Comments on: Star voice of India Videos – 7th November episod

By: Purvesh Khona

Purvesh Khona — Thu, 20 Nov 2008 07:48:47 +0000

Agreed!!! This is completely biased and bogus show. They are scheming people into sending SMS for Rs. 6/message and then don’t respect their views.

I think sukhvinder and ismail need to be kicked out along with their cronies Vipul and Mallar – let the competition be decided according to rules set forth, don’t change the rules based on whims of some idiots who think they are masters of music.

By: srikanth

srikanth — Tue, 18 Nov 2008 22:27:31 +0000

Hi, I love rithisha a lot and i have been seeing rithisha singing lot good and giving her best shot. Mr. Ismail know about singing. Ismail Darbar, i think as you are not getting any chances in Hindi films, you are not letting singers like Rithisha to come up and get her a chance. I think you should try bojpuri arena and let Saptaparna sing for you in all movies. I used to like you as a Judge in Saregamapa challenge, but you are very cunning as i came to know through VOI-2. Thanks a lot VOI. I think be a man enough to encourage good talent. Give roshini to nice talent and not to a roshini of yours.

By: Sanjay

Sanjay — Tue, 18 Nov 2008 18:35:33 +0000

Why Saptaparna? She is not good at all…

Plz save Ritisha otherwise judges have planned saptparna to win this competition.

Totally Biased show

By: shezan

shezan — Mon, 17 Nov 2008 11:08:24 +0000

well if singers like Atif Aslam can be a super star then people really don’t know anything about good or bad singing they just vote for the one they like…
Judges are doing exactly the thing that is needed…they are not favouring Vipul they are favouring the one who sings good…
for god’s sake man…ths is a show that is suppose to bring out talent not eliminate them…Ravi is teh weekest contestent in history of VOI…and i don’t he has got his lucky charm with him or sumthing….or may be its his love story in the show thats keeping him alive… Malhar, Vipul and Starparna do posses exceptional skills man..thats why they have been brought up… do you think that Ravi could be the one to represent INDIAN VOICE on international Platform…imagine RAVI performing int he world music festival representing India…as VOICE oF INDIA>..everyone is gonna Laugh their A$$E$$ off on that guy and Offcourse INdia that over a billion people and ths is wht they got to represent India..on other hand Vipul, Mallr or Saptaparna could atleast do justice with the indian voice..cuz on international level u don’t have to sing a sensational pop song with a twisted and besuri voice…u have to sing wht your country’s music is about your roots, your classical assets which these three contestents can do…thats all i gotta say…. Ravi is just another singer, not THE SINGER… Ritisha was very good in the biggining god knows wht happened to her…. however if people were really to be brought in one contestent desearved it alot too…that was the girl from Jharkand i guess the one who sang Hale Dil in the biggining….

By: atlgirl

atlgirl — Thu, 13 Nov 2008 07:00:20 +0000

i jus have to say…that i will officially stop watchin the show and stop voting today as zakir was thrown out of the competition…n that tooo while he was standin in competition with Ravi..that is simply bullshit…ravi is the worst singer ever…and throwing zakr out n keeping ravi was jus crazy..i have lost my interest in the show…dont worry zakir u will always be the star of that show…those judges have no clue what they have lost…i hope ravi is kicked off next..he doesnt deserve to be still there.

By: Voice of India Watcher

Voice of India Watcher — Wed, 12 Nov 2008 23:24:36 +0000

I think after the death of Dear Ismeet, Vipul has never grown himself out of the shock of his demise. He seems to be burdened by the passing away of Ismeet and thinks he can replace him by bringing people from his place who jump from their seats if he looses his point in the reality show. It does look that they are going to pull their daggers out if Vipul is not made to win. Honestly, there is no real talent left in the current contenders. Ryan was the rock of the stage and attracted the people all over the world but through close politics of the contenders he was out. Has any body thought about the Mohd Rafi of the VOI Dear Zakir Hussain. He sang with his heart and was a real singer, but the close politics of the stage singers, none of them ever said that he is good. I think it is a matter of picking the best from the worst left over. Ismail Durbar should be more authoratative and the judges should not be intimidated and should be fair as afterall if they do not have brains, the Indian public do have. They are puppets in the hands of Vipul and a bunch of his Red Hot crowd from his native place.

By: ancer

ancer — Tue, 11 Nov 2008 19:46:52 +0000

Its ver very sad to note that living in this world were racism still exit, vipul singing is like donkey barking in the street still the judges encourag him, were as sapthaparna is also the same, judges are not to meant tosit on they chair, when they cant decide, who are there to select , why cant they live to the public,to decide, its very sad to see zakir elimantion though he was the best among the 6

By: shivmurthy

shivmurthy — Mon, 10 Nov 2008 11:23:50 +0000

Two times re-entry means what? VOI don’t have faith on voters? one of the episode Ismail said “VOI rikshawala aur zhaduwala banathe hai, koee TATA Birla nahin” Now, TATA and Birla made something to judges. Even today I am seeing “Chote Ustad” in net. What a great judges they were? Now….che…

By: shayama

shayama — Sun, 09 Nov 2008 20:26:39 +0000

I am a viewer from Canada (I ensure that I am home for 7pm every Friday & Saturday night when those shows are aired here)of both SA RE GA MA PA & VOI and it is clear that VOI is being manipulated.

Are the Judges /directors puppets on a string and dancing to someone else’s song.

I agree to the judges calling on the public to vote for the singers who have so much promise without being partial to any one in particular. There are others who have been voted off who viewers feel should still be there but that is the nature of the program. They should have waited for the new programm to introduce new rules…e.g… voters account for half of the marks and the judges, the other half…that way the judges would have their input.

The Judges should encourage all the singers and as a matter of fact should help with the song selection as some of them whilst nice are poor choices for a competition of such grandeur.

At the onset, the rules are clear… the participants are voted to stay in the programme by the viewers and of course the judges give their feedback( in some instances, I’m sure that the judges’ comments influence viewers voting).

It is outrageous that Monty et al would vote to call back Vipul, Mallar & Zakir (I like all three of them and I think that they are excellent singers) however, the format of the show is that the decision is made by the voting public.

They last three standing before the call back are now in the bottom three…. All three of them should graciously walk off the sets and let the judges and the directors of the show have the showdown between Mallar & Vipul.

By the way was Vipul in one those shows last year & was voted off early as well (I may be wrong here, please correct me.

I am very disappointed by the way it is being done.

Last year’s VOI ended with Ishmeet winning (may his soul rest in peace & may his family always be consloed that their son/brother won the hearts of many of us who feel that we actually knew him personally…I simply loved him, he made me cry so many times as did many of the other participants,…I think he was superb even though it was felt that Harshit was the winner … it was accepted that Ishmeet won by the amount of votes he received from his stronghold of Punjab…. no big thing, the two finalists were top of the class singers but neither were voted off and recalled to take someone else’s win.

I expect to see a much wiser choice of songs for the remaining of the program and if Vipul & Mallar are the two finalists I know a lot of the Canadians would certainly not be tuning in to the program.

It is not my intention to offend anyone( viewers, participants, judges, directors/staff) and I humbly apologize in advance if anyone is indeed offended.

A good day to all.

By: SSG

SSG — Sun, 09 Nov 2008 05:32:30 +0000

Sukvindar is downgrading out Ritisha when she is probably the best singer. If this is a North-South rift issue, he should not forget that his first and probably biggest song was in a movie whose producer and music director are both South Indians.

Have you guys observed how silent and withdrawn the poor girl has become? No encouragement from the judges. Ismail Durbar has a couple of half hearted attempts at times but hardly