the sikh community. People hv made it a habit of insulting sikhs even after sikh community has done so many sacrifices for the country and Hindu religion.
I see that you guys are getting emotional. As I have said in my earlier posts, this is ALL BUSINESS!! Organizers know very well what MIRCH MASALA people want, what kind of controversies incite people…and thats exactly what they serve. Gajendra is a guy with master mind and sharp eye for opportunity to make money.
My only advice to you guys is, you also figure out how to make money from all this, the way I have done it.
Just saw this episode man.. this is biasing and nothing else.. first Anwesha is given average numbers.. Aish was given the most soulful of song in “Janeja” and she has literally s’ed that up.. still judges were praising it.. amazing man !!!.. What is that stupidity of that aish and her father’s padosan medley, for?.. This show made it clear that they want Aishwarya to win.. it very much clear there.. real disgusting man.. the show is moving to such a sad end.. doesn’t matter if Anwesha loses it.. but still that is going to pinch me a lot and I guess all music lover who followed it up with their soul.. cos even this show made it very much clearer.. that Anwesha is FARFARFAR superior.. she is the best.. and she should have win this contest..
Aish Performance: I donno of the first gujrati number.. it didn’t sound great to me.. “Jisse dhundta hun” was horribly sung.. “Dil cheez Kiya he” there was no right pace to the song.. it was a pain to listen to it.. “Janeja” totally s’ed up.. there was no soul, no feeling, no pace in the song.. it was kind of dragged singing.. I donno how kunal and shreya bear her rendition.. kunal new that she has sung it so badly, why he still praised it.. he should have known the best about the mistakes she made, cos he is the original singer.. I donno what was going on there..
And my gosh.. gujrat crowd was the most biased crowd that I have seen.. Calcutta was much better..
Anwesha’s Performance: “Kemche” was decent.. In sense there is nothing great in the song.. still Anwesha has sung it so well.. “Saki” number was so beautifully sung by her though again the song has nothing.. she made it beautiful with her talent.. “Bhor bhaye” was another lame song given to her.. mind u, she again did a decent job with it.. she has distinct voice from Lata, but she manages all songs so well, therefore this one didn’t sound that bad.. “Dupatta Tera” song choice was shocking.. they didn’t get a decent song of kunal for Anwesha? hardly unbelievable!! she coul have given “Hum se yun milenge” from Ankahee.. that was soulful and I am sure Anwesha wud have won heart of all with that song.. but nah!! she is given a s**t song to sing.. just to project Aish.. this was clearly visible man.. till now I was denying it.. but alas I cud see this too..
anyway.. I felt furious watching this episode.. but was amazed to see the exuberance of Anwesha in such a tough situation.. she is a raw talent.. hoping to see her rise up as a bright star in our music industry.. I am sure we shall have a feast of beauties of songs from her in coming future..
It’s true that Anwesha received very average kinds of songs to sing, whereas Aish had some great melodious, soulful songs that have a lot of scope. Despite this, Anwesha still did full justice to all the songs given. Her Gujrati number is still ringing in my ears. And I have to say that her ‘Bhor bhaye’ was just amazing! Very close to the original, in my opinion.
I had heard before, in a random forum, that she was going to sing ‘Kuhu kuhu bole koyalia’ for the Guru round, but for some reason wasn’t allowed to at the last minute.
I am sick of this regionalism shown in this show.. why the divide between gujrat and bengal is glorified like that? just to get stupid votes!!!.. and the thing showed in the show that gujrat is sooo great.. come on man, stop this nonsense.. if you can’t understand yourself than can’t u understand from a movie like “Chak De” that we are indian.. these guys are not bringing these two states together, but creating more divisions..
frankly speaking these shows is all in all “Dramabaazi” and making money from all resources.. only one thing was good in the whole show…. “Anwesha”..
really !!! ‘kuhu’ song would have been ideal for her.. she has got a range for that song.. This song was beautifully sung by “Poonam” and It would have been great experience to have compared the two renditions..
Problem is that we have used “amazing” word with Anwesha so much that it has become synonym with her.. But I found that her voice sounds more closer to “Asha”, “Kavita” and “Shreya”.. and not that closer to “Lata”.. but the way she sings every song sounds soo good.. I personally enjoy listening to all of her song.. just wished that she should get the best of soulful songs, so that even her hardest critic will know what she is capable of..
I completely agree with you that this was the most boring episode of all.
I cannot believe that even at this level, people try and play with minds of 14 year olds……. It sucks man !!!
To give Anwesha the songs that she got……must be one of the worst thing that has happened on television in many many years.
And i am surprised that people like Shreya and kunal have continued to let this go past their notice. If they cannot support and encourage singers ……. They have no right to be judges.
But who will remember this next year…….. NO ONE !!!
It will be same judges, same Gajji directing this show……cause with all the hype and hoopla the show is more popular than sa re ga ma pa lil champs.
But I hope they realise that it is only because they have got singer like Anwesha and to a certain extent Aishwarya that they are minting money.
Next year i hope this show gets a lul from the singing part…… I hope they dont even get people half the talent….and no one watches this show again.
chandiani:
i have attended gajendraji’s saregama recordings at famous studios and film city. i used to get passes through post . i do not know gajendra singh personally but have talked with him on telephone on couple of ocassions. despite being one of the busiest persons in his line of activity, he is a gentleman to the core. very submissive and soft spoken.
all that lose talk about corruption etc. is meaningless unless you have concrete proof to substantiate the allegations.
i did not offer you a vip pass for the finals as you have commented in one of your posts. but the way you were repeatedly mentioning about betting etc on the final winner gave an impression that you are a gambler . you are probably right when you said that lot of betting is involved in this show.
this show has thrown up two equal talents in the final and i still believe it is difficult to name a clear winner.
in fact i was offered passes for vvip enclosure also but i do not fall in that category. had dr akbiswas or any of the bloggers on this site be here, particularly madam vandana from delhi i could have arranged for any number of free passes for them
anyway i wish you and your family all happiness and winnings in whatever you do in proper manner.
thanks.
As can be noticed, nearly all the people in this forum believe that Anwesha is the better of the two finalists. So, this should naturally be the trend for all the Indian public. However, quite amazingly, the voting situation is different and as per Chhote Ustaad program, Aishwarya is leading by huge margin over Anwesha.
Yes, it was said that she was going to sing ‘kuhu kuhu’ and I was very excited about it. But needless to say, for whatever reason, it turned out that the entire round was dropped in favour of a Kunal Ganjawala dedication round!
But keep in mind that I’m not sure how reliable this source is and therefore I have no way of actually knowing whether she was really going to sing it or not…
Either way, after this show is over, I hope that some of her more diehard fans will ask a request for her to sing this song and put it up on youtube. That’d be great!
Anwesha, no matter you win this or not but you’re the winner. Remember your host (Abhas) he was not the winner either at one time but now he’s. You rock girl and you’re the best. Alas I am not in show/cinema biz to sign you. If I am not mistaken I see Lata jee’s voice in you.
There are people who have read my comments on the previous episode and commented about the sweet voice of Aishwarya and Anwesha.
To them, I am a big fan of Anwesha and I love what she does with her voice. If there is one singer in recent years that i have liked for variety of songs …. It has to be Anwesha. Previously I used to like Sunidhi Chauhan especially after Chameli…. for those scintillating numbers. But Anwesha is better and she will be far far superior to Sunidhi in a few years.
As far as Shreya goes ….. She is very good in slow and melodious numbers but i havent heard her sing high pitch numbers ……. I would like her to sing songs like “Mahi ve”, “Saki” …….. and if she has the guts …… she should sing song that Anwesha sung “O meri jaan”. And then i will rate her.
Yes i shouldnt be saying anything about Shreya Ghoshal since she has given us good numbers in the recent years and i am not even 1% as good as her. But this is no comparison……this is assessment of a talent of a 14 year old. And if singers like Shreya ghoshal cannot get it. Then i dont really understand it.
Anwesha…….. I will buy your albums anyday….
I just hope that some good music directors make you sing their songs. I hope and pray for you. Thats all i can do for you.
I guess I think most people who liked Anwesha have the same feeling of hopelessness. They can do nothing more but hope that she finds her path to victory (in life and whatever she aims for) and not get disheartened by this result.
hmm da episode..lol i dint find it xiting at all nd das sad 22 c da whle crwd in favour of aishwarya evn dough shez ma ffav. newy anwesha al d bst nn gd luk it desnt mater hu eva winz kk bibi..xox bles
Only shows the stupidity and immaturity of the Gujrati Audience compared to the Kolkata ones. They vote for Aishwariya not based on her singing ability but just because she is from Gujrat and fools like these are given the authority to choose the Chhote Ustaad.
Utter Crap!!
I am in UK and watching chotte ustad videos through this site. Gujrat has already proved that they are going to make everything for Aiswarya to win, although most music lovers in the country prefer Anwesha as the best. Anwesha is purely matured to sing all sort of music, have quality voice, great personality to be a celebrity, capability to entertain crowds in the music shows. Whereas I believe Aiswarya has sweet voice, but definitely lacking the other skills from Anwesha. Definitely Aiswarya will be matured in coming years, but as per current situation she is not the best to win chotte ustad . Nowadays we can see undeserved candidates are declared champion in these type of tv shows and this has already proved that people are loosing interests to watch these shows. As a proof we can see why Bengal is not voting. In previous episode Kolkata has shown that they are never biased and can support those who are really good. This is because Kolkata is a cultural city and Bengalis give value to the real culture, arts, music etc. Earlier Anwesha said in an interview, “Winning or loosing does not matter”, I also believe the same. She has great talent and even she loose, she has got enough support from most of the people except Gujrat, judges, media. I think she has great future. I wish her all the best to succeed in life.
Aishwarya has already won the battle
Nervousness of anwesha friends was right
Party time folks.
After 37 episodes Still Comparing
OOPS Keep it up
GUJARATAN CHALDI HAI CHALANGA MARDI
TUSSI HAAT MALLDE RAHO ANWESHA DE SATHIYO
Agree with you that behavior of crowd and judges seem to be very much biased. ANVESHA has that quality of Lata Mageshker, she will definitely WIN this contest no dobut, but more so the time will come when the world will drown in her hit songs as there is no challenge to her God gifted talent. God bless
Thanks a lot for your valuable comments and wishes. There are many bloggers on this site but I have seen that most of them are biased and are indulging in demeaning a particular contestant.
From my name you would have figured out that I am not from Gujarat, however it is unfortunate that some of the bloggers here who do not even know the spelling of Gujarat or Gujarati are making all kind of nasty comments about Gujarat and Gujarati people. What a shame..what a waste..
Devkishinji,
Yes I am involved in betting on this show as well as stock market etc in a big way. However, I believe that I am not a gambler but an investor and a businessman.
yeah at a time we used to compare.. but after all this it looks like stupid to compare the two now.. cos it is crystal clear that Anwesha is much better than Aish.. There is no nervousness between us.. But despair about the system.. You can’t make people fool for a long time.. Show is biased and it is clearly visible there now.. “Gujaratan chal nahi rahi he, sagon dodai ja rahi he.. Jit len diyon usno eh title.. ki ho jawega.. log sunange ta Anwesha nu hi.. Sunde rehan gujrati apni gujratan nu.. who cares..”
From this show:
crowd’s behavior(specially adults) made Bipasha Basu (she is beautiful and tall5’8″, wellbuilt Bengali girl almsot like sushmita sen,5’10″) uncomfortable and she minced no words “let us talk in Bengali” was a direct slap>
comedy clip of ash and her father was really funny>shows father and daughter has a beautiful relationship.
The parents of these kids are wonderful.
This episode was a little better than delhi.
Rajasthan episode is my favorite.
Shreya has looks to become a good actress in Bollywood.. I suggest someone take her as an actress in a movie.. and and and.. important point is that all her songs in the movie should be given to Anwesha to sing.. so far I buy a music album just seeing the name of Shreya and she has not disappointed me so far.. for me, it is going to b Anwesha now..
I have just finished watching the 4th April episode……
I wont dilly dally…I’ll come straight to the point……
This is an Aishwarya special…(like they do shreya special…etc) with Anwesha being used as a prop.
I go back to my blog after the Jaipur episode when they announced the next episode to be shot in Kolkata…..I had said that the choice of Ahmedabad as the venue for the penultimate episode itself was an extremely biased strategy…..now you see why it was done…..to play with peoples’ emotions….and garner maximum votes for Aishwarya….like striking when the iron is hot…I say this even though Aishwarya was leading by a minimal margin before this episode began…this is done so that Anwesha doesnt catch up at the last minute……
Looking at it objectively, its just another musical talent reality show…but it appears to be more a show of which family is more dramebaaz and which dad is more pally with the show organisers….every parent is emotional about his/her child…every mother is proud of her son/daughter….but to repetitively make use of these emotions for material gain ….that is utter cheap. Let me mention here that the margin between reality and drama is very subtle…its easy to play with peoples emotions coz not many can appreciate the difference and anybody with the slightest acting skills (all the more easier if it runs in the family)definitely stands to gain.Period.
Having said that I definitely uphold Aishwaryas talent…she has a fabulous voice no doubt….. I appreciate her parents’ sacrifice, her father’s talent, modern outlook……..BUT people voting (from recent trends in favour of Aishwarya) her over Anwesha for singing prowess……unbelievable! You dont need a degree in music to tell whos better….you need a ear for it!!!
I for one felt extremely sad seeing this episode….the onus has gradually shifted from “singing” to “stage show”….i dont want to comment more on it…………
Nevertheless, Anwesha outclassed her opponent in ALL the songs….despite the biased song selection…despite the extremely narrow-minded crowd…..despite it being an Aishwarya special!
Im more or less certain who is going to win this contest…..being judged by regionalism and favouritism….the trends of todays society…with able political leaders like Mr Modi sitting in top seats…what more can be expected?
I dont want to shift focus from singing…….so all you people watching these kids sing……the show is making one of them the voice of India…..but its the other voice of India whos making the show!!! No prizes for guessing who is which………..
Three cheers to good music and musicians…….
fairy
I was going to write plz omit the subscript ..but ill now write plz use the subscript “Anwesha outclassed her opponent..” as the title of my blog.
Thank you
fairy
Hey, no offense to Gujrati people actually.. if I am doing that then I am wrong.. they are doing what a home crowd normally do, supporting their people.. we do in sports too.. this type of support is healthy, but one shall appreciate the talent of opposite contestant as well.. specially if he/she is so good.. that makes you great..
After giving a thought, I feel that it may not be the Gujrat crowd, but the way it is presented, is not good..
yeah.. but they have exaggerated a lot on that.. too much adulation was shown.. I feel they totally side tracked Anwesha here.. Just noticed the expression on judges face during all renditions.. They can’t hide appreciation for Anwesha.. and while Aish was performing, they were kind of feeling uncomfortable, but maintained their composure while giving rich comments.. I don’t think they were saying it through their heart.. if you still think that they did, then they must be good actors as well..
Haha, my comments must be sounding very biased now, since I was supporting both of them till now.. Reason for this is that I myself sense something wrong there by the pattern of things happened in last couple of shows.. Cos I have seen the effect of it wherein some of Anwesha’s supporters start calling her “Ghamandi”, overconfident and concentrating more on dancing kind of thing.. In the last two shows they were trying to showcase Aish as cute and better singer..
At a first go I liked Aish’s audio songs.. cos all of them were classical and soulful numbers.. but after giving a couple of listening to them, I could see huge flaws in her singing.. right rhythm seems to be missing at crucial point of those songs.. I guess many people have noticed that commented on it several times.. “O Sajna” is the only song which she has sung flawlessly..
Comparatively, Anwesha has sung all types of songs pretty well.. She excelled in the songs originally sung by Asha, kavita and shreya.. she was brilliant in performing songs of other singers as well that included Richa, Shubha mugdal etc.. Lata’s ardent fans won’t believe this but she has given full justice to Lata’s songs as well.. What more versatility do you expect from a singer?..
Anybody watching live and is visiting net at the same time, please let us know how things are going in the show and who is the winner.. Like me, people who don’t have a connection here away from India, are excited to know the proceedings…
though it is of no point as we all know who will win.. but still, a hope is there that magic happens and so do the justice..
Here some SIKHS have made some comments regarding kunal Gunjwala as “Racist” for he din’t mentioned sikhs “Guru granth”
he mentioned “har holy book me” then he said viz major religons book> sikhs are only 2 millions in India >only1.5% in the 1.2 billion Indians>prime minsiter of India has been Monmohan singh,Ministry of external affairs and 4 important positions in the center are sikhs.NOT EVEN BENGAL WITH THE STARS LIKE DR.BC ROY TO JOYTI BASU NOT A SINGLE PERSON HAS BEEN > FROM SOUTH, only NARASHIMA RAO.IF sikhs are making these comments after they made such a hullabaloo
for khalisthan(forgetting?? if India would not have accomdated sikhs in partition1947, i doubt there would have been any sikh left to-day.so please count the blessings you have received from india. BENGAL has produced most sicentists and stalwarts than any state could even think of >SHE WAS MARGINALISED>when Bengal was divided By Lord carzon it came as a boon to NEHRUJI & BAPUJI than a pleasure to JINNAH.EAST BENGAL got 144,000 sq.kilometer and west got 88,00sq. kilometer ,NEHRUJI SMILED ,he was busy with kashmir to flirt with Lady EDWINA Mountbatten THAN TO THE LEAST INTEREST FOR BENGAL>never objected>BENGAL’S land fertiltiy(arable land: 55.39% https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/bg.html) highest in Indian subcontinent.IT’S NO WONDER THAT A STATE MADE THE MOST SCIENTISTS WHAT HAPPEND TO BENGAL ,STOPPED PRODUCING GOLDEN EGGS? YES, SHE WAS DECIMATED BY NEHRUJI AND BAPUJI AND HINDI-BELT CONSPIRACY>BENGAL GAVE THE MAXIMUM BLOOD.subhas chandra Bose,KHUDIRAM to TAGORE TO VIVEKANDA TO BOSE(BOSE & EINSTEIN), each as GIANTS CAME OUT OF THIS SOIL.STILL NOW MOST NOBEL PRIZEs WERE WON BY THIS STATE,BENGAL.In the early years of the 20th century, Gopal Krishna Gokhale remarked that what Bengal thinks today, India thinks tomorrow?.NOT AGAIN,BENGAL IS SPEAKING HINDI NOW,ALMOST BEHIND BIHAR> THANKS TO NEHRU JI >SONIA JI KI JAI***>HANUMANJI KI JAI**
Oh my god Anwesha has sung songs in previs episodes so beautifully – nimooda nimooda, so much liveliness , the best punches I have ever heard – like KK, or one can give, Dola re dola -Very difficult song to sing with no place for breathing. That is the caliber of this girl.
sir, this is not called for.. I believe every state has its own uniqueness and beauty.. we have such a diverse culture, but what can make us stronger is unity.. I strongly believe every culture has its own richness and beauty.. It is not only Bengal who is producing best people, but whole of our country.. I am sure everybody can give their own examples.. everybody has their own theories to tell.. that’s why outsiders play the mental game with the border states to create all this nonsense, so that they can indulge in disruption activities to the development of our country.. all invaders have utilized this strategy against us and unfortunately with our comments here, it seems that we are still very much vulnerable.. can’t we live together appreciating each other’s culture?.. mind you, a single separation of a state will result in distruction of our whole country.. whether it is kashmir, punjab, gorkhaland, tamil, bengal, maharashtra, gujrat, etc.. we are living a similar kind of life.. then why can’t we live in a unity?..
I guess we should stop this topic as it is not going to prove anything, but bring bad taste. It is just a reality show where on spur of moment, one judge miss out to say something.. we should not take care of what he said but believe what we are..
HANUMANJI KI JAI!!!!
HINDUSTAHN KI JAI!!!
SONIAJI KI JAI!!!
WHEN MORARJI DESAI, BECAME PRIME MINISTER,he prescribed to drink urine for indians and also for the world ,his secret of health.
even to-day, many are suggesting that!!
same song “MERE HO ” why was not given to ‘ANWESHA DIDI”,a 10yr old asked m ,”it’s not fair” ! He puffed.
I had to tell him SOME Indians are very smart because they drink urine every day,UNLIKE us ,we have to buy drinking water in USA.
he shrieked “yack”
DO WE NEED TO DRINK URINE??MORARJI’S PRESCRIPTION.(INDIA HAS PRODUCED SOME CLASSIC MONKEYS)
TO JUDGE anything: whether two/many talents or students of any subject /any class /any exam :same questions ,same math,same time,same age group etc are given.SAME PARAMETERS WE use universally> India is such a country where a Monkey can do a better job than ITS system of bizarre CONCEPT>Some followers of Morarji desai are saying”please drink your urine before you can think straight!”
both these kids are talented!
BOTH SHOULD BE AWRDED..!no more drinking urine to increse your intellect for sangeet and wasting time!
I STRONGLY BELIEVE WHAT I SAW IN INDIA :MAJORITY OF INDIANS FOLLOW MORARJI’S PRESCRIPTION OF HEALTH TO KNOW A SIMPLE FACT WHAT CAN BE READ BY A 3YR OLD.
I am disappointed Anwesha didn’t win.. but think of it this way, she already will sing in Golmaal 2 and the 2nd place prize is also very immense. :] She will do well, no doubt!!
On a side note, I think one of the joys of the show is listening to Abhas sing in different styles. Although he acts a bit silly, I enjoy listening to his performances.
And will the Chote Ustaad Contestants who didn’t make it perform in the final episode..?
HANUMANJI KI JAI>HNAUMANJI KI JAI>HANUMANJI KI JAI.
ALL YOU NEED IS A MONKEY AND A BANANA AND HE WILL DO A WONDERFUL JOB!
MAKE SURE YOU DRINK YOUR URINE!IT’S A MUST.(REF:HON.PERIMENISTER OF INDIA,SIR MORARJI DEASI.)
REST THE LANGUR WILL DO,YOU DON’T HAVE TO WORRY!
COngratulations!!!!I knew Aish would win. She is fantastic and definitely has a play back singer’s voice. Anwesha was equally good. I think both will do excellent in future with playback singing… Love your voice and my daughter who is 9 months old loves it too
TO GADJI:
WE EXPECTED BOTH FOR AWARDEE.
PUBLIC VOTING SHOULD BE ELIMINATED AND FAIR JUDGEMENT SHOULD BE GIVEN TO TALENT/TALENTS (MAY BE ANY INDIAN,RACE CREED,CASTE OR RELIGON )
IF YOU KEEP DOING IT >THERE COULD BE A CHANCE OF ONE FANATIC MAY SHOOT YOU!
THOUGH I KNOW MOST INDIANS ARE DOCILE.VERY GOOD BOYS.ONLY EATS DAL AND ROTI.MAKES NO NOISE.
WHY IS HE PAKI AND you are abusing him. WHY? he has expressed his opinion >he may be pakistani but he is a music lover.
you should BEHAVE YORUELF BEFORE you attck personally.WHAT IS YOUR LIMIT ,RUDE BOY!
Devkishinji ,
you are right in your review and comments and i am waitng for final episode video to see and your comments.lots of arguments in my family to-day.expected as usual.all are cooling down!we LOVE BOTH KIDS.
Normally,we never ever praise any child more than others.
thank you
The music industry owes a lot to Gajendra Singh for giving such talented people. Shreya Ghoshal, Kunal Ganjawala, Parthiv Goel(Saawariya – Yun Shabnami), Sonu Nigam (it was because of his compering he was more recognized) and now Anvesha and Aishwarya…both were equally good and talented but there has to be one winner…cant help it. If someone can pass this to him, it would be great.
shreya ghosal -yes
sonu nigam-yes
kunal Ganjwala-no.misfit .mediocre
parthiv goel-yes
here GADJI made mistake by not making these two deserving winners, for that he used so maany tactics ;if Nobel can be shared by two,grammy by two then what is chottey ustaad ? of india.
Totally bullshit comments AISHWARIYA WAS THE BEST AND SHE WON VERY FAIRLY…ANWESHA WAS GOOD BUT NOT AS GOOD AS AISHWARIYA….THE JUDGES WERE NOT BIASED AT ALL. JUST GET THE NEGATIVITY OUT OF YOUR MIND.
STOP THIS GANDHIAN POLICY .DON’T BULLSHIT MAN. TALK SOME SNSE OTHERWISE SHUT YOUR MOUTH :
IS BENGAL EQUAL TO THE REST OF INDIA? .WHERE IS YOUR EVIDENCE ??STOP THIS IDOTIC VERSION ,INDIAN.BENGAL IS BENGAL NOT ANY VEGI OR IDOTIC STUPID INDIAN.
We are fully agreed with Mr. Deven. It was clear from last 3/4 episode that Chotte Ustaad autority are given preference to Aisharya. But we think Anvesha already make her place in film industry both in bamgla and Mumbai. We pray for her and hope that she will be a super star like Shreya and Aloka.
GADJI, NEED TO STOP THIS SHOW BEACUSE YOU ARE PROMOTING INJUSTICE.
I WISH SOMEBODY SHOULD SHOOT THIS BUSTARD.
HE USED HIS DIRTY TACTICS TO ABUSE AND THEN GAVE AWRAD TO A SINGLE PERSON.
HOW MUCH NEEDED FOR A GUNMAN IN INDA?
BENGAL;: YOU SHOUD NOT SLEEP WITH THIS INJUSTICE>SHOOT THIS BUSTARD ,GAJJI.HE IS THE CULPRIT.EVEN PRITAM TOLD HIM TO AWARD THIS TO BOTH.>>THIS THICK HEADED MAN NEED SOME BULLETS IN HIS BRAIN.
I am sure you must be a mental patient.. just review your comments, you can make it out.. ohh, but how can you do that when you are..
if you have a little bit of sense left, look at what all garbage you are writing here.. anyway who cares for your nonsense theories.. and stop using somebody else’s identity.. ok !!!
Mr.Vivek,
Gajji is making money from this chotte ustaad. he has his vested interest. He is not making it free and he is not a GOD HEAD,AVATAR,LORD KRISHNA.
this man knows the trade very well .he is not a musican.he is a businessman ,a promoter with high school education.
He is good in his business but he is unethical.
Dr.Biswas,
you are 200% correct.west bengal should separate out of india (hindi belt) and join the east Bengal and become one Bengal. These Non-bengali are anti Bengali and keep their grudges as they can’t compete at intellectual level.
Bengal is marginalised in everyway :yur satement is so true.
Budha dev Bhattacharya should stop co-operation with the center and we need our industrialisation separate.
devenji,
aap history vi jante nehi,ijjath vi nehi hain>aap log hai kia? 200 saal kutta ki tera angrej ko chamcha kye hain,aaj vi chamchagiri kartye rahe .
Dr.Biswas,
Gujrat episode reveals the true picture of india.
The people who are logging here as Mr.deven or fairy and others are just acting stupid because they understand now that there is no room for argument.they realised that Gujrat is a true picture of whole of India.
Majority of these people do not have any knowlegede of India and its history.so they don’t like to hear the truth.
Bengal was deliberately marginalised by MR.JAWAHARLAL NEHRU> his intention was to divert the center of administration of india OUT OF BENGAL and Bengali hands.even in 1947,Bengal had the highest educated bengali than WHOLE OF INDIA.once Mr. shamaprasad Mukherjee,son of SIR ASUTOSH MUKEHRJEE was killed in kashmir jail on FAKE CHARGE. Indira Gandhu did the same in emergency!! a man like Vajpayee(the most honest and rsepected person of Indian politics) was sent to jail.he was sure the DELHI MASNAD will remain HIS AND HIS NEHRU FAMILY.thank GOD, RAJIV GNADHI WAS KILLED AND HOPE FULLY RAHUL GANDHI will BE ELIMNATED> so that delhi Masnad will be free from NEHRU FAMILY.
thnaks for revealing the truth.
congress party.stupid ,uneducated sonia Gandhi and his son rahul gandhi should never step foot in Bengal.Bengal need to open borders with Bangladesh and make more flow of trade and commerce along with cultural acivity.center should be marginalised and Non-bengali in west bengal should not be given any land acquisiton. BENGAL SHOULD BE FOR BENGALI FIRST >NOT A CLIENT STATE TO CENTER.
Thanks again for your insight.
I can understand Dr.Biswas because Gujrat episode was the last farce in this Gajji drama. i read all his comments>he always recommended anwesha+ aiswarya = award.
it was told by pritam ,the judge ,Mr.bacchan himself admitted in grand finale but still the award was given to aisywaria.it was TOTALLY UNFAIR.
DR.Biswas is a just person and he speaks unequivocally,may be his style is very forceful but it’s the truth: gujrat episode has revealed clearly the true picture of india.THE VERY NAKED TRUTH.
haha.. why don’t you guys go in some other bengali forum and discuss your vows?.. this forum is to discuss performances of Anwesha and Aish.. I am a big fan of Anwesha, not because of her being a bengali, ok.. and so do others..
as for history goes, we punjabi were always the first who faced/blocked the invaders.. deven is my real name and I don’t believe in fake identities.. if you think talking about unity is chamchagiri then it is a stupid thought.. why don’t you guys understand that by dividing all of these states, we won’t exist at all !!! my point is just that.. and I am not challenging anybodies capabilities.. I myself don’t believe in Gandhi’s policy.. but I am afraid that the way every region is asking about their autonomy, it is not long that we may not exists at all..
Luckily I have two very close friends: one bengali and one gujrati.. when I told all this, they also says that this is all non sense
prakriti ,with honesty and decency have left a mark on every person to adore her.when she left,she smiled and melted away with that dignity.
when she got the highest public votes,she said” i don’t deserve it”
even when she was humilated, she wept with dignity, admitted that she sang flat with dignity.
can other Indians learn from this little girl,what is decency and honesty?
Indians seems to have become the most corrupt nation on earth!! MOST INDIANS ARE UNTRUHFUL AND CORRUPT AND WON’T ACCEPT IT!
rani Mukerhjee>when asked by abhaas,a bengali girl couldn’t find a bengali bhajan or bengali song >she sang “rosgolla” ,a street slang: is a SAD PHASE,an arist >rabindra nath,dijendra lal,nazrul,atul prasad,and million others .a vast ocean of songs, poetry.
SAME WITH SHREYA
SHAAN(SHANTANU MUKHERJEE):can’t find bengali to express.asked by abhijit >he stammered in few words.
why india doens’t change “jana mano” to hindi >making their own hindi lyrics.stolen everything >what is left.
can you imagine an italian,highschool graduate became a congress president in a country of 1.2 billion people with no political experience or education? indians accepted her with NATAMASTAK.
how smart are these indians? jackass,indeed.
@Md.zubair
pritam has unequivocally told in grandfinale and also before :technically anwesha and aiswyaria are equal and the award should be shared by two NOT One.
so he abstained and he told this to guest in chief “Mr.Bacchan”
you are absolutely right.
Thanks
What kind of language is this? I feel sorry for you and your thinking. You must have a very bad childhood. sounds like if you were not brought up with good moral values. People like you are the ones who spread hatred among people. You should never be given an access to the internet. Take care of yourself. I think you need it in your life. By the way, grow up!
great music talent show. Everyone enjoys it and some of you with such a narrowmindedness and close minds can pass beyond certain levels and keep bringing in racism in. can you just cheer up for god sake. Learn to enjoy life a bit
Suman no matter what you say openly advocating shooting someone is mad behaviour – this is what nazzis/fundamentalists do when things dont go their way. We sane law abiding citizens behave differently for example peaceful demonstration. What is this guy Biswas doing apart from vomiting all over this place. If he feels so strongly why doesnt he carry out a demonstration..
Well in any case this guy, Biswas, sounds like a new born HITLER from bengal. Mr Biswas it might do you some good to read European history. And by the way rabindra sangeet is rather a drag musically – it may have great lyrics but no musical merit whatsover. So please shut up…
FOR JOHN,THE MORON:JOHN,THE INDIAN
SUMAN & ALL INDIAN
PLEASE then ask this moron WHO says “rabindra sangeet is a drag” then how two countires bangldeash and INDIA chose “Jono Gono Mono Adhinaayako….. RoBinDro Songeet ” and “sonar bangla” both countires NATIONAL ANTHEM> http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aUa3JG7loi8&watch_response
BOTH THE SONGS ARE RABINDRA SANGEET AND ALL RABINDRA SANGEET BASED ON RAGAS.
JOHN,MUST BE AN CHRISTAN IDIOT WHO HAS NO CLUE WHAT IS RABINDRA SANGEET.”GITANJALI” FOR WHICH TAGORE GOT THE FIRST NOBEL IN ASIA.
WHERE :THIS JOHN, THE ORANGUTAN COMES FROM?”
“THE MORE MOKEY CLIMBS UP ,THE MORE IT EXPOSES ITSELF”
hi aap sahi keh rahe yeh preplanned tha ki aishwariya ko jeetana hai isme koi sak nahin hai
aur hamari anwesha toh uska future hi nahin uska present bhi bahut bright hai
john:
1.people express their anger in different ways some uses foul language ,some uses ‘go to hell” and all different ways>Dr.Biswas ‘s expression of anger ‘shoot ‘ is not literal sense but you are calling him as hitler is stupid
2.rabindrasangeet :you donot know >majority of indians don’t know> doesn’t matter>you don’t comment.(i doubt you are Indian,anyway)
To each is his own>”some” hindi film music is cheap and peppy and people consider it as trash.
3.shut your mouth: shows you are uncivilized person
i doubt we have to read any european history to be civilized.
Bengali children who are born out of state do not learn bengali (except speaking,many can’t even read)as a result there is no difference between a bengali living in delhi or bombay and a NON- BENGALI living in bengal,both can’t read it>both donot know BENGALI literature AS a result they know “hindi & english” .
RABINDRA NATH,SARAT OR BANKIM are only the names but never ever have read the literature and as a result they have NO CLUE.rich BENGALI literature and sangeet never touch their heart.
HINDI CULTURE AND BOLLYWOOD WITH ITS CHEAP ENTERTAINMENT AND GOVERNMENT’s EFFORT TO DESTROY THE CULTURE HAS TAKEN ITS TOLL.THE BENGALI LIVING OUT OF STATE HAVE BECOME NON-BENGALI IN REAL SENSE.EVEN IN STATE>FEW CHILDREN read Bengali literature.
THIS IS REALITY OF INDIA.it’s a shock to you but that is reality.AS A RESULT> VAST ocean of knowledge remain elusive. LANGUAGE IS THE KEY TO CULTURE>WHEN THE KEY IS LOST ,CULTURE IS LOST>so Rani Mukherjee can’t find a bengali bhajan and bengali song where Rabindra sangeet alone is 85000.
evrymood,every occasions and every ragas to folk(baul) to western >you name it>rest aside nazrul,Drijendralal,atul prasad and million others.
THIS IS INDIA TO-DAY.(I am writing this for you as a BENGALI,living abroad ,your expectation is very high and that has made you angry. whereas i am as a Bengali living here in calcutta but travelling to other states of India and abroad, both uk & usa,has made me realised that)
Tagore lived 80yrs>longest among all talents >his pen never stopped from 5yrs
“kije ora pachhey khete orai seta janey,chagal bolye bechye achye praney.”
Suman,
1) it is preposterous to assume that anyone with the name JOHN is not Indian. This is just another reflection of irrationality of you guys – especially mr Biswas. I am sure not many christians in india will be pleased by your commment.
2) i am well trained in indian classical music – in dhrupad dagarbani style. My comment on rabindra sangeet still stands. Sorry if it hurts your ‘bengali nationalism’. I am no advocate of bollywood music (another assumption on your part).
3) My analogy to hitler still stands. But you wound not understand it if you havent studied world war two. People often think they should only confine to studying their local history. Any history is GLOBAL..you will only become wiser by studying it.
4) Just like BJP and other fundamentalist parties thrive on religious agenda but are light years away from what religion is, so are many of you bengali’s who thrive on praising great figures from bengal are light years away from what these figures have actually stood for. If Mr Biswas even had an inkling of Rabindranath or Sri Aurobindo’s preachings he will never behave in such an OBSCENCE way on the net.
5) it is deplorable the way you guys critisise INDIANS and praise BENGALIS. You must have a really low self esteem. I can only feel sorry for you.
Enough said – i am not going to waste any more space on net. Reflect on it or throw it away in a dustbin. your choice.
What is uncivilised about asking someone to shut up, someone who is openly attributing motifs, calling names, advocating shooting/killing/violence (e.g. “people of bengal go and shoot ..”)? How can you even support such a person – I am only asking this to you as I have a feeling that you are a sane person
suman:
1)please ask west Bengal govt. to totally eradicate the congress from west bengal.
(how a stupid italian sonia with highschool education became a CONGRESS PRESIDENT in a country of 1.2 billion people with no political experience or education? -is a shame for all indians: christian chapter of portugese to india of past and present italian are all shameful and corrupt)
2)BAN Mr.gajji to use west bengal for his puppy show of gujrat.
3)stayjit ray didn’t go to bollywood to get his oscar and world recognition
4)center govt.should lay off dirty hand of viswabharati, its not to make it hindiwallah’s dabbah.
5)KICK OFF UPA GOVT. TO COLLAPSE.
6)KICK OFF WHERE BENGAL’S INTERST IS MARGINALISED.
BENGAL GIVES MAX.REVENUE AND SHE NEEDS TO TAKE CARE OF HER OWN PEOPLE FIRST.
The sign of dooms are already there as you see illiterate people are jigging and glorifying a simple event like “chotte ustad” shamelessly and heard what is the position of judges made nonfunctional.
i remember when sheik Muzibar rehman’s last speech against the west pakistani of punjabi regime”amader sangram mukitr sangram”.Today,west bengal is in the same stage .as calcutta was capital for 200yrs NOT DELHI, nehruji was determined to marginalise BENGAL from day one. The next regime followed the SAME formula ..till present day sonia gandhi.JUST IMAGINE HOW MANY HIGHLY EDUCATED PEOPLE HAVE BEEN MADE ‘ULLUCK’ AND SHE TOOK OVER!!!SHOCKING!
its not what Gajji awarded anwesha or aiswyaria >IT’S THE TRICKS OF PUBLIC VOTING>CONSTANT SHIFTING GEAR OF HIS PRINCPLES>IT’S THE CUNNING WAYS HE APPLIED ,PSYCHOLOGICAL PAINS TO THESE CHILDREN AND THEIR PARENTS HE USED AND YET DECEIVED THE IMAGE OF PUBLIC PERCEPTION AS AVATAR.
YES> ITS’ THE MASTER CRAFTER >IT’S THE SAME DECEPTION AND INJUSTICE,I HATE.
i forgot SONIA GANDHI was given OFFER to become PRIME MINISTER OF INDIA***>DRINKING URINE OF MORARJI DESAI IS WORKING FOR INDIA!!!CLASSIC JACKASS STATE**
1. Christanity came to India by Portuguese mainly>it was a forced conversion of lower caste Hindus> a shameful chapter of Indian history. Shameful because it was the biggest traitors for India who supported the colonial master and in the history of freedom struggle of India their participation was with the master. That’s why when Independence was imminent, large mass of Christians migrated to Australia and newzeland.Here in park street area, a large portion was Christian community, they disappeared overnight in Calcutta. Goa, Daman and Duke, were freed by Indian soldiers after India got her independence.
Role of Christianity in slave trade of was notorious. When white master was brutally flogged the slaves, the Christian fathers brain washed the NEGROS to remain submissive. CHRISTIANITY PLAYED THAT DOUBLE STANDARD ROLE CLEVERLY. EVEN IN USA,FATHERS ENGAGED IN SODOMIZING LITTLE CHILDREN,COULDN’T BE PROSECUTED; ultimately the US SUPREME COURT had to take action against the VATICAN to prosecute them and put them behind bar. Indian chapter will not be any different, only Indian court system has no such power (ARE YOU KIDDING! SONIAJI, an Italian Christian is our congress president). So what is Christianity in India is anybody’s guess.
2. Rabidbra nath Tagore, a Nobel laureate was an international figure, not BENGALI, not Indian, not Asian, WORLD FIGURE. VISWA BHARATI, first international open university for the world.
INDIA (GOVT. OF INDIA, not west Bengal govt) took charge for shantiniketan for basking in that Tagore’s image. Originally, shantiniketan land and property was bought by prince Dwarka nath thakur.Tagore made the institution with his Nobel Prize money (NOT FROM GOVT. OF INDIA).
His sangeet, his vast works of literature is not for Bengali, Indian or Asian, it’s for world. Whether a man john, dhrupad singer from KERALA evaluates his sangeet lyrics or melody is a laughing joke!! To-day works of Tagore has been translated to 36 countries and included in most us universities curriculum of literature.
Language is a key to culture, how a keralite who doesn’t know Bengali would understand the lyrics? Insane???
3. Whether I need to study world world2, European history to become pundit like you? – the answer is no.
4. Religion’s light year away: religion and ignorance are synonymous in India, where humanity is neglected: “bhagwan ko dud khilao” is a joke. Religion has caused more ignorance, darkness, and divisions and still remains the main cause of superstitions and backwardness. political parties take the cover of religions to get vote bank –all of them do that not BJP ALONE.
5. What’s India to-day is a reality, criticism is a part of self –consciousness and only people with self esteem can do that. To us Bengali, we inherit such a vast legacy of talents that ignorance is NOT bliss to us.SO INTROSPECTION & SELF ASSESSMENT IS A PART OF OUR DAILY CONSCIUOSNESS.
I think Anvesha is much better than Aishwarya because Anvesha is versatile singer in Surs she has very large scale to sing every kind of song. you can observe this in her last performance on 5-April-08 when she sung “Ami Je Tomar”
THIS IS INDIA TO-DAY
Indians are the biggest hypocrite on earth.
He learns to speak in bifurcated tongue,like a serpent.on one tongue he admits that both are eually talented, on another he declares his single winner.Hindu superstitions damages the logic and consciousness of mental faculty.he becomes the prisoner of his own prison of obscurantist ideology.obsessive and compulsive behavior becomes his daily practice and logic goes far from his brain.This Musical event is a classic example.if both kids were awarded,what harm would have happened ? Nothing but two children would have been given the justice and recognition for their talents & hard work.
stone statues get more milk than hungry children on the street and vivekanada’s message becomes a portrait of creating fake image.THIS IS INDIA TO-DAY.
Excellent comment.. Specially, the one about statues and hungry children.. superstitions.. I’ll add –> I HATE all those who kills their daughters in womb itself.. people who throw garbage everywhere: street, buses, trains.. managers, who think people working under him/her are slaves (no work etiquette, ethics).. regionalism.. and so many other things like that..
I boil just thinking about them.. India has potential to become the top country in the world, that’s it.. cos they will not going to become one in next hundred years if these things still persist.. which will, cos nothing seems to be improving.. only that we are gaining more garbage from western world instead of gaining their good points..
I feel so happy seeing these highly talented kids perform, but then feel sad due to the way people are playing with their emotions through elimination rounds, dramabaazi and using these kids talent to earn huge money..
The whole teaching of Bhagavad Gita is to FIGHT AGAINST INJUSTICE.krishna was asking ARJUN to fight. Arjun said “krishna,my friend,i don’t want to fight against my own relatives and cousins . i prefer to surrender.” krishna COMPELLED HIM TO FIGHT.That’s the essence of Bhagavad gita. http://www.thoughtware.tv/videos/show/1578
Robert openheimer ,was the chief scientist and director of LOS ALAMOS NUCLEAR CENTER,CA,USA.
Albert Einstein: When I read the Bhagavad-Gita and reflect about how God created this universe everything else seems so superfluous.
I have asked many scientists here in UC BERKELEY AND OTHER CAMPUSES,WHY they read this book? ANSWER:”inspiration to do the just and fight agianst unjust.”
The Mahabharata has all the essential ingredients necessary to evolve and protect humanity and that within it the Bhagavad-Gita is the epitome of the Mahabharata
Suman, Your comment about christinaty really sent a chill through my spine – how pathetic really to use such arguments. Should i hate all germans because some of them killed jews. OR should we start hating all hindus because they burnt sikhs…OR should we hate all americans because they bombed japan. You dont use history to hate people – you use history to learn what to and what not to – and hatred is ceratinly in the list of what not to! YOu use history to develop compassion.
Another sign of irrationality – First i was european, now i am keralite (with obvious contempt of course!! ), and you make second assumption based on your first assumption that keralites can’t learn dhrupad). I wonder what do i become next time? ok let me unleash the truth – i am originally a delhite nd although kerala has always been on at the top of my list as places to visit, i unfortunately have not yet had the opportunity:). LOL.
Its interesting you guys make assumptions and then another set of assumptions based on those assumptions and then begin arguing wtih a sword in your hand. So Ms Suman let me teach you one important lesson. Assumptions are made to test hypothesis – they cannot be used as arguments. You obviously did not study science in high school/college ???
Finally cant you read. I am talking about music and not literature…so your entire retort on rabindra sangeet is not relevant to this discussion..
WELL RELISH IN YOUR BENGALI GHETTO…and your superloop of assumptions. May God bless you.
Question: why are you writing bad about gajji on the blog site?
In grand finale ANWESHA SANG “ami je tomar”,IT OBVIOUSLY EMBARASSED MS.JUHI CHOWLA SO SHE BECAME NERVOUS TO ANOUNCE THE NAME AND TURNED TO ANWESHA “BOTH OF YOU SHOULD HAVE THIS AWARD”
THIS DID MADE AMITAV BACCHAN PAUSED IN AWE THEN HE RESUMED HIS TACTICS LIKE OLD POLITICIAN AND ANOUNCED”MY BAHU”
SILENCE AND GRACE CAME OVER ANWESHA SHE TURNED HER GAZE DOWNWARD AND ACCEPTED THE DEFEAT.HER EXCELLENCE AND SILENCE SPAT AND SMACKED THE DIRECTOR’S FACE ,IF HE HAS ANY BREED AND SHAME.OBVIOUSLY GAJJI REMAINED UNSEEN FOR SEVERAL REASONS BUT ONE REASON FOR SHAME IN PUBLIC APPEARENCE!
I would request people to spit on this GAJJI and his image, picture.a coward ,unkuth and shameless creature who has no decency and breed.
i am sure this webmaster must be carrying some message to his master. if born as swine,then it’s hard that spit and mud could disgrace him! he should read these comments and realize how much public hate him!
sri ramkrishna used to say “maan ar hunsh nye manush” means maan + hunsh = manush (man)
here people has no self-esteem(maan) or consciousness(hunsh).every day in India, so many social injustice take place through ignorance and superstition but people don’t mind it.They never protest or try to rectify it.
the man who commits injustice and who tolerates that injustice are equally guilty.
This musical event was a shere injustice but i don’t hear any protest> so many people were there in the grand finale remained silent like herd of goats.The whole audience , heard twice from PRITAM THAT BOTH SHOULD BE AWARDED BUT REMAINED SILENT. IS IT VEGETARIAN MEALS MAKE THEM LIKE THAT OR WHAT? NO TESTOSTERONE,EFFEMINATE LIKE AN EEL.
NOT A SINGLE “AWAZ” WAS HEARD !!!
NOTHING,SHAMEFUL AND INEPT >GOD HELP THESE MENTAL RETARDATION,PLEASE! I AM STILL IN A SHOCK FROM A FAR LAND!
Both anwesha and aiswyaria are equally talented and both of them should have got the award.
aiswyaria is a beautiful child,she is well mannered and has all the social grace as anwesha but what is magical about this child is her stagefree appearence and oratory quality.i think she has acquaired that ability so great that she uses her diction and gesture like a professional orator on stage(being exposed to stage at an early age).even in distress she has learned to control her emotions fully:one has to admire that.14yrs has comforted her parents and colleagues equally: leadership quality.
judges were either stammering,verbose or at a loss for word.kunal is totally immatured and a headless chicken.he can crow at anytime as dawn.pritam is still a humanist.shreya is a cold feet and nervous lady but she is kind and shy.
anchor is a hyperactive child.sometimes ok sometimes has attention seeking behavior.
guest judges: abhijit is a 3yr brain in an adult body.rest are simple & ordinary.
audience:calcutta audience respectable and hospitable to guest.Gujrat is hostile and uncivilized.Bhopal is uneducated and imbecile.rajasthan is warm and enjoyable.
gaji:unfortunate man who needs counselling for direction
Big B:self grandiose idot who thinks that he is a shahensha to poor(500m)indians who go to hindi cinema with 2 weeks salary without food.he is nothing to international level or Bengal level.
he has not achieved neither european,russian or american level any such award to satyajit ray for berlin,french & oscar or saumitra & suchitra with moscow and berlin awards.
He also tried his luck first with nehru family,then politics>then he has bagged two ladies first jaya, a bengali star and aiswyaria,a marathi star as bahu for his ugly and imbecile son who has no star quality.
I just want to comment on one thing.. Vegie diet is much more healthier than non-veg diet in all means.. There is a lot written about cons of Animal Protein and I just don’t want to start discussing that (cos lots of detail is available on net on this).. My point is that if someone has capability to bravely stand up for truth, then it is not becos of a diet.. I am non-vegetarian but I stand by with vegetarians..
When there is a competition, there has to be one winner.. a tie doesn’t mean anything.. 2 lakh vote is huge difference to clearly make one person winner.. pritam’s point does not make any sense.. who cares about him.. he is a big copy cat, who can’t create one single tune by himself..
we shall accept the result gracefully.. I am a big fan of anwesha and I also felt very bad.. but that is fine.. as per me, she is still the best.. she has got all the limelight she deserves which will ensure her bright future.. she doesn’t seem to be that upset like us, so then why making it a big deal?
answer to vegie diet for indians:
1.the way indians COOK & EAT their vegie,the vegie are OVERCOOKED,SPICED &OILY,IT’S NUTRITIONAL VALUE IS ZERO OR MINUS.i saw with my own eyes during my visit in india.
stunted growth and malnutrition is rampant by WHO,UNDP,UNESCO REPORT. http://web.worldbank.org/WBSITE/EXTERNAL/COUNTRIES/SOUTHASIAEXT/0,,contentMDK:20916955~pagePK:146736~piPK:146830~theSitePK:223547,00.html
SINCE YOU ARE A WEB PUNDIT AND ARGUE WITH EVERYTHING>READ IT ATLEAST ONE.
MOST INDIANS ARE IGNORANTS AND IGNORANCE IS A BLISS IN INDIA.all they can argue foolishly.
Majority of indians, very few have reading habits and claim knowledge> very few houses i visited, ALL middleclass has any library or books at home>displayed electronics tvs,jewellery and car>unhealthy life style and fat like pigs .
yet they all claim to be pundit,knowldgeable and highly talented.The best examples are the delhi doctors and IMC(indian medical council).3000 fake doctors without licence practice in delhi>the most council admn members of the IMC are ignorant doctors who neither want to accept the responsiblity ,even after 60yrs,it’s function is abysmally low and unacceptable ,occupied by ignorant brains who don’t want any change..THIS IS THE CONDITION of intelligentsia no wonder British medical council has withdrawn its recognition.
Thanks sir for your comments.. I had some healthy discussion with you before and I respect you as you are my elder.. We learn and practice to respect our elders (I can say that becos I am an INDIAN).. I have no intention to argue with you or anybody here.. See my comments, I was never harsh with anyone.. I also took your sarcastic comment of me as web pundit lightly..
I live in US for quite some time, but I still love to be connected to my country, with all its problem.. Instead of cribbing, I will go and do something on my own..
I don’t boast of a library at my home, but we have huge collection of books and everyone in my house love reading.. we are health freak; regular visitors of health club and eat a very healthy diet..
I want to stop this thread as too much of “I” is making me feel small.. We should just discuss music here in place of world affairs; that I believe..
only way a nation or a person can improve in health and education is to have self-introspection (self realisation) and then implement the good ones and REMOVE the bad ones through knowledge(self actualisation)(GET RID OF RELIGIOUS SUPERSTITIONS & PREJUDICES OR ANY IGNORANCE BY STRONG WILL).
i have been trying to rectify the IMC (indian medical council)FOR YEARS and even visited their office in newdelhi but failed to change them.THESE ARE IGNORANT DOCTORS WHO ARE HOLDING THE WHOLE INDIAN MEDICAL SYSTEM AT HOSTAGE AND KEEP THEIR SEATS.THEY SHOULD BE REMOVED COMPLETELY.THE MINISTRY OF HEALTH IS LIKE JOKERS AT WORK.
HEALTH & EDUCATION are the two main indexes of human developemnt. basic amenties as clean water,basic food and environmental cleanliness are absolutely essential to life.knowledge for NUTRITION AND FOOD PREPARATION ARE ABSOLUTELY necessary from school level to university level.
READING HABIT is absolutely necessary to be knowledgable.you can never be educated without it.TV IS the biggest distraction AND MAKES YOU STUPID.COMPUTER EDUCATION SHOULD BE PROMOTED.
http://ocw.mit.edu/OcwWeb/web/home/home/index.htm
OPENWARE MIT IS GOOD SOURCE but THERE ARE MANY ELECTRONIC SOURCE SPECIALLY Carnegie Mellon Institute & STANFORD. DEPENDING on one’s interests. mayoclinic and john hopkins are specially good for medical reference.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fea1OF7C91A
on the right side are anwesha golf green,calcutta and and recent episodes from personal video > thanks to RAJA from calcutta.
rest music LOVERS ENJOY!!anwesha duttagupta.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jr3JfNOcMCc&feature=related
this is an interview with JAYANTA SARKAR AND ANWESHA DUTTAGUPTA.
SPECIALLY TO DEVKISHANJI , DEAR FRIEND.
REST ENJOY!!
THANKS RAJA FROM CALCUTTA.
I WILL TRY TO CONTACT AGAIN.
The only objective of this interviews are simply to ask those who are parents:
1. to nurture your kids for their talents.
2.promote health and education
3.combat ignorance.
when you will watch these video clips you will realize what a trmendous contributions take place from MOTHER,FATHER & TEACHER(GURU)for a child to grow his/her talent to a full bloom.
PROMOTE HEALTH SHOULD BE OUR GOAL IN LIFE WITH EDUCATION (2ND) AND KILLING IGNORANCE IS A MUST(3RD)SHOULD BE OUR MAIN DHARMA AND DUTY.
i watched anwesha’s interview in kolkata studios. anwesha’s real talent was visible in song “lag ja gale___”,she was simply awesome. had she been given old melodius songs in chhote ustad show she would have probably bagged the title . the sound system/equipment in kolkata studios is of very high standard as the echo effect enhanced the beauty of the song. anwesha’s vocal chords are maturing with the age and she almost sounded like lata mangeshkar.
god bless her .
devkishinji, one thing is very clear for both anwesha and aiswyaria that they both have good classical base and from this interview it was emphasized what you had once mentioned> then of course the whole selection of songs were just bizzare according to hindi films > just too confusing!!specially for us we never knew even who was who!we really thank their parents for their love and support.
thanks for your musical knowledge and contributions.
doctor biswas i highly appreciate tour balanced and logical views. you were the only person on this blog who always maintained that the two finalists in chhote ustad show were equally talented and deserved to be the joint winners .i fully agree with you. the real talent was never tested in the programme. anwesha suffered more at the hands of the music direcrors as she was given rather ordinary numbers particularly at ahmedabad,a crucial penultimate episode.
anwesha proved herself that she was the best classical singer and this country needs such talents badly.if we have to revive our traditional music, based on ragaas, then anwesha is here to bring back the golden era of indian music.she is only hope in this age of senseless pop music.
Thank you, devji >pop culture will bring drug culture and all the ills with it.we look up to India for beautiful musical culture if that is destroyed, except bollywood ,nothing will remain.
With these two talents: they are equally talented but aiswyaria’s stage free and oratory ability with emotional control is exemplary for 14yrs.i have given that credit to her on her blog.
What I can’t understand that why this musical show lags professionalism? The deficit shows on selection of songs, judges, elimination and grading etc.
With such huge expenses, why Gajji doesn’t make a musical institute, where talents could be trained for future. As much as I criticize this man, undoubtedly he has quality to organize musical shows in India. In many frustrations: IMC and Indian ministry of health both at the center and state level are big frustrations for me. HEALTH & MEDICAL EDUCATION are very close to my heart. Politics & nepotism are the biggest hindrance for medical admissions in India. Real talents are excluded and some mediocres are included, terrible frustration for me. In a simple example like this musical show, people argue senselessly about the talent of the two kids when they can see but don’t want to accept is a prejudice (ignorance).That’s why I say “killing ignorance is our dharma & duty”.
excellent observations dr biswasji.
we come across so many ills in our society but we as individuals are quite helpless. some organisation should come forward and provide leadership to carry out the vital changes for better and bright tomorrow.
kanu-da, is much senior to us ,we graduated from same medical college in Calcutta: an inspiring role model in personal and professional life.
I have a list of 120 brilliant top most Indian doctors (UK, USA, CANADA) and 50 MBA who would like to contribute to Indian medical system could revolutionize the system to world class but Indian Ministry of health and IMC (Indian medical council) and state level politics are reluctant to accept them .Indian skin and corruption are so thick that my acidic comments and remarks they can digest with ease. NO SHAME, NO CONSCIENCE AND NO GUILT for deceiving a mass of humanity at ransom. They have created such a barricade that nothing at those levels could affect them. THESE ARE SCUM of low level intelligence guarding their positions.
What do you think what is our limit? did you see if Amanat did not win yet again he got already work in bollywood. I agree aishwarya was better. but every one has his own point of view. so you better keep your mouth shut.
What I must say that Both of them sing equally well!!! It may be true someway that judges tried their best to make Aishwariya win; but she also sings very well!!!
But anyway, through out the series Anwesha sang very well!! you have to realize it that everywhere in the world judges are biased….the judges are not the world’s bst judges…they made Aish win only because the final episode was in Gujarat…if it was in Bengal, there was no doubt of winning of Anwesha!!!
secondly I am replying this against Waqar!! You dont know any thing about singing!!!
This for devkishinji,
what other news now in Mumbai for Musical show ?
i know you are keen for every musical show .please let us know if online anything available. pl keep well.
with regards
DR BISWASJI,
NAMASTE. TRUST THIS POST FINDS YOU AND YOUR ENTIRE FAMILY IN PINK OF HEALTH.
WE DON’T HAVE ANWESHA AND AISHWARYA IN ANY OF THE PROGRAMMES AT PRESENT.
there is however one new musical show on star plus on fridays and saturdays at 10 p.m.-indian time. the winners and the runner-ups in various music reality shows are paticipating in this programme called”jo jeeta wohi super star” the prize money for the winner is rs. 50 lacs.the judges are music composers duo vishal-shekhar and choreographer cum director farah khan mother of triplets born to her recently.
this show is watchable but not in same class as chhote ustad.
i have requested star plus to create a new blog on net for this show.
the legend amitabh bachchan’s own blog—www.blogs.bigadda.com is on the net since17th april and on an average more than 500 comments are posted by the bloggers every day. amitabh bachchan himself is blogging on the site everyday and his sense of humour and extraordinary perception of various matters gives an insight into his great mind. he is indeed a man of letters .a dignity, honesty, integrity personified.
the man who came to mumbai a city of dreams,from kolkata ,settled here and became a legend.
a very interesting blog indeed.
there is a website riafashions.com(ria is my grand daughter)this site is being monitored by my daughter manju and grand daughter khushboo with inputs by deepak my son-in-law.you will find some well designed tunics on the site which we are getting stiched here and sending to my daughter in new jersey for sale.all clothes are moderately priced and are quite attractive.just have a look at india-made tunics.
my e-mail id –devkishinvyas@gmail.com
with regards,
devkishin,mumbai.
Sorry, comments for this entry are closed at this time.
About Big Boss 5
After the resounding success of season Bigg Boss 4, Salman Khan returns to host another exciting season of the hit reality TV show. And this time he has an accomplice in Sanjay Dutt.
172 Responses to “Chote Ustad Videos – 4th April Episode”
By Muhammad Zubair, Karachi, Pakistan on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
This was the worst episode of Chhote Ustaad. Behaviour of the crowd by biased. Morever, judges have now completely biased. They are trying their utmost to pressurise Anwesha by giving easy songs to Aishwarya, ignorning her mistakes in singing and still encouraging her by giving Sartaj Servottams. On the other hand, they are giving meaningless and never heard of songs to Anwesha.
I have no hesitation in saying that the entire team of Chhote Ustaad is involved in making Aishwarya win.
However, I must say that these bad tactics cannot keep away a nice and talented singer Anwesha from becoming a big star in Bollywood.
By Muhammad Zubair, Karachi, Pakistan on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
I am fully convinced that the absence of Pritam from the show must have been his dissent and protest against the biased behaviour of other two judges.
Had there been a genuine reason for absence of Pritam, the same must have been mentioned in the program.
By jatin on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
Rupinder & Ronnie,
From my side both Aishwarya and Anwesha may go to hell. I care less. I am not voting for any body. I am saving my votes for Ishmeet in the next show Superstar.
yesterday Kunal ganjawala displayed his racist mentality by taking every religion’s name except for sikh religion. This shows how sikhs are ignored by the people of our country. No wonder why Ishmeet had to suffer so much racism in the show.
Rupinder, I am sad that inspite of being a sikh u could not understand my views. Your stattement regarding aishwarya’s day paying me was childish.
By Muhammad Zubair, Karachi, Pakistan on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
Correction: Behaviour of the crowd was biased….
By jatin on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
These reality shows have become a medium for some ppl to show their anger and disgust for sikh community as a whole. Some people just cant tolerate a sikh guy coming forward in such shows. Gajendra singh also made sure that is no sikh participant in chotte ustaad. He also has a racist mindset. Despite winning Ishmeet has been insulted because he belongs to the sikh community. People hv made it a habit of insulting sikhs even after sikh community has done so many sacrifices for the country and Hindu religion.
By Muhammad Zubair, Karachi, Pakistan on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
Correction: judges have now become completely biased
By chandinani on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
Jatin, Zubair,
I see that you guys are getting emotional. As I have said in my earlier posts, this is ALL BUSINESS!! Organizers know very well what MIRCH MASALA people want, what kind of controversies incite people…and thats exactly what they serve. Gajendra is a guy with master mind and sharp eye for opportunity to make money.
My only advice to you guys is, you also figure out how to make money from all this, the way I have done it.
By chandinani on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
Devkishinji,
your comments please!
By deven on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
Just saw this episode man.. this is biasing and nothing else.. first Anwesha is given average numbers.. Aish was given the most soulful of song in “Janeja” and she has literally s’ed that up.. still judges were praising it.. amazing man !!!.. What is that stupidity of that aish and her father’s padosan medley, for?.. This show made it clear that they want Aishwarya to win.. it very much clear there.. real disgusting man.. the show is moving to such a sad end.. doesn’t matter if Anwesha loses it.. but still that is going to pinch me a lot and I guess all music lover who followed it up with their soul.. cos even this show made it very much clearer.. that Anwesha is FARFARFAR superior.. she is the best.. and she should have win this contest..
By Shazib on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
anvesha will be the king.
By deven on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
Aish Performance: I donno of the first gujrati number.. it didn’t sound great to me.. “Jisse dhundta hun” was horribly sung.. “Dil cheez Kiya he” there was no right pace to the song.. it was a pain to listen to it.. “Janeja” totally s’ed up.. there was no soul, no feeling, no pace in the song.. it was kind of dragged singing.. I donno how kunal and shreya bear her rendition.. kunal new that she has sung it so badly, why he still praised it.. he should have known the best about the mistakes she made, cos he is the original singer.. I donno what was going on there..
And my gosh.. gujrat crowd was the most biased crowd that I have seen.. Calcutta was much better..
Anwesha’s Performance: “Kemche” was decent.. In sense there is nothing great in the song.. still Anwesha has sung it so well.. “Saki” number was so beautifully sung by her though again the song has nothing.. she made it beautiful with her talent.. “Bhor bhaye” was another lame song given to her.. mind u, she again did a decent job with it.. she has distinct voice from Lata, but she manages all songs so well, therefore this one didn’t sound that bad.. “Dupatta Tera” song choice was shocking.. they didn’t get a decent song of kunal for Anwesha? hardly unbelievable!! she coul have given “Hum se yun milenge” from Ankahee.. that was soulful and I am sure Anwesha wud have won heart of all with that song.. but nah!! she is given a s**t song to sing.. just to project Aish.. this was clearly visible man.. till now I was denying it.. but alas I cud see this too..
anyway.. I felt furious watching this episode.. but was amazed to see the exuberance of Anwesha in such a tough situation.. she is a raw talent.. hoping to see her rise up as a bright star in our music industry.. I am sure we shall have a feast of beauties of songs from her in coming future..
By Anonymous on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
It’s true that Anwesha received very average kinds of songs to sing, whereas Aish had some great melodious, soulful songs that have a lot of scope. Despite this, Anwesha still did full justice to all the songs given. Her Gujrati number is still ringing in my ears. And I have to say that her ‘Bhor bhaye’ was just amazing! Very close to the original, in my opinion.
I had heard before, in a random forum, that she was going to sing ‘Kuhu kuhu bole koyalia’ for the Guru round, but for some reason wasn’t allowed to at the last minute.
By deven on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
I am sick of this regionalism shown in this show.. why the divide between gujrat and bengal is glorified like that? just to get stupid votes!!!.. and the thing showed in the show that gujrat is sooo great.. come on man, stop this nonsense.. if you can’t understand yourself than can’t u understand from a movie like “Chak De” that we are indian.. these guys are not bringing these two states together, but creating more divisions..
frankly speaking these shows is all in all “Dramabaazi” and making money from all resources.. only one thing was good in the whole show…. “Anwesha”..
By deven on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
really !!! ‘kuhu’ song would have been ideal for her.. she has got a range for that song.. This song was beautifully sung by “Poonam” and It would have been great experience to have compared the two renditions..
Problem is that we have used “amazing” word with Anwesha so much that it has become synonym with her.. But I found that her voice sounds more closer to “Asha”, “Kavita” and “Shreya”.. and not that closer to “Lata”.. but the way she sings every song sounds soo good.. I personally enjoy listening to all of her song.. just wished that she should get the best of soulful songs, so that even her hardest critic will know what she is capable of..
By gooboo123 on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
Hello guys,
I completely agree with you that this was the most boring episode of all.
I cannot believe that even at this level, people try and play with minds of 14 year olds……. It sucks man !!!
To give Anwesha the songs that she got……must be one of the worst thing that has happened on television in many many years.
And i am surprised that people like Shreya and kunal have continued to let this go past their notice. If they cannot support and encourage singers ……. They have no right to be judges.
But who will remember this next year…….. NO ONE !!!
It will be same judges, same Gajji directing this show……cause with all the hype and hoopla the show is more popular than sa re ga ma pa lil champs.
But I hope they realise that it is only because they have got singer like Anwesha and to a certain extent Aishwarya that they are minting money.
Next year i hope this show gets a lul from the singing part…… I hope they dont even get people half the talent….and no one watches this show again.
Thats my wish. I hope it turns true.
Sanjay
By VYAS DEVKISHIN on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
chandiani:
i have attended gajendraji’s saregama recordings at famous studios and film city. i used to get passes through post . i do not know gajendra singh personally but have talked with him on telephone on couple of ocassions. despite being one of the busiest persons in his line of activity, he is a gentleman to the core. very submissive and soft spoken.
all that lose talk about corruption etc. is meaningless unless you have concrete proof to substantiate the allegations.
i did not offer you a vip pass for the finals as you have commented in one of your posts. but the way you were repeatedly mentioning about betting etc on the final winner gave an impression that you are a gambler . you are probably right when you said that lot of betting is involved in this show.
this show has thrown up two equal talents in the final and i still believe it is difficult to name a clear winner.
in fact i was offered passes for vvip enclosure also but i do not fall in that category. had dr akbiswas or any of the bloggers on this site be here, particularly madam vandana from delhi i could have arranged for any number of free passes for them
anyway i wish you and your family all happiness and winnings in whatever you do in proper manner.
thanks.
By Muhammad Zubair, Karachi, Pakistan on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
As can be noticed, nearly all the people in this forum believe that Anwesha is the better of the two finalists. So, this should naturally be the trend for all the Indian public. However, quite amazingly, the voting situation is different and as per Chhote Ustaad program, Aishwarya is leading by huge margin over Anwesha.
Are “JINS AND BHOOTS” giving votes to Aishwarya?
By Anonymous on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
Yes, it was said that she was going to sing ‘kuhu kuhu’ and I was very excited about it. But needless to say, for whatever reason, it turned out that the entire round was dropped in favour of a Kunal Ganjawala dedication round!
But keep in mind that I’m not sure how reliable this source is and therefore I have no way of actually knowing whether she was really going to sing it or not…
Either way, after this show is over, I hope that some of her more diehard fans will ask a request for her to sing this song and put it up on youtube. That’d be great!
By Kamche on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
Anwesha, no matter you win this or not but you’re the winner. Remember your host (Abhas) he was not the winner either at one time but now he’s. You rock girl and you’re the best. Alas I am not in show/cinema biz to sign you. If I am not mistaken I see Lata jee’s voice in you.
By gooboo123 on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
There are people who have read my comments on the previous episode and commented about the sweet voice of Aishwarya and Anwesha.
To them, I am a big fan of Anwesha and I love what she does with her voice. If there is one singer in recent years that i have liked for variety of songs …. It has to be Anwesha. Previously I used to like Sunidhi Chauhan especially after Chameli…. for those scintillating numbers. But Anwesha is better and she will be far far superior to Sunidhi in a few years.
As far as Shreya goes ….. She is very good in slow and melodious numbers but i havent heard her sing high pitch numbers ……. I would like her to sing songs like “Mahi ve”, “Saki” …….. and if she has the guts …… she should sing song that Anwesha sung “O meri jaan”. And then i will rate her.
Yes i shouldnt be saying anything about Shreya Ghoshal since she has given us good numbers in the recent years and i am not even 1% as good as her. But this is no comparison……this is assessment of a talent of a 14 year old. And if singers like Shreya ghoshal cannot get it. Then i dont really understand it.
Anwesha…….. I will buy your albums anyday….
I just hope that some good music directors make you sing their songs. I hope and pray for you. Thats all i can do for you.
Sanjay
By gooboo123 on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
I guess I think most people who liked Anwesha have the same feeling of hopelessness. They can do nothing more but hope that she finds her path to victory (in life and whatever she aims for) and not get disheartened by this result.
We love you Anwesha.
Sanjay
By alia on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
hmm da episode..lol i dint find it xiting at all nd das sad 22 c da whle crwd in favour of aishwarya evn dough shez ma ffav. newy anwesha al d bst nn gd luk it desnt mater hu eva winz kk bibi..xox bles
By Tonima on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
Only shows the stupidity and immaturity of the Gujrati Audience compared to the Kolkata ones. They vote for Aishwariya not based on her singing ability but just because she is from Gujrat and fools like these are given the authority to choose the Chhote Ustaad.
Utter Crap!!
By 727 on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
That’s because Mr. Gajodhar (Gaj Mahashay) is an a…h…le. He is a CHEAPO.
By nilu on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
I am in UK and watching chotte ustad videos through this site. Gujrat has already proved that they are going to make everything for Aiswarya to win, although most music lovers in the country prefer Anwesha as the best. Anwesha is purely matured to sing all sort of music, have quality voice, great personality to be a celebrity, capability to entertain crowds in the music shows. Whereas I believe Aiswarya has sweet voice, but definitely lacking the other skills from Anwesha. Definitely Aiswarya will be matured in coming years, but as per current situation she is not the best to win chotte ustad . Nowadays we can see undeserved candidates are declared champion in these type of tv shows and this has already proved that people are loosing interests to watch these shows. As a proof we can see why Bengal is not voting. In previous episode Kolkata has shown that they are never biased and can support those who are really good. This is because Kolkata is a cultural city and Bengalis give value to the real culture, arts, music etc. Earlier Anwesha said in an interview, “Winning or loosing does not matter”, I also believe the same. She has great talent and even she loose, she has got enough support from most of the people except Gujrat, judges, media. I think she has great future. I wish her all the best to succeed in life.
By Ashish on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
Aishwarya has already won the battle
Nervousness of anwesha friends was right
Party time folks.
After 37 episodes Still Comparing
OOPS Keep it up
GUJARATAN CHALDI HAI CHALANGA MARDI
TUSSI HAAT MALLDE RAHO ANWESHA DE SATHIYO
By Tonima on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
what on earth are you talking about? speak a language that everyone can understand!!
By AG, Europe on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
Agree with you that behavior of crowd and judges seem to be very much biased. ANVESHA has that quality of Lata Mageshker, she will definitely WIN this contest no dobut, but more so the time will come when the world will drown in her hit songs as there is no challenge to her God gifted talent. God bless
By chandinani on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
Devkishinji,
Thanks a lot for your valuable comments and wishes. There are many bloggers on this site but I have seen that most of them are biased and are indulging in demeaning a particular contestant.
From my name you would have figured out that I am not from Gujarat, however it is unfortunate that some of the bloggers here who do not even know the spelling of Gujarat or Gujarati are making all kind of nasty comments about Gujarat and Gujarati people. What a shame..what a waste..
Devkishinji,
Yes I am involved in betting on this show as well as stock market etc in a big way. However, I believe that I am not a gambler but an investor and a businessman.
By italian stalian on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
va fanculo titti stronzi,,i want to say aishwarya and anvesha both are superb but aishwarya will win,,,and best of luck anvesha for the future,,
By italian stalian on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
u paki,,,shut ur mouth and stay in ur limit,,,,
By italian stalian on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
what u want from devikishan ji ?
By deven on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
yeah at a time we used to compare.. but after all this it looks like stupid to compare the two now.. cos it is crystal clear that Anwesha is much better than Aish.. There is no nervousness between us.. But despair about the system.. You can’t make people fool for a long time.. Show is biased and it is clearly visible there now.. “Gujaratan chal nahi rahi he, sagon dodai ja rahi he.. Jit len diyon usno eh title.. ki ho jawega.. log sunange ta Anwesha nu hi.. Sunde rehan gujrati apni gujratan nu.. who cares..”
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
From this show:
crowd’s behavior(specially adults) made Bipasha Basu (she is beautiful and tall5’8″, wellbuilt Bengali girl almsot like sushmita sen,5’10″) uncomfortable and she minced no words “let us talk in Bengali” was a direct slap>
comedy clip of ash and her father was really funny>shows father and daughter has a beautiful relationship.
The parents of these kids are wonderful.
This episode was a little better than delhi.
Rajasthan episode is my favorite.
By deven on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
Shreya has looks to become a good actress in Bollywood.. I suggest someone take her as an actress in a movie.. and and and.. important point is that all her songs in the movie should be given to Anwesha to sing.. so far I buy a music album just seeing the name of Shreya and she has not disappointed me so far.. for me, it is going to b Anwesha now..
By fairy on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
I have just finished watching the 4th April episode……
I wont dilly dally…I’ll come straight to the point……
This is an Aishwarya special…(like they do shreya special…etc) with Anwesha being used as a prop.
I go back to my blog after the Jaipur episode when they announced the next episode to be shot in Kolkata…..I had said that the choice of Ahmedabad as the venue for the penultimate episode itself was an extremely biased strategy…..now you see why it was done…..to play with peoples’ emotions….and garner maximum votes for Aishwarya….like striking when the iron is hot…I say this even though Aishwarya was leading by a minimal margin before this episode began…this is done so that Anwesha doesnt catch up at the last minute……
Looking at it objectively, its just another musical talent reality show…but it appears to be more a show of which family is more dramebaaz and which dad is more pally with the show organisers….every parent is emotional about his/her child…every mother is proud of her son/daughter….but to repetitively make use of these emotions for material gain ….that is utter cheap. Let me mention here that the margin between reality and drama is very subtle…its easy to play with peoples emotions coz not many can appreciate the difference and anybody with the slightest acting skills (all the more easier if it runs in the family)definitely stands to gain.Period.
Having said that I definitely uphold Aishwaryas talent…she has a fabulous voice no doubt….. I appreciate her parents’ sacrifice, her father’s talent, modern outlook……..BUT people voting (from recent trends in favour of Aishwarya) her over Anwesha for singing prowess……unbelievable! You dont need a degree in music to tell whos better….you need a ear for it!!!
I for one felt extremely sad seeing this episode….the onus has gradually shifted from “singing” to “stage show”….i dont want to comment more on it…………
Nevertheless, Anwesha outclassed her opponent in ALL the songs….despite the biased song selection…despite the extremely narrow-minded crowd…..despite it being an Aishwarya special!
Im more or less certain who is going to win this contest…..being judged by regionalism and favouritism….the trends of todays society…with able political leaders like Mr Modi sitting in top seats…what more can be expected?
I dont want to shift focus from singing…….so all you people watching these kids sing……the show is making one of them the voice of India…..but its the other voice of India whos making the show!!! No prizes for guessing who is which………..
Three cheers to good music and musicians…….
fairy
Anwesha outclassed her opponent
By fairy on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
I was going to write plz omit the subscript ..but ill now write plz use the subscript “Anwesha outclassed her opponent..” as the title of my blog.
Thank you
fairy
By deven on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
Hey, no offense to Gujrati people actually.. if I am doing that then I am wrong.. they are doing what a home crowd normally do, supporting their people.. we do in sports too.. this type of support is healthy, but one shall appreciate the talent of opposite contestant as well.. specially if he/she is so good.. that makes you great..
After giving a thought, I feel that it may not be the Gujrat crowd, but the way it is presented, is not good..
By Tonima on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
well said fairy!!
By deven on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
yeah.. but they have exaggerated a lot on that.. too much adulation was shown.. I feel they totally side tracked Anwesha here.. Just noticed the expression on judges face during all renditions.. They can’t hide appreciation for Anwesha.. and while Aish was performing, they were kind of feeling uncomfortable, but maintained their composure while giving rich comments.. I don’t think they were saying it through their heart.. if you still think that they did, then they must be good actors as well..
Haha, my comments must be sounding very biased now, since I was supporting both of them till now.. Reason for this is that I myself sense something wrong there by the pattern of things happened in last couple of shows.. Cos I have seen the effect of it wherein some of Anwesha’s supporters start calling her “Ghamandi”, overconfident and concentrating more on dancing kind of thing.. In the last two shows they were trying to showcase Aish as cute and better singer..
At a first go I liked Aish’s audio songs.. cos all of them were classical and soulful numbers.. but after giving a couple of listening to them, I could see huge flaws in her singing.. right rhythm seems to be missing at crucial point of those songs.. I guess many people have noticed that commented on it several times.. “O Sajna” is the only song which she has sung flawlessly..
Comparatively, Anwesha has sung all types of songs pretty well.. She excelled in the songs originally sung by Asha, kavita and shreya.. she was brilliant in performing songs of other singers as well that included Richa, Shubha mugdal etc.. Lata’s ardent fans won’t believe this but she has given full justice to Lata’s songs as well.. What more versatility do you expect from a singer?..
By deven on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
Man, excellent comment.. abs to the point..
By deven on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
Anybody watching live and is visiting net at the same time, please let us know how things are going in the show and who is the winner.. Like me, people who don’t have a connection here away from India, are excited to know the proceedings…
though it is of no point as we all know who will win.. but still, a hope is there that magic happens and so do the justice..
By Optimistic on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
The show is goind on. Too much focus on Aish, as always Anwesha is sidelined
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
Here some SIKHS have made some comments regarding kunal Gunjwala as “Racist” for he din’t mentioned sikhs “Guru granth”
he mentioned “har holy book me” then he said viz major religons book> sikhs are only 2 millions in India >only1.5% in the 1.2 billion Indians>prime minsiter of India has been Monmohan singh,Ministry of external affairs and 4 important positions in the center are sikhs.NOT EVEN BENGAL WITH THE STARS LIKE DR.BC ROY TO JOYTI BASU NOT A SINGLE PERSON HAS BEEN > FROM SOUTH, only NARASHIMA RAO.IF sikhs are making these comments after they made such a hullabaloo
for khalisthan(forgetting?? if India would not have accomdated sikhs in partition1947, i doubt there would have been any sikh left to-day.so please count the blessings you have received from india. BENGAL has produced most sicentists and stalwarts than any state could even think of >SHE WAS MARGINALISED>when Bengal was divided By Lord carzon it came as a boon to NEHRUJI & BAPUJI than a pleasure to JINNAH.EAST BENGAL got 144,000 sq.kilometer and west got 88,00sq. kilometer ,NEHRUJI SMILED ,he was busy with kashmir to flirt with Lady EDWINA Mountbatten THAN TO THE LEAST INTEREST FOR BENGAL>never objected>BENGAL’S land fertiltiy(arable land: 55.39%
https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/bg.html) highest in Indian subcontinent.IT’S NO WONDER THAT A STATE MADE THE MOST SCIENTISTS WHAT HAPPEND TO BENGAL ,STOPPED PRODUCING GOLDEN EGGS? YES, SHE WAS DECIMATED BY NEHRUJI AND BAPUJI AND HINDI-BELT CONSPIRACY>BENGAL GAVE THE MAXIMUM BLOOD.subhas chandra Bose,KHUDIRAM to TAGORE TO VIVEKANDA TO BOSE(BOSE & EINSTEIN), each as GIANTS CAME OUT OF THIS SOIL.STILL NOW MOST NOBEL PRIZEs WERE WON BY THIS STATE,BENGAL.In the early years of the 20th century, Gopal Krishna Gokhale remarked that what Bengal thinks today, India thinks tomorrow?.NOT AGAIN,BENGAL IS SPEAKING HINDI NOW,ALMOST BEHIND BIHAR> THANKS TO NEHRU JI >SONIA JI KI JAI***>HANUMANJI KI JAI**
By Amit on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
Abhas needs to stop making comments regarding region.
By Amit on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
Oh my god Anwesha has sung songs in previs episodes so beautifully – nimooda nimooda, so much liveliness , the best punches I have ever heard – like KK, or one can give, Dola re dola -Very difficult song to sing with no place for breathing. That is the caliber of this girl.
By rohail on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
HI this is rohail from bombay i like
Aishwarya song she is best singer
By deven on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
sir, this is not called for.. I believe every state has its own uniqueness and beauty.. we have such a diverse culture, but what can make us stronger is unity.. I strongly believe every culture has its own richness and beauty.. It is not only Bengal who is producing best people, but whole of our country.. I am sure everybody can give their own examples.. everybody has their own theories to tell.. that’s why outsiders play the mental game with the border states to create all this nonsense, so that they can indulge in disruption activities to the development of our country.. all invaders have utilized this strategy against us and unfortunately with our comments here, it seems that we are still very much vulnerable.. can’t we live together appreciating each other’s culture?.. mind you, a single separation of a state will result in distruction of our whole country.. whether it is kashmir, punjab, gorkhaland, tamil, bengal, maharashtra, gujrat, etc.. we are living a similar kind of life.. then why can’t we live in a unity?..
I guess we should stop this topic as it is not going to prove anything, but bring bad taste. It is just a reality show where on spur of moment, one judge miss out to say something.. we should not take care of what he said but believe what we are..
By rohail on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
I LIKE Aishwarya so keep voting for her please aishwarya is good singerrrrrrrr
By deven on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
which song do you like in particular?
By Optimistic on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
Voting for either of the girls is now out of question.
By Ronnie on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
Optimistic
Do you know how long the show is?
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
HANUMANJI KI JAI!!!!
HINDUSTAHN KI JAI!!!
SONIAJI KI JAI!!!
WHEN MORARJI DESAI, BECAME PRIME MINISTER,he prescribed to drink urine for indians and also for the world ,his secret of health.
even to-day, many are suggesting that!!
same song “MERE HO ” why was not given to ‘ANWESHA DIDI”,a 10yr old asked m ,”it’s not fair” ! He puffed.
I had to tell him SOME Indians are very smart because they drink urine every day,UNLIKE us ,we have to buy drinking water in USA.
he shrieked “yack”
By Optimistic on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
No More Masala. As already decided by organisers, Aish is the winner of Chote Ustaad
By Ronnie on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
Aish won.
By deven on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
Aish is the winner.. no pleasant surprises.. game is over.. turn of real life now.. enjoy guys
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
DO WE NEED TO DRINK URINE??MORARJI’S PRESCRIPTION.(INDIA HAS PRODUCED SOME CLASSIC MONKEYS)
TO JUDGE anything: whether two/many talents or students of any subject /any class /any exam :same questions ,same math,same time,same age group etc are given.SAME PARAMETERS WE use universally> India is such a country where a Monkey can do a better job than ITS system of bizarre CONCEPT>Some followers of Morarji desai are saying”please drink your urine before you can think straight!”
both these kids are talented!
BOTH SHOULD BE AWRDED..!no more drinking urine to increse your intellect for sangeet and wasting time!
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
DO WE DON’T NEED ANY ALBERT EINSTEIN TO PREDICT THE WINNER, A DELHI/BANARAS MONKEY COULD DO THAT LONG AGO!! JUST FOR A BANANA.
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
I STRONGLY BELIEVE WHAT I SAW IN INDIA :MAJORITY OF INDIANS FOLLOW MORARJI’S PRESCRIPTION OF HEALTH TO KNOW A SIMPLE FACT WHAT CAN BE READ BY A 3YR OLD.
By vivace on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
I am disappointed Anwesha didn’t win.. but think of it this way, she already will sing in Golmaal 2 and the 2nd place prize is also very immense. :] She will do well, no doubt!!
By vivace on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
On a side note, I think one of the joys of the show is listening to Abhas sing in different styles. Although he acts a bit silly, I enjoy listening to his performances.
And will the Chote Ustaad Contestants who didn’t make it perform in the final episode..?
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
HANUMANJI KI JAI>HNAUMANJI KI JAI>HANUMANJI KI JAI.
ALL YOU NEED IS A MONKEY AND A BANANA AND HE WILL DO A WONDERFUL JOB!
MAKE SURE YOU DRINK YOUR URINE!IT’S A MUST.(REF:HON.PERIMENISTER OF INDIA,SIR MORARJI DEASI.)
REST THE LANGUR WILL DO,YOU DON’T HAVE TO WORRY!
By parul on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
COngratulations!!!!I knew Aish would win. She is fantastic and definitely has a play back singer’s voice. Anwesha was equally good. I think both will do excellent in future with playback singing… Love your voice and my daughter who is 9 months old loves it too
parul
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
WHAT AN INTELLIGENT GUY!
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
TO GADJI:
WE EXPECTED BOTH FOR AWARDEE.
PUBLIC VOTING SHOULD BE ELIMINATED AND FAIR JUDGEMENT SHOULD BE GIVEN TO TALENT/TALENTS (MAY BE ANY INDIAN,RACE CREED,CASTE OR RELIGON )
IF YOU KEEP DOING IT >THERE COULD BE A CHANCE OF ONE FANATIC MAY SHOOT YOU!
THOUGH I KNOW MOST INDIANS ARE DOCILE.VERY GOOD BOYS.ONLY EATS DAL AND ROTI.MAKES NO NOISE.
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
WHY IS HE PAKI AND you are abusing him. WHY? he has expressed his opinion >he may be pakistani but he is a music lover.
you should BEHAVE YORUELF BEFORE you attck personally.WHAT IS YOUR LIMIT ,RUDE BOY!
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
for :italian stalian above remrks
don’t be saucy
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
Devkishinji ,
you are right in your review and comments and i am waitng for final episode video to see and your comments.lots of arguments in my family to-day.expected as usual.all are cooling down!we LOVE BOTH KIDS.
Normally,we never ever praise any child more than others.
thank you
By Vivek on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
The music industry owes a lot to Gajendra Singh for giving such talented people. Shreya Ghoshal, Kunal Ganjawala, Parthiv Goel(Saawariya – Yun Shabnami), Sonu Nigam (it was because of his compering he was more recognized) and now Anvesha and Aishwarya…both were equally good and talented but there has to be one winner…cant help it. If someone can pass this to him, it would be great.
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
shreya ghosal -yes
sonu nigam-yes
kunal Ganjwala-no.misfit .mediocre
parthiv goel-yes
here GADJI made mistake by not making these two deserving winners, for that he used so maany tactics ;if Nobel can be shared by two,grammy by two then what is chottey ustaad ? of india.
By waqar on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
Totally bullshit comments AISHWARIYA WAS THE BEST AND SHE WON VERY FAIRLY…ANWESHA WAS GOOD BUT NOT AS GOOD AS AISHWARIYA….THE JUDGES WERE NOT BIASED AT ALL. JUST GET THE NEGATIVITY OUT OF YOUR MIND.
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
for deven :That is when taildrops and Homosapiens become homoerectus and more civlized!!a million years!
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 5, 2008 | Reply
DO YOU THINK INDIANS NEED TO DRINK MORE URINE??HON.MORARJI DESAI’S (EX-PRIME MINISTER OF INDIA)PRESCRIPTION
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 6, 2008 | Reply
Thanks to PRITAM CHAKRABORTY, THE JUDGE ,
FOR STICKING TO YOUR PRINCIPLE :THIS AWARD SHUOLD BE GIVEN TO BOTH.
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 6, 2008 | Reply
STOP THIS GANDHIAN POLICY .DON’T BULLSHIT MAN. TALK SOME SNSE OTHERWISE SHUT YOUR MOUTH :
IS BENGAL EQUAL TO THE REST OF INDIA? .WHERE IS YOUR EVIDENCE ??STOP THIS IDOTIC VERSION ,INDIAN.BENGAL IS BENGAL NOT ANY VEGI OR IDOTIC STUPID INDIAN.
By Saiful Islam on Apr 6, 2008 | Reply
We are fully agreed with Mr. Deven. It was clear from last 3/4 episode that Chotte Ustaad autority are given preference to Aisharya. But we think Anvesha already make her place in film industry both in bamgla and Mumbai. We pray for her and hope that she will be a super star like Shreya and Aloka.
Saif, Mohi, Najmul, Mizan, zubaer
Riyadh
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 6, 2008 | Reply
GADJI, NEED TO STOP THIS SHOW BEACUSE YOU ARE PROMOTING INJUSTICE.
I WISH SOMEBODY SHOULD SHOOT THIS BUSTARD.
HE USED HIS DIRTY TACTICS TO ABUSE AND THEN GAVE AWRAD TO A SINGLE PERSON.
HOW MUCH NEEDED FOR A GUNMAN IN INDA?
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 6, 2008 | Reply
BENGAL;: YOU SHOUD NOT SLEEP WITH THIS INJUSTICE>SHOOT THIS BUSTARD ,GAJJI.HE IS THE CULPRIT.EVEN PRITAM TOLD HIM TO AWARD THIS TO BOTH.>>THIS THICK HEADED MAN NEED SOME BULLETS IN HIS BRAIN.
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 6, 2008 | Reply
BENGAL NEEDS TO BE SEPARATED FROM THIS STUPID HINDI BELT.
By deven on Apr 6, 2008 | Reply
I am sure you must be a mental patient.. just review your comments, you can make it out.. ohh, but how can you do that when you are..
if you have a little bit of sense left, look at what all garbage you are writing here.. anyway who cares for your nonsense theories.. and stop using somebody else’s identity.. ok !!!
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 6, 2008 | Reply
Mr.Vivek,
Gajji is making money from this chotte ustaad. he has his vested interest. He is not making it free and he is not a GOD HEAD,AVATAR,LORD KRISHNA.
this man knows the trade very well .he is not a musican.he is a businessman ,a promoter with high school education.
He is good in his business but he is unethical.
By skylark on Apr 6, 2008 | Reply
Dr.Biswas,
you are 200% correct.west bengal should separate out of india (hindi belt) and join the east Bengal and become one Bengal. These Non-bengali are anti Bengali and keep their grudges as they can’t compete at intellectual level.
Bengal is marginalised in everyway :yur satement is so true.
Budha dev Bhattacharya should stop co-operation with the center and we need our industrialisation separate.
By skylark on Apr 6, 2008 | Reply
devenji,
aap history vi jante nehi,ijjath vi nehi hain>aap log hai kia? 200 saal kutta ki tera angrej ko chamcha kye hain,aaj vi chamchagiri kartye rahe .
By suman on Apr 6, 2008 | Reply
Dr.Biswas,
Gujrat episode reveals the true picture of india.
The people who are logging here as Mr.deven or fairy and others are just acting stupid because they understand now that there is no room for argument.they realised that Gujrat is a true picture of whole of India.
Majority of these people do not have any knowlegede of India and its history.so they don’t like to hear the truth.
Bengal was deliberately marginalised by MR.JAWAHARLAL NEHRU> his intention was to divert the center of administration of india OUT OF BENGAL and Bengali hands.even in 1947,Bengal had the highest educated bengali than WHOLE OF INDIA.once Mr. shamaprasad Mukherjee,son of SIR ASUTOSH MUKEHRJEE was killed in kashmir jail on FAKE CHARGE. Indira Gandhu did the same in emergency!! a man like Vajpayee(the most honest and rsepected person of Indian politics) was sent to jail.he was sure the DELHI MASNAD will remain HIS AND HIS NEHRU FAMILY.thank GOD, RAJIV GNADHI WAS KILLED AND HOPE FULLY RAHUL GANDHI will BE ELIMNATED> so that delhi Masnad will be free from NEHRU FAMILY.
thnaks for revealing the truth.
By John on Apr 6, 2008 | Reply
@ akbiswas
you are like a mad dog, barking and biting all over. Hope you know the treatment for such creatures?
By suman on Apr 6, 2008 | Reply
apologise for typos
By suman on Apr 6, 2008 | Reply
congress party.stupid ,uneducated sonia Gandhi and his son rahul gandhi should never step foot in Bengal.Bengal need to open borders with Bangladesh and make more flow of trade and commerce along with cultural acivity.center should be marginalised and Non-bengali in west bengal should not be given any land acquisiton. BENGAL SHOULD BE FOR BENGALI FIRST >NOT A CLIENT STATE TO CENTER.
Thanks again for your insight.
By suman on Apr 6, 2008 | Reply
I can understand Dr.Biswas because Gujrat episode was the last farce in this Gajji drama. i read all his comments>he always recommended anwesha+ aiswarya = award.
it was told by pritam ,the judge ,Mr.bacchan himself admitted in grand finale but still the award was given to aisywaria.it was TOTALLY UNFAIR.
DR.Biswas is a just person and he speaks unequivocally,may be his style is very forceful but it’s the truth: gujrat episode has revealed clearly the true picture of india.THE VERY NAKED TRUTH.
By deven on Apr 6, 2008 | Reply
haha.. why don’t you guys go in some other bengali forum and discuss your vows?.. this forum is to discuss performances of Anwesha and Aish.. I am a big fan of Anwesha, not because of her being a bengali, ok.. and so do others..
as for history goes, we punjabi were always the first who faced/blocked the invaders.. deven is my real name and I don’t believe in fake identities.. if you think talking about unity is chamchagiri then it is a stupid thought.. why don’t you guys understand that by dividing all of these states, we won’t exist at all !!! my point is just that.. and I am not challenging anybodies capabilities.. I myself don’t believe in Gandhi’s policy.. but I am afraid that the way every region is asking about their autonomy, it is not long that we may not exists at all..
Luckily I have two very close friends: one bengali and one gujrati.. when I told all this, they also says that this is all non sense
By Dr.akbiswas.USA. on Apr 6, 2008 | Reply
prakriti ,with honesty and decency have left a mark on every person to adore her.when she left,she smiled and melted away with that dignity.
when she got the highest public votes,she said” i don’t deserve it”
even when she was humilated, she wept with dignity, admitted that she sang flat with dignity.
can other Indians learn from this little girl,what is decency and honesty?
Indians seems to have become the most corrupt nation on earth!! MOST INDIANS ARE UNTRUHFUL AND CORRUPT AND WON’T ACCEPT IT!
By Dr.akbiswas.USA. on Apr 6, 2008 | Reply
thank you,suman.
By Dr.akbiswas.USA. on Apr 6, 2008 | Reply
rani Mukerhjee>when asked by abhaas,a bengali girl couldn’t find a bengali bhajan or bengali song >she sang “rosgolla” ,a street slang: is a SAD PHASE,an arist >rabindra nath,dijendra lal,nazrul,atul prasad,and million others .a vast ocean of songs, poetry.
SAME WITH SHREYA
SHAAN(SHANTANU MUKHERJEE):can’t find bengali to express.asked by abhijit >he stammered in few words.
why india doens’t change “jana mano” to hindi >making their own hindi lyrics.stolen everything >what is left.
By Dr.akbiswas.USA. on Apr 7, 2008 | Reply
can you imagine an italian,highschool graduate became a congress president in a country of 1.2 billion people with no political experience or education? indians accepted her with NATAMASTAK.
how smart are these indians? jackass,indeed.
By Dr.akbiswas.USA. on Apr 7, 2008 | Reply
@Md.zubair
pritam has unequivocally told in grandfinale and also before :technically anwesha and aiswyaria are equal and the award should be shared by two NOT One.
so he abstained and he told this to guest in chief “Mr.Bacchan”
you are absolutely right.
Thanks
By Dr.akbiswas.USA. on Apr 7, 2008 | Reply
yes
By Dr.akbiswas.USA. on Apr 7, 2008 | Reply
i really didn’t know that pakistanis also know>Jin and bhoot> AMAZING!
By human & humanity on Apr 7, 2008 | Reply
What kind of language is this? I feel sorry for you and your thinking. You must have a very bad childhood. sounds like if you were not brought up with good moral values. People like you are the ones who spread hatred among people. You should never be given an access to the internet. Take care of yourself. I think you need it in your life. By the way, grow up!
By human & humanity on Apr 7, 2008 | Reply
great music talent show. Everyone enjoys it and some of you with such a narrowmindedness and close minds can pass beyond certain levels and keep bringing in racism in. can you just cheer up for god sake. Learn to enjoy life a bit
By john on Apr 7, 2008 | Reply
Suman no matter what you say openly advocating shooting someone is mad behaviour – this is what nazzis/fundamentalists do when things dont go their way. We sane law abiding citizens behave differently for example peaceful demonstration. What is this guy Biswas doing apart from vomiting all over this place. If he feels so strongly why doesnt he carry out a demonstration..
Well in any case this guy, Biswas, sounds like a new born HITLER from bengal. Mr Biswas it might do you some good to read European history. And by the way rabindra sangeet is rather a drag musically – it may have great lyrics but no musical merit whatsover. So please shut up…
By Dr.akbiswas.USA. on Apr 7, 2008 | Reply
FOR JOHN,THE MORON:JOHN,THE INDIAN
SUMAN & ALL INDIAN
PLEASE then ask this moron WHO says “rabindra sangeet is a drag” then how two countires bangldeash and INDIA chose “Jono Gono Mono Adhinaayako….. RoBinDro Songeet ” and “sonar bangla” both countires NATIONAL ANTHEM>
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aUa3JG7loi8&watch_response
BOTH THE SONGS ARE RABINDRA SANGEET AND ALL RABINDRA SANGEET BASED ON RAGAS.
JOHN,MUST BE AN CHRISTAN IDIOT WHO HAS NO CLUE WHAT IS RABINDRA SANGEET.”GITANJALI” FOR WHICH TAGORE GOT THE FIRST NOBEL IN ASIA.
WHERE :THIS JOHN, THE ORANGUTAN COMES FROM?”
“THE MORE MOKEY CLIMBS UP ,THE MORE IT EXPOSES ITSELF”
By Dr.akbiswas.USA. on Apr 7, 2008 | Reply
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6VbvxIFUbWo&feature=related
By Saiful Islam on Apr 7, 2008 | Reply
I think Bhut Nath gave the votes to Ash. But Anwesha is the best.
By Dr.akbiswas.USA. on Apr 7, 2008 | Reply
IN WHAT PATHETIC STAGE IS INDIA TODAY,BEYOND MY IMAGINATION,SEEING THIS JOHN.***
I HAVE NO WORDS TO EXPRESS!!!
By neha on Apr 7, 2008 | Reply
hi aap sahi keh rahe yeh preplanned tha ki aishwariya ko jeetana hai isme koi sak nahin hai
aur hamari anwesha toh uska future hi nahin uska present bhi bahut bright hai
By neha on Apr 7, 2008 | Reply
I M AGREE TO YOU EAST OR WEST ANWESHA IS THE BEST
By suman on Apr 7, 2008 | Reply
john:
1.people express their anger in different ways some uses foul language ,some uses ‘go to hell” and all different ways>Dr.Biswas ‘s expression of anger ‘shoot ‘ is not literal sense but you are calling him as hitler is stupid
2.rabindrasangeet :you donot know >majority of indians don’t know> doesn’t matter>you don’t comment.(i doubt you are Indian,anyway)
To each is his own>”some” hindi film music is cheap and peppy and people consider it as trash.
3.shut your mouth: shows you are uncivilized person
i doubt we have to read any european history to be civilized.
By suman on Apr 7, 2008 | Reply
Dr.biswas,
please don’t waste your time here.
don’t take the ignorance as insult personally>that’s india to-day.
nothing you can do. sad indeed.
By suman on Apr 7, 2008 | Reply
Bengali children who are born out of state do not learn bengali (except speaking,many can’t even read)as a result there is no difference between a bengali living in delhi or bombay and a NON- BENGALI living in bengal,both can’t read it>both donot know BENGALI literature AS a result they know “hindi & english” .
RABINDRA NATH,SARAT OR BANKIM are only the names but never ever have read the literature and as a result they have NO CLUE.rich BENGALI literature and sangeet never touch their heart.
HINDI CULTURE AND BOLLYWOOD WITH ITS CHEAP ENTERTAINMENT AND GOVERNMENT’s EFFORT TO DESTROY THE CULTURE HAS TAKEN ITS TOLL.THE BENGALI LIVING OUT OF STATE HAVE BECOME NON-BENGALI IN REAL SENSE.EVEN IN STATE>FEW CHILDREN read Bengali literature.
THIS IS REALITY OF INDIA.it’s a shock to you but that is reality.AS A RESULT> VAST ocean of knowledge remain elusive. LANGUAGE IS THE KEY TO CULTURE>WHEN THE KEY IS LOST ,CULTURE IS LOST>so Rani Mukherjee can’t find a bengali bhajan and bengali song where Rabindra sangeet alone is 85000.
evrymood,every occasions and every ragas to folk(baul) to western >you name it>rest aside nazrul,Drijendralal,atul prasad and million others.
THIS IS INDIA TO-DAY.(I am writing this for you as a BENGALI,living abroad ,your expectation is very high and that has made you angry. whereas i am as a Bengali living here in calcutta but travelling to other states of India and abroad, both uk & usa,has made me realised that)
By suman on Apr 7, 2008 | Reply
Tagore lived 80yrs>longest among all talents >his pen never stopped from 5yrs
“kije ora pachhey khete orai seta janey,chagal bolye bechye achye praney.”
By John on Apr 7, 2008 | Reply
Suman,
1) it is preposterous to assume that anyone with the name JOHN is not Indian. This is just another reflection of irrationality of you guys – especially mr Biswas. I am sure not many christians in india will be pleased by your commment.
2) i am well trained in indian classical music – in dhrupad dagarbani style. My comment on rabindra sangeet still stands. Sorry if it hurts your ‘bengali nationalism’. I am no advocate of bollywood music (another assumption on your part).
3) My analogy to hitler still stands. But you wound not understand it if you havent studied world war two. People often think they should only confine to studying their local history. Any history is GLOBAL..you will only become wiser by studying it.
4) Just like BJP and other fundamentalist parties thrive on religious agenda but are light years away from what religion is, so are many of you bengali’s who thrive on praising great figures from bengal are light years away from what these figures have actually stood for. If Mr Biswas even had an inkling of Rabindranath or Sri Aurobindo’s preachings he will never behave in such an OBSCENCE way on the net.
5) it is deplorable the way you guys critisise INDIANS and praise BENGALIS. You must have a really low self esteem. I can only feel sorry for you.
Enough said – i am not going to waste any more space on net. Reflect on it or throw it away in a dustbin. your choice.
By John on Apr 7, 2008 | Reply
@suman
one questions for you :
What is uncivilised about asking someone to shut up, someone who is openly attributing motifs, calling names, advocating shooting/killing/violence (e.g. “people of bengal go and shoot ..”)? How can you even support such a person – I am only asking this to you as I have a feeling that you are a sane person
By Dr.akbiswas.USA on Apr 7, 2008 | Reply
suman:
1)please ask west Bengal govt. to totally eradicate the congress from west bengal.
(how a stupid italian sonia with highschool education became a CONGRESS PRESIDENT in a country of 1.2 billion people with no political experience or education? -is a shame for all indians: christian chapter of portugese to india of past and present italian are all shameful and corrupt)
2)BAN Mr.gajji to use west bengal for his puppy show of gujrat.
3)stayjit ray didn’t go to bollywood to get his oscar and world recognition
4)center govt.should lay off dirty hand of viswabharati, its not to make it hindiwallah’s dabbah.
5)KICK OFF UPA GOVT. TO COLLAPSE.
6)KICK OFF WHERE BENGAL’S INTERST IS MARGINALISED.
BENGAL GIVES MAX.REVENUE AND SHE NEEDS TO TAKE CARE OF HER OWN PEOPLE FIRST.
The sign of dooms are already there as you see illiterate people are jigging and glorifying a simple event like “chotte ustad” shamelessly and heard what is the position of judges made nonfunctional.
i remember when sheik Muzibar rehman’s last speech against the west pakistani of punjabi regime”amader sangram mukitr sangram”.Today,west bengal is in the same stage .as calcutta was capital for 200yrs NOT DELHI, nehruji was determined to marginalise BENGAL from day one. The next regime followed the SAME formula ..till present day sonia gandhi.JUST IMAGINE HOW MANY HIGHLY EDUCATED PEOPLE HAVE BEEN MADE ‘ULLUCK’ AND SHE TOOK OVER!!!SHOCKING!
By Dr.akbiswas.USA on Apr 7, 2008 | Reply
IF I WERE IN WEST BENGAL,INDIA ,I COULD FIX THIS GAJJI IN ONE DAY!
By Dr.akbiswas.USA on Apr 8, 2008 | Reply
its not what Gajji awarded anwesha or aiswyaria >IT’S THE TRICKS OF PUBLIC VOTING>CONSTANT SHIFTING GEAR OF HIS PRINCPLES>IT’S THE CUNNING WAYS HE APPLIED ,PSYCHOLOGICAL PAINS TO THESE CHILDREN AND THEIR PARENTS HE USED AND YET DECEIVED THE IMAGE OF PUBLIC PERCEPTION AS AVATAR.
YES> ITS’ THE MASTER CRAFTER >IT’S THE SAME DECEPTION AND INJUSTICE,I HATE.
By Dr.akbiswas.USA on Apr 8, 2008 | Reply
i forgot SONIA GANDHI was given OFFER to become PRIME MINISTER OF INDIA***>DRINKING URINE OF MORARJI DESAI IS WORKING FOR INDIA!!!CLASSIC JACKASS STATE**
By suman on Apr 9, 2008 | Reply
MR.JOHN,
Let me answer to your questions:(1-5)
1. Christanity came to India by Portuguese mainly>it was a forced conversion of lower caste Hindus> a shameful chapter of Indian history. Shameful because it was the biggest traitors for India who supported the colonial master and in the history of freedom struggle of India their participation was with the master. That’s why when Independence was imminent, large mass of Christians migrated to Australia and newzeland.Here in park street area, a large portion was Christian community, they disappeared overnight in Calcutta. Goa, Daman and Duke, were freed by Indian soldiers after India got her independence.
Role of Christianity in slave trade of was notorious. When white master was brutally flogged the slaves, the Christian fathers brain washed the NEGROS to remain submissive. CHRISTIANITY PLAYED THAT DOUBLE STANDARD ROLE CLEVERLY. EVEN IN USA,FATHERS ENGAGED IN SODOMIZING LITTLE CHILDREN,COULDN’T BE PROSECUTED; ultimately the US SUPREME COURT had to take action against the VATICAN to prosecute them and put them behind bar. Indian chapter will not be any different, only Indian court system has no such power (ARE YOU KIDDING! SONIAJI, an Italian Christian is our congress president). So what is Christianity in India is anybody’s guess.
2. Rabidbra nath Tagore, a Nobel laureate was an international figure, not BENGALI, not Indian, not Asian, WORLD FIGURE. VISWA BHARATI, first international open university for the world.
INDIA (GOVT. OF INDIA, not west Bengal govt) took charge for shantiniketan for basking in that Tagore’s image. Originally, shantiniketan land and property was bought by prince Dwarka nath thakur.Tagore made the institution with his Nobel Prize money (NOT FROM GOVT. OF INDIA).
His sangeet, his vast works of literature is not for Bengali, Indian or Asian, it’s for world. Whether a man john, dhrupad singer from KERALA evaluates his sangeet lyrics or melody is a laughing joke!! To-day works of Tagore has been translated to 36 countries and included in most us universities curriculum of literature.
Language is a key to culture, how a keralite who doesn’t know Bengali would understand the lyrics? Insane???
3. Whether I need to study world world2, European history to become pundit like you? – the answer is no.
4. Religion’s light year away: religion and ignorance are synonymous in India, where humanity is neglected: “bhagwan ko dud khilao” is a joke. Religion has caused more ignorance, darkness, and divisions and still remains the main cause of superstitions and backwardness. political parties take the cover of religions to get vote bank –all of them do that not BJP ALONE.
5. What’s India to-day is a reality, criticism is a part of self –consciousness and only people with self esteem can do that. To us Bengali, we inherit such a vast legacy of talents that ignorance is NOT bliss to us.SO INTROSPECTION & SELF ASSESSMENT IS A PART OF OUR DAILY CONSCIUOSNESS.
Thna
By suman on Apr 9, 2008 | Reply
Thanks
By suman on Apr 9, 2008 | Reply
apologise some typos: Rabindra nath ,…
By Rafay Mahmood on Apr 9, 2008 | Reply
I think Anvesha is much better than Aishwarya because Anvesha is versatile singer in Surs she has very large scale to sing every kind of song. you can observe this in her last performance on 5-April-08 when she sung “Ami Je Tomar”
By Dr.akbiswas.USA on Apr 9, 2008 | Reply
THIS IS INDIA TO-DAY
Indians are the biggest hypocrite on earth.
He learns to speak in bifurcated tongue,like a serpent.on one tongue he admits that both are eually talented, on another he declares his single winner.Hindu superstitions damages the logic and consciousness of mental faculty.he becomes the prisoner of his own prison of obscurantist ideology.obsessive and compulsive behavior becomes his daily practice and logic goes far from his brain.This Musical event is a classic example.if both kids were awarded,what harm would have happened ? Nothing but two children would have been given the justice and recognition for their talents & hard work.
stone statues get more milk than hungry children on the street and vivekanada’s message becomes a portrait of creating fake image.THIS IS INDIA TO-DAY.
By deven on Apr 10, 2008 | Reply
Excellent comment.. Specially, the one about statues and hungry children.. superstitions.. I’ll add –> I HATE all those who kills their daughters in womb itself.. people who throw garbage everywhere: street, buses, trains.. managers, who think people working under him/her are slaves (no work etiquette, ethics).. regionalism.. and so many other things like that..
I boil just thinking about them.. India has potential to become the top country in the world, that’s it.. cos they will not going to become one in next hundred years if these things still persist.. which will, cos nothing seems to be improving.. only that we are gaining more garbage from western world instead of gaining their good points..
I feel so happy seeing these highly talented kids perform, but then feel sad due to the way people are playing with their emotions through elimination rounds, dramabaazi and using these kids talent to earn huge money..
By Dr.akbiswas.USA on Apr 10, 2008 | Reply
Thanks for your true understanding of Humanity..and the old corrupt system that drastically needs to change!!
By Dr.akbiswas.USA on Apr 10, 2008 | Reply
The whole teaching of Bhagavad Gita is to FIGHT AGAINST INJUSTICE.krishna was asking ARJUN to fight. Arjun said “krishna,my friend,i don’t want to fight against my own relatives and cousins . i prefer to surrender.” krishna COMPELLED HIM TO FIGHT.That’s the essence of Bhagavad gita.
http://www.thoughtware.tv/videos/show/1578
Robert openheimer ,was the chief scientist and director of LOS ALAMOS NUCLEAR CENTER,CA,USA.
Albert Einstein: When I read the Bhagavad-Gita and reflect about how God created this universe everything else seems so superfluous.
I have asked many scientists here in UC BERKELEY AND OTHER CAMPUSES,WHY they read this book? ANSWER:”inspiration to do the just and fight agianst unjust.”
By Dr.akbiswas.USA on Apr 10, 2008 | Reply
This book is not religion,it’s a philosophy>
http://www.bhagavad-gita.us/articles/662/1/Famous-Reflections-on-the-Bhagavad-Gita/
By Dr.akbiswas.USA on Apr 10, 2008 | Reply
The Mahabharata has all the essential ingredients necessary to evolve and protect humanity and that within it the Bhagavad-Gita is the epitome of the Mahabharata
By Dr.akbiswas.USA on Apr 10, 2008 | Reply
I WOULD AGAIN REQUEST PEOPLE TO TAKE THIS RASCAL,GAJIJI TO JUSTICE.THIS CRAFTY MAN MUST BE PUNISHED.
By john on Apr 10, 2008 | Reply
Suman, Your comment about christinaty really sent a chill through my spine – how pathetic really to use such arguments. Should i hate all germans because some of them killed jews. OR should we start hating all hindus because they burnt sikhs…OR should we hate all americans because they bombed japan. You dont use history to hate people – you use history to learn what to and what not to – and hatred is ceratinly in the list of what not to! YOu use history to develop compassion.
Another sign of irrationality – First i was european, now i am keralite (with obvious contempt of course!! ), and you make second assumption based on your first assumption that keralites can’t learn dhrupad). I wonder what do i become next time? ok let me unleash the truth – i am originally a delhite nd although kerala has always been on at the top of my list as places to visit, i unfortunately have not yet had the opportunity:). LOL.
Its interesting you guys make assumptions and then another set of assumptions based on those assumptions and then begin arguing wtih a sword in your hand. So Ms Suman let me teach you one important lesson. Assumptions are made to test hypothesis – they cannot be used as arguments. You obviously did not study science in high school/college ???
Finally cant you read. I am talking about music and not literature…so your entire retort on rabindra sangeet is not relevant to this discussion..
WELL RELISH IN YOUR BENGALI GHETTO…and your superloop of assumptions. May God bless you.
By Dr.akbiswas,USA. on Apr 10, 2008 | Reply
The whole of grand finale,i never saw Mr.gajji on stage.i would request,any body could please upload a picture of Mr.gajji >
thanks in advance.
By Dr.akbiswas,USA. on Apr 11, 2008 | Reply
Question: why are you writing bad about gajji on the blog site?
In grand finale ANWESHA SANG “ami je tomar”,IT OBVIOUSLY EMBARASSED MS.JUHI CHOWLA SO SHE BECAME NERVOUS TO ANOUNCE THE NAME AND TURNED TO ANWESHA “BOTH OF YOU SHOULD HAVE THIS AWARD”
THIS DID MADE AMITAV BACCHAN PAUSED IN AWE THEN HE RESUMED HIS TACTICS LIKE OLD POLITICIAN AND ANOUNCED”MY BAHU”
SILENCE AND GRACE CAME OVER ANWESHA SHE TURNED HER GAZE DOWNWARD AND ACCEPTED THE DEFEAT.HER EXCELLENCE AND SILENCE SPAT AND SMACKED THE DIRECTOR’S FACE ,IF HE HAS ANY BREED AND SHAME.OBVIOUSLY GAJJI REMAINED UNSEEN FOR SEVERAL REASONS BUT ONE REASON FOR SHAME IN PUBLIC APPEARENCE!
By Dr.akbiswas,USA. on Apr 11, 2008 | Reply
I would request people to spit on this GAJJI and his image, picture.a coward ,unkuth and shameless creature who has no decency and breed.
i am sure this webmaster must be carrying some message to his master. if born as swine,then it’s hard that spit and mud could disgrace him! he should read these comments and realize how much public hate him!
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 12, 2008 | Reply
sri ramkrishna used to say “maan ar hunsh nye manush” means maan + hunsh = manush (man)
here people has no self-esteem(maan) or consciousness(hunsh).every day in India, so many social injustice take place through ignorance and superstition but people don’t mind it.They never protest or try to rectify it.
the man who commits injustice and who tolerates that injustice are equally guilty.
This musical event was a shere injustice but i don’t hear any protest> so many people were there in the grand finale remained silent like herd of goats.The whole audience , heard twice from PRITAM THAT BOTH SHOULD BE AWARDED BUT REMAINED SILENT. IS IT VEGETARIAN MEALS MAKE THEM LIKE THAT OR WHAT? NO TESTOSTERONE,EFFEMINATE LIKE AN EEL.
NOT A SINGLE “AWAZ” WAS HEARD !!!
NOTHING,SHAMEFUL AND INEPT >GOD HELP THESE MENTAL RETARDATION,PLEASE! I AM STILL IN A SHOCK FROM A FAR LAND!
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 12, 2008 | Reply
sheer(typo)
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 12, 2008 | Reply
i feel, had it been in calcutta,people would have stopped the program and made a big uproar.
By XXX on Apr 16, 2008 | Reply
Anwesha u r d true winner.
@ Moderator of dis blog
Please block ppl like Dr.akbiswas.
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 17, 2008 | Reply
if i were present in such event,your big B and gaji will go under cover and flee
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 17, 2008 | Reply
Both anwesha and aiswyaria are equally talented and both of them should have got the award.
aiswyaria is a beautiful child,she is well mannered and has all the social grace as anwesha but what is magical about this child is her stagefree appearence and oratory quality.i think she has acquaired that ability so great that she uses her diction and gesture like a professional orator on stage(being exposed to stage at an early age).even in distress she has learned to control her emotions fully:one has to admire that.14yrs has comforted her parents and colleagues equally: leadership quality.
judges were either stammering,verbose or at a loss for word.kunal is totally immatured and a headless chicken.he can crow at anytime as dawn.pritam is still a humanist.shreya is a cold feet and nervous lady but she is kind and shy.
anchor is a hyperactive child.sometimes ok sometimes has attention seeking behavior.
guest judges: abhijit is a 3yr brain in an adult body.rest are simple & ordinary.
audience:calcutta audience respectable and hospitable to guest.Gujrat is hostile and uncivilized.Bhopal is uneducated and imbecile.rajasthan is warm and enjoyable.
gaji:unfortunate man who needs counselling for direction
Big B:self grandiose idot who thinks that he is a shahensha to poor(500m)indians who go to hindi cinema with 2 weeks salary without food.he is nothing to international level or Bengal level.
he has not achieved neither european,russian or american level any such award to satyajit ray for berlin,french & oscar or saumitra & suchitra with moscow and berlin awards.
He also tried his luck first with nehru family,then politics>then he has bagged two ladies first jaya, a bengali star and aiswyaria,a marathi star as bahu for his ugly and imbecile son who has no star quality.
By deven on Apr 17, 2008 | Reply
I just want to comment on one thing.. Vegie diet is much more healthier than non-veg diet in all means.. There is a lot written about cons of Animal Protein and I just don’t want to start discussing that (cos lots of detail is available on net on this).. My point is that if someone has capability to bravely stand up for truth, then it is not becos of a diet.. I am non-vegetarian but I stand by with vegetarians..
When there is a competition, there has to be one winner.. a tie doesn’t mean anything.. 2 lakh vote is huge difference to clearly make one person winner.. pritam’s point does not make any sense.. who cares about him.. he is a big copy cat, who can’t create one single tune by himself..
we shall accept the result gracefully.. I am a big fan of anwesha and I also felt very bad.. but that is fine.. as per me, she is still the best.. she has got all the limelight she deserves which will ensure her bright future.. she doesn’t seem to be that upset like us, so then why making it a big deal?
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 17, 2008 | Reply
is this award for voting or for talent ?
if it’s for talent both are equal and both should be awardee.i hate hypocrisy.
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 17, 2008 | Reply
answer to vegie diet for indians:
1.the way indians COOK & EAT their vegie,the vegie are OVERCOOKED,SPICED &OILY,IT’S NUTRITIONAL VALUE IS ZERO OR MINUS.i saw with my own eyes during my visit in india.
stunted growth and malnutrition is rampant by WHO,UNDP,UNESCO REPORT.
http://web.worldbank.org/WBSITE/EXTERNAL/COUNTRIES/SOUTHASIAEXT/0,,contentMDK:20916955~pagePK:146736~piPK:146830~theSitePK:223547,00.html
SINCE YOU ARE A WEB PUNDIT AND ARGUE WITH EVERYTHING>READ IT ATLEAST ONE.
MOST INDIANS ARE IGNORANTS AND IGNORANCE IS A BLISS IN INDIA.all they can argue foolishly.
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 17, 2008 | Reply
The above comments are for web pundit,Mr.deven.
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 17, 2008 | Reply
Majority of indians, very few have reading habits and claim knowledge> very few houses i visited, ALL middleclass has any library or books at home>displayed electronics tvs,jewellery and car>unhealthy life style and fat like pigs .
yet they all claim to be pundit,knowldgeable and highly talented.The best examples are the delhi doctors and IMC(indian medical council).3000 fake doctors without licence practice in delhi>the most council admn members of the IMC are ignorant doctors who neither want to accept the responsiblity ,even after 60yrs,it’s function is abysmally low and unacceptable ,occupied by ignorant brains who don’t want any change..THIS IS THE CONDITION of intelligentsia no wonder British medical council has withdrawn its recognition.
By deven on Apr 17, 2008 | Reply
Thanks sir for your comments.. I had some healthy discussion with you before and I respect you as you are my elder.. We learn and practice to respect our elders (I can say that becos I am an INDIAN).. I have no intention to argue with you or anybody here.. See my comments, I was never harsh with anyone.. I also took your sarcastic comment of me as web pundit lightly..
I live in US for quite some time, but I still love to be connected to my country, with all its problem.. Instead of cribbing, I will go and do something on my own..
I don’t boast of a library at my home, but we have huge collection of books and everyone in my house love reading.. we are health freak; regular visitors of health club and eat a very healthy diet..
I want to stop this thread as too much of “I” is making me feel small.. We should just discuss music here in place of world affairs; that I believe..
By deven on Apr 17, 2008 | Reply
Thanks for the link.. It’s useful information..
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 17, 2008 | Reply
only way a nation or a person can improve in health and education is to have self-introspection (self realisation) and then implement the good ones and REMOVE the bad ones through knowledge(self actualisation)(GET RID OF RELIGIOUS SUPERSTITIONS & PREJUDICES OR ANY IGNORANCE BY STRONG WILL).
i have been trying to rectify the IMC (indian medical council)FOR YEARS and even visited their office in newdelhi but failed to change them.THESE ARE IGNORANT DOCTORS WHO ARE HOLDING THE WHOLE INDIAN MEDICAL SYSTEM AT HOSTAGE AND KEEP THEIR SEATS.THEY SHOULD BE REMOVED COMPLETELY.THE MINISTRY OF HEALTH IS LIKE JOKERS AT WORK.
HEALTH & EDUCATION are the two main indexes of human developemnt. basic amenties as clean water,basic food and environmental cleanliness are absolutely essential to life.knowledge for NUTRITION AND FOOD PREPARATION ARE ABSOLUTELY necessary from school level to university level.
READING HABIT is absolutely necessary to be knowledgable.you can never be educated without it.TV IS the biggest distraction AND MAKES YOU STUPID.COMPUTER EDUCATION SHOULD BE PROMOTED.
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 18, 2008 | Reply
http://ocw.mit.edu/OcwWeb/web/home/home/index.htm
OPENWARE MIT IS GOOD SOURCE but THERE ARE MANY ELECTRONIC SOURCE SPECIALLY Carnegie Mellon Institute & STANFORD. DEPENDING on one’s interests. mayoclinic and john hopkins are specially good for medical reference.
By joy on Apr 18, 2008 | Reply
Dr.Biswas,Thank you very much for MIT link.I AM REALLY GRATEFUL.
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 19, 2008 | Reply
welcome
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 19, 2008 | Reply
LIFE EXPECTANCY
?
HEALTH?KNOWLEDGE? SUCCESS
?
WEALTH
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 19, 2008 | Reply
ARROWS WERE NOT RECOGNISED By the server life exp.,health, wealth and success> all are knowledge base.so the flow chart broke.
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 19, 2008 | Reply
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fea1OF7C91A
on the right side are anwesha golf green,calcutta and and recent episodes from personal video > thanks to RAJA from calcutta.
rest music LOVERS ENJOY!!anwesha duttagupta.
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 19, 2008 | Reply
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jr3JfNOcMCc&feature=related
this is an interview with JAYANTA SARKAR AND ANWESHA DUTTAGUPTA.
SPECIALLY TO DEVKISHANJI , DEAR FRIEND.
REST ENJOY!!
THANKS RAJA FROM CALCUTTA.
I WILL TRY TO CONTACT AGAIN.
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 19, 2008 | Reply
PLEASE SEE PART2 ……PART7 …..ON THE SIDE.
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 19, 2008 | Reply
TYPO:DEVKISHINJI
WITH BEST WISHES >SORRY THIS IS IN BENGALI ,YOU CAN ASK A FRIEND TO INTERPRET.
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 19, 2008 | Reply
http://video.aol.com/video-detail/anwesha-inerview-at-ne-bangla-on-april-122008-part-5/2220635959
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 19, 2008 | Reply
The only objective of this interviews are simply to ask those who are parents:
1. to nurture your kids for their talents.
2.promote health and education
3.combat ignorance.
when you will watch these video clips you will realize what a trmendous contributions take place from MOTHER,FATHER & TEACHER(GURU)for a child to grow his/her talent to a full bloom.
PROMOTE HEALTH SHOULD BE OUR GOAL IN LIFE WITH EDUCATION (2ND) AND KILLING IGNORANCE IS A MUST(3RD)SHOULD BE OUR MAIN DHARMA AND DUTY.
By DEVKISHIN VYAS on Apr 19, 2008 | Reply
i watched anwesha’s interview in kolkata studios. anwesha’s real talent was visible in song “lag ja gale___”,she was simply awesome. had she been given old melodius songs in chhote ustad show she would have probably bagged the title . the sound system/equipment in kolkata studios is of very high standard as the echo effect enhanced the beauty of the song. anwesha’s vocal chords are maturing with the age and she almost sounded like lata mangeshkar.
god bless her .
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 19, 2008 | Reply
devkishinji, one thing is very clear for both anwesha and aiswyaria that they both have good classical base and from this interview it was emphasized what you had once mentioned> then of course the whole selection of songs were just bizzare according to hindi films > just too confusing!!specially for us we never knew even who was who!we really thank their parents for their love and support.
thanks for your musical knowledge and contributions.
By DEVKISHIN VYAS on Apr 20, 2008 | Reply
doctor biswas i highly appreciate tour balanced and logical views. you were the only person on this blog who always maintained that the two finalists in chhote ustad show were equally talented and deserved to be the joint winners .i fully agree with you. the real talent was never tested in the programme. anwesha suffered more at the hands of the music direcrors as she was given rather ordinary numbers particularly at ahmedabad,a crucial penultimate episode.
anwesha proved herself that she was the best classical singer and this country needs such talents badly.if we have to revive our traditional music, based on ragaas, then anwesha is here to bring back the golden era of indian music.she is only hope in this age of senseless pop music.
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 20, 2008 | Reply
Thank you, devji >pop culture will bring drug culture and all the ills with it.we look up to India for beautiful musical culture if that is destroyed, except bollywood ,nothing will remain.
With these two talents: they are equally talented but aiswyaria’s stage free and oratory ability with emotional control is exemplary for 14yrs.i have given that credit to her on her blog.
What I can’t understand that why this musical show lags professionalism? The deficit shows on selection of songs, judges, elimination and grading etc.
With such huge expenses, why Gajji doesn’t make a musical institute, where talents could be trained for future. As much as I criticize this man, undoubtedly he has quality to organize musical shows in India. In many frustrations: IMC and Indian ministry of health both at the center and state level are big frustrations for me. HEALTH & MEDICAL EDUCATION are very close to my heart. Politics & nepotism are the biggest hindrance for medical admissions in India. Real talents are excluded and some mediocres are included, terrible frustration for me. In a simple example like this musical show, people argue senselessly about the talent of the two kids when they can see but don’t want to accept is a prejudice (ignorance).That’s why I say “killing ignorance is our dharma & duty”.
By DEVKISHIN VYAS on Apr 21, 2008 | Reply
excellent observations dr biswasji.
we come across so many ills in our society but we as individuals are quite helpless. some organisation should come forward and provide leadership to carry out the vital changes for better and bright tomorrow.
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 21, 2008 | Reply
HOW INDIAN SYSTEM WORKS:
http://www.cardiology.ucsf.edu/people/chatterjee.htm
http://www.calcuttaweb.com/nri/Kanu_Chatterjee.shtml
kanu-da, is much senior to us ,we graduated from same medical college in Calcutta: an inspiring role model in personal and professional life.
I have a list of 120 brilliant top most Indian doctors (UK, USA, CANADA) and 50 MBA who would like to contribute to Indian medical system could revolutionize the system to world class but Indian Ministry of health and IMC (Indian medical council) and state level politics are reluctant to accept them .Indian skin and corruption are so thick that my acidic comments and remarks they can digest with ease. NO SHAME, NO CONSCIENCE AND NO GUILT for deceiving a mass of humanity at ransom. They have created such a barricade that nothing at those levels could affect them. THESE ARE SCUM of low level intelligence guarding their positions.
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 21, 2008 | Reply
The thread was for: Vyasji.thanks
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 21, 2008 | Reply
http://cardiology.ucsf.edu/people/chatterjee.htm
By naim on Apr 21, 2008 | Reply
What do you think what is our limit? did you see if Amanat did not win yet again he got already work in bollywood. I agree aishwarya was better. but every one has his own point of view. so you better keep your mouth shut.
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on Apr 21, 2008 | Reply
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=anlP73PPyTM
how a child feels the fear of elimination!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0WB6DDvge3E&feature=related
see how she performs
By Deepanjan Datta on Apr 24, 2008 | Reply
Hi All,
What I must say that Both of them sing equally well!!! It may be true someway that judges tried their best to make Aishwariya win; but she also sings very well!!!
But anyway, through out the series Anwesha sang very well!! you have to realize it that everywhere in the world judges are biased….the judges are not the world’s bst judges…they made Aish win only because the final episode was in Gujarat…if it was in Bengal, there was no doubt of winning of Anwesha!!!
secondly I am replying this against Waqar!! You dont know any thing about singing!!!
thanks!!
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on May 2, 2008 | Reply
This for devkishinji,
what other news now in Mumbai for Musical show ?
i know you are keen for every musical show .please let us know if online anything available. pl keep well.
with regards
By DEVKISHIN VYAS on May 3, 2008 | Reply
DR BISWASJI,
NAMASTE. TRUST THIS POST FINDS YOU AND YOUR ENTIRE FAMILY IN PINK OF HEALTH.
WE DON’T HAVE ANWESHA AND AISHWARYA IN ANY OF THE PROGRAMMES AT PRESENT.
there is however one new musical show on star plus on fridays and saturdays at 10 p.m.-indian time. the winners and the runner-ups in various music reality shows are paticipating in this programme called”jo jeeta wohi super star” the prize money for the winner is rs. 50 lacs.the judges are music composers duo vishal-shekhar and choreographer cum director farah khan mother of triplets born to her recently.
this show is watchable but not in same class as chhote ustad.
i have requested star plus to create a new blog on net for this show.
the legend amitabh bachchan’s own blog—www.blogs.bigadda.com is on the net since17th april and on an average more than 500 comments are posted by the bloggers every day. amitabh bachchan himself is blogging on the site everyday and his sense of humour and extraordinary perception of various matters gives an insight into his great mind. he is indeed a man of letters .a dignity, honesty, integrity personified.
the man who came to mumbai a city of dreams,from kolkata ,settled here and became a legend.
a very interesting blog indeed.
there is a website riafashions.com(ria is my grand daughter)this site is being monitored by my daughter manju and grand daughter khushboo with inputs by deepak my son-in-law.you will find some well designed tunics on the site which we are getting stiched here and sending to my daughter in new jersey for sale.all clothes are moderately priced and are quite attractive.just have a look at india-made tunics.
my e-mail id –devkishinvyas@gmail.com
with regards,
devkishin,mumbai.
By Dr.akbiswas,USA on May 7, 2008 | Reply
thank you and god bless.
By Drakbiswas on Jun 4, 2008 | Reply
saregamapa :
one is aiswyaria :8yrsold
shreya 12+
song:khu khu
same judges.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WYMWITCSv4c
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A7Kx562j-dk&feature=related
enjoy.
By Drakbiswas on Jun 4, 2008 | Reply
correction
I made a mistake shreya must be 15-16yrs.
i was confused with shampa kundu.
By Drakbiswas on Jun 11, 2008 | Reply
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKbpMdWfJwo
watch this fantastic arabic performer.